iVOD / 170591

本逐字稿內容由 AI 自動生成,可能包含錯誤、遺漏或誤譯之處。請使用者務必與原始影片音訊內容交叉比對,以確保資訊正確性。另可參考立法院日後釋出的正式公報以取得最終權威版本。

謝龍介 @ 第11屆第5會期外交及國防委員會第27次全體委員會議

Start Time End Time Text
00:00:00,960 00:00:01,760 我要搶保釣
00:00:03,340 00:00:03,980 請顧伯掌
00:00:04,910 00:00:05,410 請顧掌
00:00:06,060 00:00:06,560 剛剛
00:00:06,560 00:00:08,059 市中心委員
00:00:10,120 00:00:11,120 用心良苦
00:00:12,550 00:00:13,750 你們國安部
00:00:15,080 00:00:16,680 沒有所謂的買方市場
00:00:16,680 00:00:17,880 因為長期以來
00:00:17,880 00:00:19,580 軍事採購你們都把成
00:00:19,580 00:00:22,080 把我們任何採購都變成賣方市場
00:00:23,390 00:00:25,390 我們再有優勢也沒有用
00:00:26,610 00:00:27,610 這真可惜
00:00:28,450 00:00:30,450 他剛才說的LOC的概念很好
00:00:31,600 00:00:32,100
00:00:32,520 00:00:33,160 當然
00:00:33,160 00:00:34,120 出了後
00:00:34,120 00:00:35,720 國安部是收割人
00:00:35,720 00:00:36,820 啊拼離約
00:00:36,820 00:00:38,820 國安部就不用去當壞人
00:00:40,080 00:00:41,699 又А
00:00:42,000 00:00:45,800 我請教你,在這個委員會的過程中,你今天要報告
00:00:47,650 00:00:49,650 那針對這個
00:00:50,960 00:00:52,960 RTX這個案件
00:00:53,740 00:00:55,740 我上次問你的時候
00:00:55,740 00:00:57,740 我說本來要請
00:00:57,740 00:00:59,740 周圍,帶我們來印度
00:00:59,740 00:01:01,740 對不對,場刊啊
00:01:02,760 00:01:04,759
00:01:04,459 00:01:06,460 啊結果這件,現在怎樣
00:01:06,740 00:01:08,740 刈標後進行怎樣
00:01:09,520 00:01:12,520 跟委員報告,現在這個案子,福邁公司
00:01:12,520 00:01:14,520 他規定沒有按照契約
00:01:14,520 00:01:17,520 180日日曆天取得輸出許可
00:01:18,770 00:01:20,770 再期待
00:01:20,770 00:01:22,770 你那時候說我
00:01:22,770 00:01:24,770 沒有沒有,合約
00:01:24,770 00:01:26,770 合約都是要180天之後取得
00:01:26,770 00:01:28,770 才會往下走
00:01:28,770 00:01:30,770 你那時候說他可以取得
00:01:30,770 00:01:32,770 所以我不敢說,我們來印度看
00:01:32,770 00:01:34,770 場刊
00:01:36,020 00:01:38,020
00:01:38,110 00:01:40,110 這樣就上去六個月前,這就是那一件
00:01:41,110 00:01:43,110 這件沒辦法嘛
00:01:42,780 00:01:44,780 這不怪嘛,這做總統的
00:01:46,610 00:01:48,610 這中宏耶
00:01:48,660 00:01:50,660 台灣大陸,我去探聽多少人,還探聽到
00:01:53,010 00:01:55,010 現在確定不行喔
00:01:55,030 00:01:59,030 他在七月初,他就超過36天,解獄
00:01:59,030 00:02:01,030 發四千幾萬
00:02:01,030 00:02:03,030 啊解獄後
00:02:03,030 00:02:05,030 目前就在當地上岸
00:02:05,030 00:02:07,030 要發四千幾萬,他沒錢
00:02:07,030 00:02:09,030 但是他押標金多少
00:02:09,449 00:02:11,450 押標金
00:02:12,890 00:02:14,890 兩千五萬的款
00:02:14,890 00:02:16,890 差不多,因為我這裡住了,我沒寫
00:02:16,890 00:02:18,890 剛才兩千多,這樣放著
00:02:18,890 00:02:20,890 兩千多萬的押標金
00:02:20,890 00:02:22,890 不良廠商,給他停權
00:02:23,110 00:02:25,110 停權喔
00:02:25,110 00:02:27,110 他們就自分一組組
00:02:27,110 00:02:29,110 一人公司,準備四五十金
00:02:29,110 00:02:31,110 要給你用
00:02:31,500 00:02:33,500 所以你可以再出四五十個標案
00:02:33,500 00:02:35,500 他都能吃得下耶
00:02:38,990 00:02:40,990 這實在是真的有夠離譜
00:02:40,990 00:02:42,990 你敢知道
00:02:42,990 00:02:44,990 你當時跟我們講,很緊張耶
00:02:44,990 00:02:46,990 如果不趕快採購啊
00:02:46,990 00:02:48,990 這對我們這個
00:02:48,990 00:02:50,990 建軍啊,備案啊
00:02:52,260 00:02:54,260 會很影響耶
00:02:54,260 00:02:56,260 對我們的戰力
00:02:56,260 00:02:58,260 嚴重下降
00:02:58,260 00:03:00,260 譬如說,我都
00:03:00,260 00:03:02,260 對你們的武神都支持
00:03:01,740 00:03:03,740 你看我這樣,真心換很多
00:03:05,270 00:03:07,270 我對你們這麼要小心
00:03:07,230 00:03:09,230 你怎麼給我放工
00:03:09,520 00:03:13,520 我今天叫國民黨這裡的國防委員會委員都給我請
00:03:13,980 00:03:15,980 你都說不能看
00:03:16,050 00:03:18,050 武神不要抬
00:03:18,350 00:03:20,350 他還在那邊看,他怎麼這樣
00:03:20,960 00:03:22,960 跟你說三名,現在跟你說三名
00:03:22,960 00:03:24,960 不好意思,一定要學會,不好意思
00:03:24,960 00:03:26,960 沒辦法
00:03:28,070 00:03:30,070 我電話內面啊
00:03:30,460 00:03:32,460 沒辦法
00:03:31,930 00:03:33,930 我想
00:03:33,750 00:03:35,750 委員關切這個案子
00:03:35,750 00:03:37,750 那來源輸出國
00:03:37,750 00:03:39,750 一旦曝光的話
00:03:39,750 00:03:41,750 就我看法政治上的壓力
00:03:41,750 00:03:43,750 是會形成啦
00:03:43,750 00:03:45,750 但是無論如何
00:03:46,540 00:03:48,540 這個沒有按照企業來提供
00:03:48,540 00:03:50,540 部長,當時該保密的
00:03:50,540 00:03:52,540 我們都讓你保密喔
00:03:52,540 00:03:54,540 是可以公開的,是你們國防部選擇
00:03:54,540 00:03:56,540 可以公開的部分才公開喔
00:03:56,540 00:03:58,540 是,那我想我們就是
00:03:58,540 00:04:00,540 預約來累計這個
00:04:00,540 00:04:02,540 相關的這個沒收理約保證金
00:04:02,540 00:04:04,540 跟罰款的一個
00:04:04,540 00:04:06,540 一個作用
00:04:06,540 00:04:08,540 罰款敢不敢對方通知啊
00:04:09,020 00:04:11,020
00:04:10,290 00:04:12,290 這個是按照目前
00:04:12,290 00:04:14,290 我們會報到我們國防採購市
00:04:14,290 00:04:16,289 國防採購市就會一合一
00:04:16,289 00:04:18,289 馬上就很快
00:04:18,289 00:04:20,289 會脫散啊
00:04:20,070 00:04:22,070 他個人現在也沒出什麼來
00:04:24,920 00:04:26,920 用合成啊
00:04:26,920 00:04:28,920 好啦,你建議啊
00:04:28,920 00:04:30,920 你要去看看當時那個
00:04:30,920 00:04:32,920 壓標金是誰專給他的啊
00:04:34,650 00:04:36,650 好,我再請教你一個問題喔
00:04:36,880 00:04:38,880 法務部有沒有單位向你們調這個案子
00:04:38,880 00:04:40,880 還有那個
00:04:41,710 00:04:43,710 呃,消極瓜那個案子的資料
00:04:45,780 00:04:47,780 法務部來查明了
00:04:47,780 00:04:49,780 監察院也都來看了
00:04:49,780 00:04:51,780 我們基本上整個我們的採購的
00:04:51,780 00:04:53,780 流程基本上回覆是
00:04:53,780 00:04:55,780 沒有什麼其他的
00:04:55,780 00:04:57,780 流程不會有問題啦
00:04:57,780 00:04:59,780 台南台南地檢署也來調過了
00:04:59,780 00:05:01,780 我們依合約,依規定都等
00:05:01,780 00:05:03,780 為什麼要調
00:05:03,780 00:05:05,780 我現在就是
00:05:05,820 00:05:07,820 我要打個bug
00:05:09,030 00:05:11,030 為什麼不拿出
00:05:10,970 00:05:12,970 他的來源證明
00:05:14,410 00:05:16,410 因為人在查
00:05:17,420 00:05:19,420 這條錢,這塊肉吃不下去啊
00:05:22,280 00:05:24,280 快點辦公
00:05:26,340 00:05:28,340 各位鄉親們
00:05:27,960 00:05:29,960 你看我們的
00:05:29,960 00:05:31,960 見證案這麼嚴肅
00:05:31,960 00:05:33,960 我這樣一路給他們雞吃無雙
00:05:34,540 00:05:36,540 這媽的草
00:05:37,650 00:05:39,650 我這樣查,台南也有調問
00:05:42,020 00:05:44,020 查明了,因為這個案子
00:05:44,020 00:05:46,020 這個案子繼續走下去
00:05:46,020 00:05:48,020 成交了
00:05:48,530 00:05:50,530 阿伯來臨了,比較大隻
00:05:51,120 00:05:53,120 大伯就抓到了
00:05:54,070 00:05:56,070 所以這個斷尾求生
00:05:56,940 00:05:58,940 現在緊張了,等現在的事
00:05:58,940 00:06:00,940 阿伯,別扛
00:06:00,940 00:06:02,940 見證證就當Honky
00:06:03,790 00:06:05,790 這樣吃虧,變成我們柴港單位
00:06:10,420 00:06:12,420 阿伯,別生氣,我不生氣
00:06:12,780 00:06:14,780 你算他天啊
00:06:14,810 00:06:18,810 拜託他可以顧其他的財國國王軍購預算啊
00:06:18,810 00:06:20,810 幫忙一下
00:06:21,420 00:06:23,420 阿伯,我如果不讓你簽就幫你啊
00:06:24,920 00:06:26,920
00:06:26,740 00:06:28,740 阿伯,你要擲兩招讓我們屁股痛
00:06:34,150 00:06:36,150 我覺得這實在是十點不夠意思
00:06:37,470 00:06:41,470 他把你台南這裡的案件,台南地檢署都把你調整了,你知不知道
00:06:43,140 00:06:45,140 調幾個案件的資料
00:06:47,140 00:06:51,140 這不是機密,他只有調一個RDS而已,其他都沒有
00:06:52,590 00:06:54,590 阿,韓國那個黑火藥
00:06:54,590 00:06:56,590 阿伯
00:06:57,470 00:06:59,470 韓國的韓華,也是因為曝光解約
00:07:01,820 00:07:03,820 是因為曝光解約,還是他無法理約而解約
00:07:03,820 00:07:05,820 這個我們沒有按照合約取得輸出許可,一律解約
00:07:05,820 00:07:07,820 我們沒有去做其他的一些另外的想法
00:07:07,820 00:07:09,820 所以你還基本上有一個把關的態度嘛
00:07:18,210 00:07:23,210 我是要跟部長說,軍事採購啊,我們知道我們是很困難啊
00:07:23,940 00:07:25,940 在國際上咧
00:07:27,610 00:07:29,610 算是要被打死了,真的就是
00:07:30,980 00:07:32,980 就算是買方的市場也會變成賣方市場
00:07:35,070 00:07:37,070 這是真的中華民國的問題
00:07:38,810 00:07:40,810 但我們支持你
00:07:41,090 00:07:43,090 你還給我們一個交代,有的人是要我們問
00:07:43,090 00:07:45,090 阿,買一張買就用那個政治對抗
00:07:45,090 00:07:47,090 國民黨在這兒,都在判國
00:07:47,090 00:07:49,090 要當武神,不是這樣啦
00:07:49,090 00:07:51,090 不要這樣用
00:07:51,090 00:07:53,090 你用這個態度,我是不能接受
00:07:53,090 00:07:55,090 我問你,你國防部的武神,我給你當一個人
00:07:57,960 00:07:59,960 我給你當一個,過一個月嘛
00:08:05,630 00:08:07,630 我給你當一個,過一個月嘛
00:08:07,630 00:08:09,630 你說到那邊危險
00:08:09,630 00:08:11,630 台灣很危險
00:08:10,250 00:08:12,250 錢都給你了
00:08:12,250 00:08:14,250 結果你看,一條一條都給你了
00:08:14,250 00:08:16,250 在那裡抵擋
00:08:17,460 00:08:19,460 所以你給我當一個
00:08:19,450 00:08:21,450 一年一年在這兒,這次蔡鋼岸
00:08:21,450 00:08:23,450 我扮成國防部長
00:08:24,810 00:08:26,810 我會把你記警告,口頭警告
00:08:29,540 00:08:31,540 部長你幹嘛這樣做
00:08:32,690 00:08:34,690 你會不會這樣做
00:08:34,679 00:08:36,679 蔡鋼岸一條一條都開火
00:08:37,820 00:08:39,820 這樣,東京時代,立法院報告的時候
00:08:39,820 00:08:41,820 都說很緊急耶
00:08:42,600 00:08:44,600 那不,不酷啦
00:08:45,060 00:08:47,060
00:08:47,090 00:08:49,090 一條一條通通開花啦
00:08:50,700 00:08:52,700 甚至法務單位都介入要調查
00:08:55,800 00:08:57,800 我很辛苦在這裡跟你說
00:08:57,800 00:08:59,800 提供一個意見
00:09:00,320 00:09:02,320 這種案件
00:09:02,170 00:09:04,170 不要再聽了啦
00:09:06,710 00:09:08,710 蔡健全的公司
00:09:08,920 00:09:10,920 我告訴你就是針對後面這些無人機產業
00:09:13,750 00:09:15,750 台灣有很多投入無人機產業研發
00:09:17,550 00:09:19,550 五年三年十五年以上的公司
00:09:21,180 00:09:23,180 我告訴你,如果要做無人機,我怎麼會當
00:09:24,180 00:09:26,180 你敢當
00:09:27,220 00:09:29,220 來,滾住,砍人嗎
00:09:29,110 00:09:31,110 如果我當了怎麼辦
00:09:35,450 00:09:37,450 我也當過了
00:09:38,050 00:09:40,050 我還當過了戰車,你知道嗎
00:09:42,130 00:09:44,130 我40年前就在開玩具工廠
00:09:44,130 00:09:46,130 你知道嗎
00:09:47,250 00:09:49,250 那如果以現在無人機的組裝
00:09:50,740 00:09:52,740 對我來說毫無困難
00:09:52,900 00:09:54,900 但是你們掌握前端的
00:09:57,410 00:09:59,410 記得授權
00:09:59,410 00:10:01,410 當你真的授權要給誰
00:10:03,530 00:10:05,530 就變成他拿到了
00:10:05,530 00:10:07,530 我在這裡很正式的跟他講
00:10:08,260 00:10:10,260 不要再有這種
00:10:11,020 00:10:13,020 給一個同胞
00:10:12,800 00:10:14,800 然後最後分包到最後
00:10:14,800 00:10:16,800 真正做了沒有幫助到
00:10:16,800 00:10:18,800 我們整個台灣這些原本
00:10:18,800 00:10:20,800 投入研發生產的
00:10:20,800 00:10:22,800 這些無人機產業
00:10:23,340 00:10:25,340 在什麼綠油有誰的油
00:10:25,340 00:10:27,340 賴油油都不重要
00:10:27,920 00:10:29,920 為台灣的國防,大家好好用心來打拚
00:10:32,690 00:10:34,690 台灣我知道的有投入無人機研發的很多
00:10:38,110 00:10:40,110 不要亂給這些工廠
00:10:40,690 00:10:42,690 給這些研發者
00:10:42,930 00:10:44,930 我們都支持
00:10:44,930 00:10:46,930 也要找一些新的
00:10:46,930 00:10:48,930 像這個公司中鴻的
00:10:48,930 00:10:50,930 賣鴨的
00:10:50,930 00:10:52,930 做這個水質做塞宅的
00:10:54,220 00:10:56,220 一定要拿我們的錢去當資本當老婆
00:10:59,370 00:11:01,370 然後你最上游給他
00:11:01,330 00:11:03,330 他裡面也是找到這些
00:11:03,330 00:11:07,330 真正投入無人機產業研發者的業者
00:11:08,400 00:11:10,400 這樣就不理人家
00:11:10,400 00:11:12,400 在這裡所有委員給你們繼續扶手
00:11:14,930 00:11:16,930 不需要這樣了
00:11:17,340 00:11:19,340
00:11:19,960 00:11:21,960 我是覺得對這裡的案件
00:11:23,100 00:11:25,100 韓國
00:11:24,620 00:11:26,620 這個案件
00:11:26,860 00:11:28,860 跟胡邁這個案件
00:11:29,760 00:11:31,760 以及
00:11:33,660 00:11:35,660 你現在削雞瓜進來
00:11:36,380 00:11:38,380 純度多少你有驗了嗎
00:11:39,350 00:11:41,350 我們的合約規範就是99
00:11:41,350 00:11:43,350 還沒有到,還沒有交貨
00:11:43,350 00:11:45,350 要到11月才會交貨期
00:11:45,350 00:11:49,350 現在他有跟你確定會準時交貨嗎
00:11:49,350 00:11:51,350 我們依合約辦理
00:11:52,860 00:11:54,860 那你評估現在他準時
00:11:54,860 00:11:56,860 可以交貨的機率有幾%
00:11:56,860 00:11:58,860 有沒有六成以上
00:12:01,440 00:12:03,440 我懂
00:12:03,010 00:12:05,010 沒有
00:12:04,320 00:12:06,320 沒關係,談不談
00:12:06,320 00:12:08,320 因為這已經差不多外國大家都知道了
00:12:08,320 00:12:10,320 不是,那個委員
00:12:10,320 00:12:12,320 我想合約的期限還沒有到之前
00:12:12,320 00:12:14,320 那合約
00:12:14,320 00:12:16,320 你沒法說
00:12:16,320 00:12:18,320 那個,廠商也沒有提到說
00:12:18,320 00:12:20,320 有什麼延誤的情況
00:12:20,320 00:12:22,320 那我們當然就是依合約來辦理
00:12:22,320 00:12:24,320 剛剛君佩局長也說明得很清楚
00:12:24,320 00:12:26,320 那我們其他的這些相關的
00:12:26,560 00:12:28,560 有去獲得的這個
00:12:28,560 00:12:30,560 規劃跟採購的計畫
00:12:30,560 00:12:32,560 我們都是會依法來
00:12:32,560 00:12:34,560 進行這個相關的
00:12:34,560 00:12:36,560 正常的採購作業程序
00:12:36,560 00:12:38,560 那最有利標的這個部分
00:12:38,560 00:12:40,560 我們都也會請部外的委員來進行評選
00:12:40,560 00:12:42,560 我想
00:12:42,560 00:12:44,560 這個都是
00:12:44,560 00:12:46,560 我根本辛苦
00:12:46,560 00:12:48,560 在依法再進行沒有什麼問題
00:12:48,560 00:12:50,560 但是立法院把你罷官以後
00:12:50,560 00:12:52,560 你們自己要先做第一審的罷官
00:12:52,560 00:12:54,560 不需要
00:12:54,560 00:12:56,560 我們不需要
00:12:56,560 00:12:58,560 我也不知道說
00:12:58,560 00:13:00,560 有的就是我們本地的地下全部人員
00:13:02,270 00:13:04,270 每年本地的地下全部人員
00:13:04,270 00:13:06,270 到底收集多少資料
00:13:06,270 00:13:08,270 你們才可以對他們這麼好
00:13:12,430 00:13:14,430 看了這個報告
00:13:14,430 00:13:16,430 我實在說我真鬱悶
00:13:16,530 00:13:18,530 你會覺得我一路給你們支持你們的威聲
00:13:19,640 00:13:21,640 對不對
00:13:21,190 00:13:23,190 我沒像人家說今天要怎樣問你
00:13:23,190 00:13:25,190 你來說明我都支持你
00:13:26,880 00:13:28,880 結果你給我
00:13:29,810 00:13:31,810 這個案件我為什麼要問你
00:13:31,810 00:13:33,810 因為調查局有人跟我說
00:13:35,670 00:13:37,670 我問說為什麼不翻案
00:13:38,970 00:13:40,970 甚至那個資安的
00:13:41,960 00:13:43,960 那個茶葉行
00:13:43,960 00:13:45,960 他就自己說他是人頭
00:13:45,960 00:13:47,960 我問法務部
00:13:47,960 00:13:49,960 你們為什麼不調查他
00:13:49,960 00:13:51,960 他說有
00:13:48,660 00:13:50,660 所以我現在才來跟你們
00:13:51,770 00:13:53,770 問問是不是因為來調查你
00:13:53,770 00:13:55,770 調查料
00:13:55,800 00:13:57,800 茶葉行沒有
00:13:58,280 00:14:00,280 目前沒有
00:13:59,550 00:14:01,550 目前沒有
00:14:01,770 00:14:03,770 茶葉電機店沒有來調查你
00:14:03,770 00:14:05,770 沒有
00:14:05,770 00:14:07,770 他是因為他是資安的服務
00:14:08,240 00:14:10,240 那個案子是一個資安服務
00:14:10,240 00:14:12,240 目前正在履約當中
00:14:12,240 00:14:14,240 從今年的1月1號到明年的12月30號
00:14:14,240 00:14:16,240 目前履約進度是正常
00:14:17,970 00:14:19,970 好,這樣我再來問調查局
00:14:19,970 00:14:21,970 好,就這樣,謝謝