iVOD / 170882

本逐字稿內容由 AI 自動生成,可能包含錯誤、遺漏或誤譯之處。請使用者務必與原始影片音訊內容交叉比對,以確保資訊正確性。另可參考立法院日後釋出的正式公報以取得最終權威版本。

呂玉玲 @ 第11屆第5會期經濟委員會第25次全體委員會議

Start Time End Time Text
00:00:00,000 00:00:02,600 而換請呂玉琳委員執行
00:00:14,880 00:00:16,000 謝謝主席
00:00:16,640 00:00:19,080 我們請經濟部的公部長
00:00:19,240 00:00:21,680 食藥署的江署長
00:00:22,040 00:00:23,600 台唐的蔡副總
00:00:24,960 00:00:27,960 好 請部長署長跟陸董
00:00:28,960 00:00:30,400 張委長官
00:00:30,920 00:00:33,520 食品的安全沒有太嚴格
00:00:33,520 00:00:35,040 是一定要嚴格
00:00:35,040 00:00:37,040 也絕對不能打折扣
00:00:37,320 00:00:40,160 這是人民吃下去的東西
00:00:40,160 00:00:43,240 他們的生命的健康的安全性
00:00:43,240 00:00:46,040 所以我們要重演審慎
00:00:46,040 00:00:49,360 來制定我們的制度跟法律跟規定
00:00:49,360 00:00:53,080 這才是我們今天開這場會議
00:00:53,080 00:00:54,680 最重要的精神
00:00:55,680 00:00:59,600 食品安全是我們民眾最基本
00:00:59,600 00:01:01,680 也是最卑微的一個請求
00:01:01,680 00:01:03,680 大家在市場裡面
00:01:03,680 00:01:05,160 或者是在超市裡面
00:01:05,160 00:01:06,440 買回去的東西
00:01:06,440 00:01:07,720 我們要求的
00:01:07,720 00:01:10,680 就是要給家人吃得安心
00:01:10,680 00:01:12,480 所以中年這一次
00:01:12,480 00:01:15,440 爆發油料毒油的問題
00:01:15,440 00:01:17,600 扁平皮的或超標的問題
00:01:17,600 00:01:19,360 再次的重創國人
00:01:19,360 00:01:21,840 對食品安全的信任
00:01:22,080 00:01:23,280 尤其是在中年
00:01:23,280 00:01:26,520 作為原料油的廠商
00:01:27,160 00:01:29,280 他把生產的油品
00:01:29,280 00:01:31,440 分別供應給下游廠商
00:01:31,440 00:01:33,760 包括泰山福壽
00:01:33,760 00:01:34,880 還有福茂等
00:01:34,880 00:01:36,360 知名的加工廠
00:01:36,360 00:01:40,320 再經由餐廳到通路
00:01:40,320 00:01:43,960 到我們的零售業販賣給我們消費者
00:01:43,960 00:01:46,760 這個油品影響是越來越大
00:01:46,760 00:01:48,040 被擴大了
00:01:48,040 00:01:50,400 隨著我們衛福部的食藥署
00:01:50,480 00:01:52,800 全面在清查中
00:01:52,800 00:01:56,080 中年四月份到六月份生產的油品
00:01:56,080 00:01:58,240 最終得到確認的
00:01:58,240 00:02:02,680 就有七批的油品有問題
00:02:02,680 00:02:05,360 這七批的油品都不符合規定
00:02:05,360 00:02:07,480 所以食藥署也趕快的
00:02:07,480 00:02:09,840 要他們下架回收
00:02:09,840 00:02:11,320 原來大家以為這個事情
00:02:11,320 00:02:12,640 已經告一個段落了
00:02:12,640 00:02:15,240 但是在台中地檢署
00:02:15,240 00:02:18,920 追究整體事件的刑事責任的時候
00:02:18,920 00:02:20,120 發現了
00:02:20,200 00:02:23,440 原來早在五月十五日的時候
00:02:24,440 00:02:28,840 台糖在採購中年的製造
00:02:28,840 00:02:31,760 福茂供應的油品原料的時候
00:02:31,760 00:02:35,480 就發生了扁平坪的超標的問題
00:02:35,480 00:02:37,440 而且這一批的原油扁平坪
00:02:37,440 00:02:41,960 已經超標到14ppb
00:02:41,960 00:02:44,000 我們的規定是2ppb
00:02:44,000 00:02:45,600 對不對食藥署
00:02:45,600 00:02:46,920 所以超高這麼多
00:02:46,920 00:02:49,400 當然台糖會舉手
00:02:49,400 00:02:52,600 管的是管已經可以吃的油
00:02:52,600 00:02:54,560 中間製造大豆
00:02:54,560 00:02:55,640 製造壓出來的
00:02:55,640 00:02:57,000 你不用再跟我講這個
00:02:57,000 00:02:59,560 我想的問題你有沒有聽懂
00:02:59,560 00:03:01,280 它有超標是不是
00:03:01,280 00:03:03,600 當然有14,18都有
00:03:03,600 00:03:06,560 但是我們訂的規定是不是2ppb
00:03:06,560 00:03:08,600 我們沒有訂脫膠原油的部分
00:03:08,600 00:03:10,240 你回答我對不對
00:03:10,240 00:03:11,480 我們沒有訂脫膠原油的部分
00:03:11,480 00:03:13,160 前面的解釋我都聽過了
00:03:13,160 00:03:14,080 我現在跟你
00:03:14,080 00:03:16,480 原油一條一條列給你知道
00:03:16,480 00:03:17,800 你們的錯誤在哪裡
00:03:17,840 00:03:20,720 你們要改進要修正的法在哪裡
00:03:20,720 00:03:23,240 所以我問你2ppb對不對
00:03:23,240 00:03:25,000 2ppb是我們食品的
00:03:25,000 00:03:26,400 可以吃的油
00:03:26,400 00:03:27,960 脫膠原油是不能吃的
00:03:27,960 00:03:32,280 好所以沒有依照食品管理的
00:03:32,280 00:03:36,440 法規面的第七條第五項的規定
00:03:36,440 00:03:40,120 向地方衛生主管機關來通報
00:03:40,120 00:03:43,440 所以我想請問的就是說
00:03:43,440 00:03:45,640 在發生有移力的時候
00:03:45,679 00:03:47,040 公營單位
00:03:47,040 00:03:48,959 台糖你是公營
00:03:48,959 00:03:50,160 你不是民營
00:03:50,160 00:03:51,600 有這些問題的時候
00:03:51,600 00:03:53,600 你就要橫向溝通
00:03:53,600 00:03:55,519 不管是我們食藥署衛福部
00:03:55,519 00:03:56,640 還是經濟部
00:03:56,640 00:03:58,679 你都要去了解
00:03:58,679 00:04:00,880 你都要告訴他們有這種問題
00:04:00,880 00:04:02,799 因為你剛剛提到的是說
00:04:02,799 00:04:05,119 如果說有扁平皮
00:04:05,119 00:04:06,239 超標的部分
00:04:06,239 00:04:08,079 在製造過程
00:04:08,079 00:04:09,560 他可以把它拿掉
00:04:09,560 00:04:12,560 那這個製造過程要被知道
00:04:12,560 00:04:15,119 被告知去執行去做
00:04:15,120 00:04:16,680 才能夠被拿掉
00:04:16,680 00:04:18,040 所以你沒有通報
00:04:18,040 00:04:20,120 他沒有辦法在製造過程中
00:04:20,120 00:04:21,560 加了哪些程序
00:04:21,560 00:04:23,720 去把這個扁平皮的成分
00:04:23,720 00:04:24,960 降低再降低
00:04:24,960 00:04:27,160 到安全的PPP
00:04:27,160 00:04:28,080 對不對
00:04:28,080 00:04:30,760 所以請問一下台糖
00:04:30,760 00:04:32,200 副總
00:04:32,200 00:04:34,280 台糖曾經發生過
00:04:34,280 00:04:37,640 有扁平皮的超標的問題嗎
00:04:37,640 00:04:39,480 這麼久以來有發生過嗎
00:04:39,480 00:04:42,120 我們只能說我們所採購的
00:04:42,120 00:04:43,200 都沒有是不是
00:04:43,240 00:04:45,280 所採購的原料油
00:04:45,280 00:04:47,000 出油
00:04:47,000 00:04:50,560 是按照我們的超標的規範來做驗收
00:04:50,560 00:04:51,560 有沒有發生過
00:04:51,560 00:04:53,080 告訴他們發生過
00:04:53,080 00:04:53,760 沒有
00:04:53,760 00:04:55,560 沒有發生過
00:04:55,560 00:04:57,280 這是首次第一次發生
00:04:57,280 00:04:57,920 對不對
00:04:57,920 00:04:58,320
00:04:58,320 00:05:00,000 這是這麼嚴重的事情
00:05:00,000 00:05:01,880 首次第一次發生
00:05:01,880 00:05:03,360 那你為什麼
00:05:03,360 00:05:05,719 沒有盡你的義務責任
00:05:05,719 00:05:07,760 台糖
00:05:07,760 00:05:09,440 你台糖是公營
00:05:09,440 00:05:10,919 你應該通報給
00:05:10,960 00:05:13,560 橫向的所屬相關單位
00:05:13,560 00:05:14,480 大家知道
00:05:14,480 00:05:15,800 要合作的警惕
00:05:15,800 00:05:16,720 應該是這麼說
00:05:16,720 00:05:17,400 就是說
00:05:17,400 00:05:18,560 其他的廠商
00:05:18,560 00:05:20,360 如果說他也要用出油
00:05:20,360 00:05:22,520 去精煉成沙拉油的話
00:05:22,520 00:05:23,800 他應該在採購的時候
00:05:23,800 00:05:24,840 他們要去驗
00:05:24,840 00:05:26,360 不是台南公司去幫他們驗
00:05:26,360 00:05:26,840 或者是告訴他們
00:05:26,840 00:05:28,200 沒有叫你驗
00:05:28,200 00:05:29,440 互相通報
00:05:29,440 00:05:30,520 大家注意
00:05:30,520 00:05:31,800 有吃批貨
00:05:31,800 00:05:33,520 大家要注意
00:05:33,520 00:05:35,040 這個責任沒有嗎
00:05:35,040 00:05:36,080 我強調
00:05:36,080 00:05:37,120 你是公營
00:05:37,120 00:05:39,440 所以這麼嚴重的情形之下
00:05:39,480 00:05:41,280 你沒有通報
00:05:41,280 00:05:42,920 就是讓我們的原料
00:05:42,920 00:05:43,760 有問題的
00:05:43,760 00:05:44,520 不用通報
00:05:44,520 00:05:45,840 變成產品
00:05:45,840 00:05:47,360 會變成產品
00:05:47,360 00:05:49,200 原料沒有通報
00:05:49,200 00:05:50,560 就會變成產品
00:05:50,560 00:05:52,040 所以報告
00:05:52,040 00:05:54,840 沒有所謂的原料有問題
00:05:54,840 00:05:55,600 他只是說
00:05:55,600 00:05:57,680 他不符合台南公司採購的規範
00:05:57,680 00:05:58,360 沒有問題
00:05:58,360 00:05:59,600 你為什麼退貨
00:05:59,600 00:06:00,680 為什麼要換貨
00:06:00,680 00:06:02,600 他沒有符合台南公司的驗收
00:06:02,600 00:06:03,720 對嘛
00:06:03,720 00:06:04,760 就是有問題
00:06:04,760 00:06:06,440 你才要退貨換貨
00:06:06,440 00:06:08,080 那個不符合規定
00:06:08,120 00:06:10,520 副總你不要再狡辯了
00:06:10,520 00:06:12,320 你不要再狡辯了
00:06:12,320 00:06:14,120 所以你為什麼
00:06:14,120 00:06:15,240 我剛剛告訴你
00:06:15,240 00:06:17,159 你有通報的責任
00:06:17,159 00:06:19,039 是依據
00:06:19,039 00:06:21,120 我們經濟部
00:06:21,120 00:06:24,200 依據經濟部所屬事業
00:06:24,200 00:06:27,599 各類災害及緊急事件
00:06:27,599 00:06:29,080 速報程序
00:06:29,080 00:06:31,000 第三條第二款
00:06:31,000 00:06:32,919 第五目的規定
00:06:32,919 00:06:34,599 重大事件
00:06:34,599 00:06:37,440 若是影響到事業的形象
00:06:37,440 00:06:40,520 或者是影響到相關產業上
00:06:40,520 00:06:42,560 上下游事業
00:06:42,560 00:06:43,320 供需
00:06:43,320 00:06:44,480 或者民生
00:06:44,480 00:06:45,560 國營事業
00:06:45,560 00:06:48,680 就應該向經濟部通報
00:06:48,680 00:06:49,800 有沒有這個法
00:06:49,800 00:06:50,400 公部長
00:06:50,400 00:06:52,400 有沒有這個法
00:06:52,400 00:06:53,360 我這邊強調
00:06:53,360 00:06:54,560 國營事業
00:06:54,560 00:06:57,120 應向經濟部通報
00:06:57,120 00:06:58,680 有沒有
00:06:58,680 00:07:00,120 還有狡辯
00:07:00,120 00:07:02,040 不是啊
00:07:02,040 00:07:04,159 這是紙安法跟招訪法的規定
00:07:04,159 00:07:04,880
00:07:04,880 00:07:06,120 那是產業
00:07:06,120 00:07:07,040 事業
00:07:07,040 00:07:08,600 台長是不是個事業
00:07:08,600 00:07:10,520 對 但是跟食品安全法
00:07:10,520 00:07:12,240 應該就不太一樣
00:07:12,240 00:07:13,040 產品
00:07:13,040 00:07:14,000 事業
00:07:14,000 00:07:14,840 所以
00:07:14,840 00:07:17,160 食品安全還是要回歸到食品安全
00:07:17,160 00:07:17,920 公部長
00:07:17,920 00:07:18,640 食品安全
00:07:18,640 00:07:20,680 你們一槍就脫了食品安全
00:07:20,680 00:07:22,160 產業公司
00:07:22,160 00:07:23,360 經營製造
00:07:23,360 00:07:24,640 產品
00:07:24,640 00:07:25,360 出來
00:07:25,360 00:07:27,520 我們吃下去肚子的健康
00:07:27,520 00:07:28,880 這是一年慣的
00:07:28,880 00:07:30,280 一個產業鏈的
00:07:30,280 00:07:31,760 統統要關心
00:07:31,760 00:07:32,800 所以
00:07:32,800 00:07:35,360 在2024年的時候
00:07:35,360 00:07:36,840 蘇丹紅十
00:07:36,880 00:07:38,880 食安事件發生的時候
00:07:38,880 00:07:41,440 他們用蘇丹紅添加了
00:07:41,440 00:07:43,000 在辣椒粉裡面
00:07:43,000 00:07:45,400 辣椒粉的色澤看起來比較好看
00:07:45,400 00:07:47,200 在衛福部
00:07:47,200 00:07:48,400 食藥署
00:07:48,400 00:07:52,799 你們在2024年的3月11號的新聞
00:07:52,799 00:07:54,719 這個新聞稿當中
00:07:54,719 00:07:56,000 特別強調
00:07:56,000 00:07:57,719 食品業者
00:07:57,719 00:07:59,919 如果發現原料
00:07:59,919 00:08:01,359 和產品
00:08:01,359 00:08:03,000 有危害
00:08:03,000 00:08:04,840 衛生安全之虞
00:08:04,880 00:08:07,159 請主動停止製造
00:08:07,159 00:08:10,359 加工販賣及辦理回收
00:08:10,359 00:08:14,280 並通報直轄市縣市的主管機關
00:08:14,280 00:08:15,520 白紙黑字
00:08:15,520 00:08:16,719 寫在這邊
00:08:16,719 00:08:18,320 原料有問題
00:08:18,320 00:08:19,960 你們就必須要
00:08:19,960 00:08:21,960 將所有的主管機關
00:08:21,960 00:08:23,200 所有的範圍
00:08:23,200 00:08:25,120 統統都要通報
00:08:25,120 00:08:26,359 這個你們的
00:08:26,359 00:08:27,479 去年
00:08:27,479 00:08:29,559 2024年3月11號
00:08:29,559 00:08:30,599 你們新聞稿
00:08:30,599 00:08:31,880 白紙黑字就寫出來了
00:08:31,880 00:08:32,559 謝謝委員的
00:08:32,559 00:08:33,120 是不是
00:08:33,120 00:08:34,400 謝謝委員的指導
00:08:34,439 00:08:35,039 因為
00:08:35,039 00:08:36,319 蘇丹紅
00:08:36,319 00:08:37,439 跟扁平坯
00:08:37,439 00:08:38,720 都有化學結構
00:08:38,720 00:08:39,600 一個呢
00:08:39,600 00:08:40,400
00:08:40,400 00:08:40,919
00:08:40,919 00:08:42,039 不得添加的
00:08:42,039 00:08:43,400 一個是在製程裡面
00:08:43,400 00:08:45,319 本來就會有的
00:08:45,319 00:08:46,760 這兩個是不一樣的
00:08:46,760 00:08:47,880 不一樣
00:08:47,880 00:08:48,560 署長
00:08:48,560 00:08:49,920 剛剛不講的
00:08:49,920 00:08:51,319 一個是添加的
00:08:51,319 00:08:53,240 一個製造過程中可以拿掉
00:08:53,240 00:08:54,000 所以我說
00:08:54,000 00:08:55,199 你及早通報
00:08:55,199 00:08:57,640 如果說中年4月份發生
00:08:57,640 00:08:58,720 到6月30號
00:08:58,720 00:08:59,840 你及早通報
00:08:59,840 00:09:01,439 我們及早把中西
00:09:01,439 00:09:04,000 組合在原料
00:09:04,000 00:09:05,000 出產的地方
00:09:05,000 00:09:06,800 不要跑到下游去的話
00:09:06,800 00:09:07,600 我們人民
00:09:07,600 00:09:09,480 是不會遲到了
00:09:09,480 00:09:11,720 你通報一下會怎麼樣呢
00:09:11,720 00:09:12,760 所以這些
00:09:12,760 00:09:13,720 我這樣
00:09:13,720 00:09:15,160 全部這樣講下來
00:09:15,160 00:09:16,640 就是要讓你們了解
00:09:16,640 00:09:17,880 不是沒有法
00:09:17,880 00:09:18,920 不是沒有規定
00:09:18,920 00:09:20,480 不是沒有制度
00:09:20,480 00:09:22,040 都有讓你們知醒
00:09:22,040 00:09:23,240 是你們要不要
00:09:23,240 00:09:24,320 橫向溝通
00:09:24,320 00:09:25,440 互相通報
00:09:25,440 00:09:26,760 尤其是公營
00:09:26,760 00:09:28,440 法規面經濟部都公
00:09:28,440 00:09:29,480 國營事業
00:09:29,480 00:09:31,200 就要有通報的責任
00:09:31,200 00:09:32,560 安全
00:09:32,560 00:09:33,320 所以
00:09:33,320 00:09:34,360 你現在
00:09:34,360 00:09:35,840 我們行政院
00:09:35,840 00:09:37,240 7月份也送出了
00:09:37,240 00:09:38,600 這個版本出來了
00:09:38,600 00:09:39,520 就針對於
00:09:39,520 00:09:41,200 我們食安的這個漏洞
00:09:41,200 00:09:42,520 要把補好的修法
00:09:42,520 00:09:44,000 把補好的這個漏洞
00:09:44,000 00:09:45,520 已經送進來了
00:09:45,520 00:09:46,640 所以我們希望
00:09:46,640 00:09:48,720 大家要好好的
00:09:48,720 00:09:51,120 把食安健康這個問題
00:09:51,120 00:09:52,360 好好的來討論
00:09:52,360 00:09:53,680 看看怎麼樣的制度
00:09:53,680 00:09:54,720 能夠保障
00:09:54,720 00:09:55,880 我們國人的健康
00:09:55,880 00:09:57,000 這才是真正的
00:09:57,000 00:09:58,200 不要再推責任
00:09:58,200 00:10:00,600 互相一定要把這個責任
00:10:00,600 00:10:01,760 這個整個建構好來
00:10:01,760 00:10:03,240 尤其是公部長
00:10:03,280 00:10:05,640 經濟部包括是產業
00:10:05,640 00:10:07,160 不要一直推給食藥署
00:10:07,160 00:10:09,480 大家橫向溝通
00:10:09,480 00:10:10,920 把這事情做好來
00:10:10,920 00:10:12,680 把這個制度健全起來
00:10:12,680 00:10:13,760 好不好
00:10:13,760 00:10:14,760 謝謝