| IVOD_ID | 157130 | 
        
        | IVOD_URL | https://ivod.ly.gov.tw/Play/Clip/1M/157130 | 
        
        | 日期 | 2024-11-20 | 
        
        | 會議資料.會議代碼 | 委員會-11-2-26-9 | 
        
        | 會議資料.會議代碼:str | 第11屆第2會期社會福利及衛生環境委員會第9次全體委員會議 | 
        
        | 會議資料.屆 | 11 | 
        
        | 會議資料.會期 | 2 | 
        
        | 會議資料.會次 | 9 | 
        
        | 會議資料.種類 | 委員會 | 
        
        | 會議資料.委員會代碼[0] | 26 | 
        
        | 會議資料.委員會代碼:str[0] | 社會福利及衛生環境委員會 | 
        
        | 會議資料.標題 | 第11屆第2會期社會福利及衛生環境委員會第9次全體委員會議 | 
        
        | 影片種類 | Clip | 
        
        | 開始時間 | 2024-11-20T10:26:09+08:00 | 
        
        | 結束時間 | 2024-11-20T10:42:49+08:00 | 
        
        | 影片長度 | 00:16:40 | 
        
        | 支援功能[0] | ai-transcript | 
        
        | 支援功能[1] | gazette | 
        
        | video_url | https://ivod-lyvod.cdn.hinet.net/vod_1/_definst_/mp4:1MClips/be8492a9d81d8eab0086b26e5bd29a5f15c44cfb233885202ae224b9eab90f6174d47481ca160e5e5ea18f28b6918d91.mp4/playlist.m3u8 | 
        
        | 委員名稱 | 劉建國 | 
        
        | 委員發言時間 | 10:26:09 - 10:42:49 | 
        
        | 會議時間 | 2024-11-20T09:00:00+08:00 | 
        
        | 會議名稱 | 立法院第11屆第2會期社會福利及衛生環境委員會第9次全體委員會議(事由:邀請勞動部部長、銓敘部、國防部、內政部警政署、內政部消防署、行政院人事行政總處、考試院、公務人員保障暨培訓委員會、教育部及國家科學及技術委員會就「職場霸凌防治與處理作業」進行專題報告,並備質詢。) | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[0].speaker | SPEAKER_00 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[0].start | 0.03096875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[0].end | 2.62971875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[1].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[1].start | 12.67034375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[1].end | 13.81784375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[2].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[2].start | 15.33659375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[2].end | 16.93971875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[3].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[3].start | 17.20971875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[3].end | 17.44596875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[4].speaker | SPEAKER_03 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[4].start | 18.77909375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[4].end | 19.30221875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[5].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[5].start | 20.12909375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[5].end | 20.92221875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[6].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[6].start | 21.63096875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[6].end | 22.64346875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[7].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[7].start | 24.49971875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[7].end | 26.52471875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[8].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[8].start | 27.67221875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[8].end | 28.71846875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[9].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[9].start | 30.45659375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[9].end | 31.90784375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[10].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[10].start | 32.98784375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[10].end | 34.74284375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[11].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[11].start | 35.13096875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[11].end | 36.27846875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[12].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[12].start | 38.01659375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[12].end | 39.97409375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[13].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[13].start | 40.81784375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[13].end | 42.45471875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[14].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[14].start | 43.58534375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[14].end | 45.66096875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[15].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[15].start | 46.92659375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[15].end | 47.56784375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[16].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[16].start | 47.77034375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[16].end | 49.77846875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[17].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[17].start | 50.45346875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[17].end | 50.75721875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[18].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[18].start | 51.31409375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[18].end | 55.11096875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[19].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[19].start | 55.68471875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[19].end | 58.72221875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[20].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[20].start | 59.19471875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[20].end | 60.47721875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[21].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[21].start | 61.23659375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[21].end | 63.51471875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[22].speaker | SPEAKER_03 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[22].start | 63.83534375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[22].end | 64.72971875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[23].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[23].start | 66.51846875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[23].end | 67.73346875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[24].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[24].start | 69.01596875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[24].end | 70.48409375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[25].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[25].start | 71.46284375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[25].end | 73.74096875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[26].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[26].start | 74.34846875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[26].end | 75.24284375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[27].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[27].start | 76.52534375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[27].end | 77.48721875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[28].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[28].start | 79.57971875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[28].end | 80.81159375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[29].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[29].start | 81.33471875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[29].end | 82.26284375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[30].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[30].start | 83.41034375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[30].end | 84.11909375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[31].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[31].start | 84.60846875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[31].end | 86.63346875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[32].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[32].start | 87.10596875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[32].end | 88.03409375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[33].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[33].start | 90.14346875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[33].end | 90.90284375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[34].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[34].start | 92.01659375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[34].end | 92.62409375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[35].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[35].start | 93.13034375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[35].end | 95.47596875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[36].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[36].start | 96.60659375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[36].end | 101.09534375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[37].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[37].start | 101.65221875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[37].end | 104.28471875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[38].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[38].start | 105.17909375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[38].end | 106.81596875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[39].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[39].start | 107.42346875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[39].end | 108.09846875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[40].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[40].start | 108.67221875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[40].end | 109.49909375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[41].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[41].start | 111.49034375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[41].end | 112.55346875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[42].speaker | SPEAKER_03 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[42].start | 113.41409375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[42].end | 114.24096875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[43].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[43].start | 113.71784375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[43].end | 114.39284375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[44].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[44].start | 116.19846875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[44].end | 117.31221875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[45].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[45].start | 117.78471875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[45].end | 119.91096875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[46].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[46].start | 121.12596875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[46].end | 122.96534375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[47].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[47].start | 123.35346875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[47].end | 125.69909375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[48].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[48].start | 126.74534375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[48].end | 129.10784375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[49].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[49].start | 129.71534375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[49].end | 133.19159375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[50].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[50].start | 133.63034375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[50].end | 136.29659375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[51].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[51].start | 136.95471875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[51].end | 137.27534375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[52].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[52].start | 137.79846875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[52].end | 138.91221875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[53].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[53].start | 139.95846875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[53].end | 141.42659375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[54].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[54].start | 141.96659375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[54].end | 142.87784375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[55].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[55].start | 143.31659375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[55].end | 145.69596875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[56].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[56].start | 146.55659375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[56].end | 147.68721875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[57].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[57].start | 148.26096875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[57].end | 150.15096875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[58].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[58].start | 152.05784375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[58].end | 152.88471875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[59].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[59].start | 153.77909375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[59].end | 154.53846875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[60].speaker | SPEAKER_03 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[60].start | 154.53846875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[60].end | 157.74471875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[61].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[61].start | 159.87096875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[61].end | 164.34284375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[62].speaker | SPEAKER_03 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[62].start | 161.15346875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[62].end | 161.20409375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[63].speaker | SPEAKER_03 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[63].start | 161.22096875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[63].end | 161.27159375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[64].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[64].start | 164.76471875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[64].end | 171.21096875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[65].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[65].start | 171.59909375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[65].end | 173.69159375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[66].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[66].start | 174.13034375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[66].end | 180.17159375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[67].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[67].start | 180.42471875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[67].end | 184.99784375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[68].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[68].start | 185.53784375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[68].end | 187.96784375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[69].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[69].start | 188.67659375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[69].end | 191.86596875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[70].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[70].start | 192.32159375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[70].end | 193.30034375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[71].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[71].start | 193.53659375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[71].end | 194.17784375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[72].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[72].start | 194.54909375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[72].end | 195.05534375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[73].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[73].start | 196.62471875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[73].end | 197.16471875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[74].speaker | SPEAKER_03 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[74].start | 198.17721875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[74].end | 204.97784375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[75].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[75].start | 204.97784375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[75].end | 215.27159375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[76].speaker | SPEAKER_03 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[76].start | 214.30971875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[76].end | 216.62159375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[77].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[77].start | 217.02659375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[77].end | 217.53284375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[78].speaker | SPEAKER_03 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[78].start | 217.66784375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[78].end | 219.23721875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[79].speaker | SPEAKER_03 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[79].start | 219.97971875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[79].end | 223.48971875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[80].speaker | SPEAKER_03 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[80].start | 223.89471875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[80].end | 236.07846875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[81].speaker | SPEAKER_03 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[81].start | 236.48346875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[81].end | 246.96284375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[82].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[82].start | 246.96284375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[82].end | 262.99409375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[83].speaker | SPEAKER_03 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[83].start | 258.11721875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[83].end | 258.74159375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[84].speaker | SPEAKER_03 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[84].start | 263.06159375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[84].end | 266.85846875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[85].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[85].start | 263.34846875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[85].end | 263.93909375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[86].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[86].start | 264.71534375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[86].end | 265.13721875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[87].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[87].start | 265.25534375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[87].end | 265.72784375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[88].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[88].start | 266.33534375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[88].end | 269.00159375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[89].speaker | SPEAKER_03 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[89].start | 269.00159375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[89].end | 270.72284375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[90].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[90].start | 269.60909375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[90].end | 269.62596875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[91].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[91].start | 269.64284375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[91].end | 269.99721875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[92].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[92].start | 270.45284375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[92].end | 273.28784375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[93].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[93].start | 274.40159375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[93].end | 274.63784375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[94].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[94].start | 275.29596875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[94].end | 276.40971875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[95].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[95].start | 276.62909375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[95].end | 277.45596875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[96].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[96].start | 277.75971875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[96].end | 278.65409375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[97].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[97].start | 279.36284375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[97].end | 280.86471875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[98].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[98].start | 281.43846875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[98].end | 282.73784375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[99].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[99].start | 283.37909375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[99].end | 284.89784375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[100].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[100].start | 285.33659375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[100].end | 285.82596875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[101].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[101].start | 286.31534375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[101].end | 287.20971875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[102].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[102].start | 288.37409375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[102].end | 289.82534375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[103].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[103].start | 290.07846875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[103].end | 290.60159375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[104].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[104].start | 291.02346875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[104].end | 292.32284375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[105].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[105].start | 292.50846875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[105].end | 293.31846875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[106].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[106].start | 293.82471875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[106].end | 294.78659375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[107].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[107].start | 296.54159375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[107].end | 297.94221875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[108].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[108].start | 299.59596875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[108].end | 300.86159375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[109].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[109].start | 301.19909375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[109].end | 302.80221875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[110].speaker | SPEAKER_01 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[110].start | 304.97909375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[110].end | 313.12971875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[111].speaker | SPEAKER_01 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[111].start | 313.51784375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[111].end | 316.85909375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[112].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[112].start | 315.39096875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[112].end | 316.11659375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[113].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[113].start | 316.85909375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[113].end | 318.54659375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[114].speaker | SPEAKER_01 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[114].start | 318.78284375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[114].end | 320.41971875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[115].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[115].start | 320.41971875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[115].end | 322.07346875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[116].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[116].start | 322.47846875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[116].end | 324.06471875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[117].speaker | SPEAKER_01 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[117].start | 323.64284375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[117].end | 323.89596875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[118].speaker | SPEAKER_01 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[118].start | 324.06471875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[118].end | 324.35159375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[119].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[119].start | 324.35159375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[119].end | 329.38034375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[120].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[120].start | 330.13971875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[120].end | 330.61221875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[121].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[121].start | 331.23659375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[121].end | 332.21534375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[122].speaker | SPEAKER_01 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[122].start | 332.46846875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[122].end | 334.67909375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[123].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[123].start | 333.88596875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[123].end | 337.37909375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[124].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[124].start | 337.98659375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[124].end | 343.03221875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[125].speaker | SPEAKER_01 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[125].start | 344.34846875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[125].end | 352.02659375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[126].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[126].start | 344.93909375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[126].end | 345.24284375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[127].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[127].start | 350.50784375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[127].end | 351.73971875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[128].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[128].start | 352.02659375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[128].end | 352.04346875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[129].speaker | SPEAKER_01 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[129].start | 352.04346875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[129].end | 354.89534375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[130].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[130].start | 352.11096875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[130].end | 352.46534375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[131].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[131].start | 355.46909375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[131].end | 360.32909375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[132].speaker | SPEAKER_01 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[132].start | 356.21159375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[132].end | 358.15221875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[133].speaker | SPEAKER_01 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[133].start | 359.16471875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[133].end | 359.82284375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[134].speaker | SPEAKER_01 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[134].start | 360.32909375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[134].end | 360.58221875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[135].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[135].start | 360.58221875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[135].end | 361.03784375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[136].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[136].start | 361.37534375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[136].end | 367.09596875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[137].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[137].start | 367.95659375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[137].end | 369.91409375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[138].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[138].start | 370.50471875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[138].end | 371.23034375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[139].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[139].start | 371.28096875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[139].end | 375.61784375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[140].speaker | SPEAKER_01 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[140].start | 374.03159375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[140].end | 374.74034375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[141].speaker | SPEAKER_01 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[141].start | 376.81596875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[141].end | 389.55659375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[142].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[142].start | 380.42721875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[142].end | 381.11909375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[143].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[143].start | 387.91971875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[143].end | 389.50596875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[144].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[144].start | 391.10909375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[144].end | 394.07909375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[145].speaker | SPEAKER_01 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[145].start | 394.66971875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[145].end | 394.68659375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[146].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[146].start | 394.68659375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[146].end | 396.89721875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[147].speaker | SPEAKER_01 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[147].start | 394.72034375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[147].end | 398.01096875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[148].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[148].start | 397.62284375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[148].end | 398.39909375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[149].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[149].start | 399.12471875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[149].end | 400.20471875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[150].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[150].start | 401.47034375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[150].end | 404.00159375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[151].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[151].start | 404.62596875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[151].end | 405.48659375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[152].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[152].start | 406.14471875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[152].end | 407.02221875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[153].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[153].start | 407.29221875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[153].end | 407.71409375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[154].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[154].start | 408.25409375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[154].end | 409.65471875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[155].speaker | SPEAKER_01 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[155].start | 412.54034375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[155].end | 413.11409375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[156].speaker | SPEAKER_01 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[156].start | 413.67096875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[156].end | 423.96471875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[157].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[157].start | 424.09971875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[157].end | 432.85784375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[158].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[158].start | 433.36409375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[158].end | 436.09784375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[159].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[159].start | 437.66721875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[159].end | 437.68409375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[160].speaker | SPEAKER_01 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[160].start | 437.68409375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[160].end | 445.37909375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[161].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[161].start | 445.58159375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[161].end | 446.66159375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[162].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[162].start | 447.77534375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[162].end | 448.93971875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[163].speaker | SPEAKER_01 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[163].start | 448.93971875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[163].end | 452.06159375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[164].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[164].start | 450.23909375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[164].end | 454.40721875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[165].speaker | SPEAKER_01 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[165].start | 452.09534375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[165].end | 452.11221875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[166].speaker | SPEAKER_01 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[166].start | 452.85471875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[166].end | 454.33971875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[167].speaker | SPEAKER_01 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[167].start | 454.40721875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[167].end | 454.96409375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[168].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[168].start | 454.96409375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[168].end | 457.34346875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[169].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[169].start | 457.71471875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[169].end | 458.72721875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[170].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[170].start | 459.01409375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[170].end | 461.15721875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[171].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[171].start | 462.05159375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[171].end | 463.58721875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[172].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[172].start | 464.38034375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[172].end | 466.13534375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[173].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[173].start | 466.52346875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[173].end | 467.72159375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[174].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[174].start | 468.12659375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[174].end | 470.21909375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[175].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[175].start | 470.64096875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[175].end | 471.82221875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[176].speaker | SPEAKER_01 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[176].start | 472.61534375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[176].end | 472.63221875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[177].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[177].start | 472.63221875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[177].end | 472.66596875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[178].speaker | SPEAKER_01 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[178].start | 472.66596875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[178].end | 472.85159375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[179].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[179].start | 472.85159375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[179].end | 472.98659375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[180].speaker | SPEAKER_01 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[180].start | 472.98659375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[180].end | 479.71971875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[181].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[181].start | 478.23471875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[181].end | 481.35659375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[182].speaker | SPEAKER_01 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[182].start | 482.20034375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[182].end | 484.10721875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[183].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[183].start | 483.17909375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[183].end | 488.35971875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[184].speaker | SPEAKER_01 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[184].start | 489.67596875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[184].end | 491.21159375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[185].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[185].start | 490.48596875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[185].end | 492.08909375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[186].speaker | SPEAKER_01 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[186].start | 492.46034375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[186].end | 499.00784375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[187].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[187].start | 500.61096875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[187].end | 505.04909375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[188].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[188].start | 505.77471875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[188].end | 508.22159375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[189].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[189].start | 508.74471875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[189].end | 509.41971875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[190].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[190].start | 510.19596875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[190].end | 514.98846875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[191].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[191].start | 515.25846875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[191].end | 519.42659375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[192].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[192].start | 519.89909375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[192].end | 522.64971875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[193].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[193].start | 523.17284375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[193].end | 526.95284375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[194].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[194].start | 527.77971875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[194].end | 528.84284375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[195].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[195].start | 529.19721875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[195].end | 530.15909375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[196].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[196].start | 530.46284375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[196].end | 531.50909375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[197].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[197].start | 531.91409375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[197].end | 533.41596875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[198].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[198].start | 534.36096875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[198].end | 535.08659375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[199].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[199].start | 535.66034375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[199].end | 536.60534375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[200].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[200].start | 536.84159375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[200].end | 547.67534375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[201].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[201].start | 549.21096875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[201].end | 550.84784375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[202].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[202].start | 551.65784375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[202].end | 552.75471875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[203].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[203].start | 553.26096875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[203].end | 554.86409375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[204].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[204].start | 555.79221875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[204].end | 557.37846875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[205].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[205].start | 559.04909375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[205].end | 561.81659375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[206].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[206].start | 564.53346875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[206].end | 565.59659375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[207].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[207].start | 567.11534375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[207].end | 569.22471875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[208].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[208].start | 571.77284375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[208].end | 572.65034375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[209].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[209].start | 573.88221875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[209].end | 575.45159375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[210].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[210].start | 576.43034375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[210].end | 577.29096875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[211].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[211].start | 579.09659375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[211].end | 580.37909375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[212].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[212].start | 581.20596875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[212].end | 583.60221875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[213].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[213].start | 584.85096875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[213].end | 585.84659375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[214].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[214].start | 588.39471875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[214].end | 589.59284375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[215].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[215].start | 589.86284375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[215].end | 590.97659375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[216].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[216].start | 593.01846875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[216].end | 593.37284375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[217].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[217].start | 593.72721875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[217].end | 598.62096875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[218].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[218].start | 599.75159375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[218].end | 600.74721875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[219].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[219].start | 601.45596875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[219].end | 606.72096875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[220].speaker | SPEAKER_03 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[220].start | 607.73346875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[220].end | 621.72284375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[221].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[221].start | 621.72284375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[221].end | 631.00409375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[222].speaker | SPEAKER_03 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[222].start | 621.73971875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[222].end | 621.79034375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[223].speaker | SPEAKER_03 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[223].start | 623.54534375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[223].end | 623.89971875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[224].speaker | SPEAKER_03 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[224].start | 631.00409375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[224].end | 638.05784375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[225].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[225].start | 631.45971875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[225].end | 631.86471875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[226].speaker | SPEAKER_03 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[226].start | 638.95221875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[226].end | 639.23909375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[227].speaker | SPEAKER_03 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[227].start | 640.15034375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[227].end | 642.88409375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[228].speaker | SPEAKER_03 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[228].start | 643.32284375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[228].end | 645.61784375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[229].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[229].start | 645.61784375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[229].end | 646.78221875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[230].speaker | SPEAKER_03 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[230].start | 647.11971875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[230].end | 653.17784375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[231].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[231].start | 648.72284375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[231].end | 653.59971875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[232].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[232].start | 654.61221875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[232].end | 659.91096875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[233].speaker | SPEAKER_03 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[233].start | 659.91096875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[233].end | 667.35284375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[234].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[234].start | 667.23471875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[234].end | 669.51284375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[235].speaker | SPEAKER_03 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[235].start | 669.63096875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[235].end | 669.96846875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[236].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[236].start | 669.96846875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[236].end | 681.64596875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[237].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[237].start | 682.15221875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[237].end | 687.85596875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[238].speaker | SPEAKER_00 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[238].start | 683.29971875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[238].end | 685.24034375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[239].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[239].start | 688.14284375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[239].end | 689.59409375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[240].speaker | SPEAKER_03 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[240].start | 692.36159375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[240].end | 692.41221875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[241].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[241].start | 692.41221875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[241].end | 697.17096875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[242].speaker | SPEAKER_03 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[242].start | 692.44596875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[242].end | 694.47096875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[243].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[243].start | 697.44096875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[243].end | 699.36471875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[244].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[244].start | 699.51659375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[244].end | 700.51221875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[245].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[245].start | 701.60909375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[245].end | 703.33034375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[246].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[246].start | 704.42721875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[246].end | 705.47346875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[247].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[247].start | 707.02596875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[247].end | 709.62471875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[248].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[248].start | 710.23221875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[248].end | 710.85659375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[249].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[249].start | 711.98721875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[249].end | 714.51846875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[250].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[250].start | 715.27784375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[250].end | 717.16784375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[251].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[251].start | 717.35346875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[251].end | 719.53034375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[252].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[252].start | 721.18409375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[252].end | 725.26784375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[253].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[253].start | 725.75721875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[253].end | 728.45721875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[254].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[254].start | 728.72721875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[254].end | 729.31784375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[255].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[255].start | 731.88284375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[255].end | 733.95846875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[256].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[256].start | 736.20284375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[256].end | 737.48534375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[257].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[257].start | 738.48096875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[257].end | 738.88596875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[258].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[258].start | 739.99971875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[258].end | 740.38784375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[259].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[259].start | 741.33284375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[259].end | 742.37909375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[260].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[260].start | 743.47596875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[260].end | 744.64034375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[261].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[261].start | 745.73721875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[261].end | 746.63159375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[262].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[262].start | 747.17159375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[262].end | 748.63971875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[263].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[263].start | 749.56784375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[263].end | 750.31034375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[264].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[264].start | 751.54221875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[264].end | 754.05659375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[265].speaker | SPEAKER_03 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[265].start | 754.74846875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[265].end | 756.18284375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[266].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[266].start | 755.54159375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[266].end | 756.21659375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[267].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[267].start | 757.27971875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[267].end | 758.62971875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[268].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[268].start | 758.98409375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[268].end | 759.81096875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[269].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[269].start | 760.82346875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[269].end | 762.12284375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[270].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[270].start | 762.73034375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[270].end | 764.67096875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[271].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[271].start | 765.00846875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[271].end | 765.36284375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[272].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[272].start | 765.93659375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[272].end | 766.52721875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[273].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[273].start | 767.52284375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[273].end | 768.80534375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[274].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[274].start | 769.32846875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[274].end | 770.54346875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[275].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[275].start | 772.33221875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[275].end | 774.13784375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[276].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[276].start | 775.58909375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[276].end | 776.28096875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[277].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[277].start | 777.02346875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[277].end | 778.28909375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[278].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[278].start | 779.13284375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[278].end | 781.27596875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[279].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[279].start | 787.73909375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[279].end | 790.16909375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[280].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[280].start | 790.55721875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[280].end | 792.31221875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[281].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[281].start | 792.83534375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[281].end | 794.11784375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[282].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[282].start | 795.11346875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[282].end | 795.83909375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[283].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[283].start | 796.71659375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[283].end | 798.91034375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[284].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[284].start | 799.19721875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[284].end | 800.10846875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[285].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[285].start | 800.63159375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[285].end | 801.54284375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[286].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[286].start | 802.11659375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[286].end | 802.72409375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[287].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[287].start | 803.21346875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[287].end | 807.24659375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[288].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[288].start | 809.57534375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[288].end | 810.77346875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[289].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[289].start | 811.00971875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[289].end | 811.11096875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[290].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[290].start | 811.68471875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[290].end | 826.87221875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[291].speaker | SPEAKER_00 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[291].start | 812.41034375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[291].end | 813.28784375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[292].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[292].start | 827.63159375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[292].end | 829.70721875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[293].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[293].start | 830.41596875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[293].end | 831.98534375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[294].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[294].start | 833.65596875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[294].end | 835.63034375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[295].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[295].start | 836.28846875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[295].end | 842.27909375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[296].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[296].start | 842.38034375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[296].end | 845.14784375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[297].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[297].start | 845.16471875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[297].end | 846.32909375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[298].speaker | SPEAKER_00 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[298].start | 847.05471875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[298].end | 863.18721875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[299].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[299].start | 862.17471875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[299].end | 863.59221875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[300].speaker | SPEAKER_00 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[300].start | 863.59221875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[300].end | 863.62596875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[301].speaker | SPEAKER_00 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[301].start | 863.91284375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[301].end | 865.63409375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[302].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[302].start | 864.14909375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[302].end | 865.73534375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[303].speaker | SPEAKER_00 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[303].start | 866.12346875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[303].end | 867.94596875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[304].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[304].start | 867.35534375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[304].end | 870.02159375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[305].speaker | SPEAKER_00 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[305].start | 870.39284375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[305].end | 877.69971875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[306].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[306].start | 876.33284375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[306].end | 877.48034375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[307].speaker | SPEAKER_00 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[307].start | 878.00346875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[307].end | 878.35784375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[308].speaker | SPEAKER_00 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[308].start | 878.59409375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[308].end | 884.46659375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[309].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[309].start | 878.66159375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[309].end | 880.04534375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[310].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[310].start | 883.92659375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[310].end | 885.37784375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[311].speaker | SPEAKER_00 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[311].start | 885.76596875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[311].end | 889.59659375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[312].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[312].start | 887.84159375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[312].end | 888.21284375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[313].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[313].start | 889.69784375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[313].end | 893.19096875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[314].speaker | SPEAKER_00 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[314].start | 893.30909375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[314].end | 900.61596875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[315].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[315].start | 899.18159375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[315].end | 907.46721875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[316].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[316].start | 908.96909375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[316].end | 915.56721875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[317].speaker | SPEAKER_00 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[317].start | 916.74846875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[317].end | 921.64221875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[318].speaker | SPEAKER_00 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[318].start | 921.96284375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[318].end | 927.34596875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[319].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[319].start | 926.87346875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[319].end | 931.15971875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[320].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[320].start | 931.42971875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[320].end | 943.81596875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[321].speaker | SPEAKER_00 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[321].start | 934.04534375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[321].end | 938.48346875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[322].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[322].start | 944.81159375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[322].end | 945.57096875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[323].speaker | SPEAKER_00 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[323].start | 944.82846875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[323].end | 965.07846875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[324].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[324].start | 964.45409375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[324].end | 965.24721875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[325].speaker | SPEAKER_00 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[325].start | 965.68596875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[325].end | 966.68159375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[326].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[326].start | 968.18346875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[326].end | 968.84159375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[327].speaker | SPEAKER_00 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[327].start | 968.20034375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[327].end | 973.83659375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[328].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[328].start | 971.20409375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[328].end | 974.08971875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[329].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[329].start | 975.00096875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[329].end | 976.77284375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[330].speaker | SPEAKER_00 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[330].start | 977.34659375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[330].end | 977.36346875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[331].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[331].start | 977.36346875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[331].end | 977.41409375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[332].speaker | SPEAKER_00 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[332].start | 977.41409375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[332].end | 978.64596875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[333].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[333].start | 977.59971875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[333].end | 979.43909375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[334].speaker | SPEAKER_00 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[334].start | 979.16909375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[334].end | 980.40096875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[335].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[335].start | 980.40096875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[335].end | 994.74471875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[336].speaker | SPEAKER_00 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[336].start | 980.94096875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[336].end | 981.64971875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[337].speaker | SPEAKER_00 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[337].start | 991.26846875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[337].end | 991.30221875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[338].speaker | SPEAKER_01 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[338].start | 991.43721875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[338].end | 992.46659375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[339].speaker | SPEAKER_00 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[339].start | 992.46659375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[339].end | 992.88846875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[340].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[340].start | 994.94721875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[340].end | 994.96409375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[341].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[341].start | 995.04846875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[341].end | 995.97659375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[342].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[342].start | 996.43221875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[342].end | 996.93846875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[343].speaker | SPEAKER_02 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[343].start | 997.20846875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[343].end | 997.76534375 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[344].speaker | SPEAKER_01 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[344].start | 998.55846875 | 
        
        | transcript.pyannote[344].end | 1000.06034375 | 
        
        | transcript.whisperx[0].start | 0.009 | 
        
        | transcript.whisperx[0].end | 2.13 | 
        
        | transcript.whisperx[0].text | 來,有請部長蔡署長你並上來吧我也好部長辛苦了但這件事情從11月4號發生到現在如果再處理不好 | 
        
        | transcript.whisperx[1].start | 30.472 | 
        
        | transcript.whisperx[1].end | 48.809 | 
        
        | transcript.whisperx[1].text | 你會越來越苦了。勞動部上上下下的同仁也一樣會越來越苦。會發生這樣的憾事絕對不是一個單一事件。所以你們的調查報告裡面,我覺得有很多討論的空間。 | 
        
        | transcript.whisperx[2].start | 51.543 | 
        
        | transcript.whisperx[2].end | 77.125 | 
        
        | transcript.whisperx[2].text | 雖然是外部委員的這樣的一個調查但畢竟是經過您跟次長對外公開說明所以就必須要概括承受當然當然今天北昏暑發生這個憾事會有這麼多執政黨的地方議員到現在還窮追不捨 | 
        
        | transcript.whisperx[3].start | 79.659 | 
        
        | transcript.whisperx[3].end | 103.973 | 
        
        | transcript.whisperx[3].text | 也有政治黨的委員也看不下去所以今天蘇昭偉排這樣的專案報告當然就是要趕快來釐清不要讓這樣的憾事再持續發生下去但是我們真的有這樣的決心跟魄力跟環形確實不要讓這樣的憾事再發生下去嗎 | 
        
        | transcript.whisperx[4].start | 105.302 | 
        
        | transcript.whisperx[4].end | 109.264 | 
        
        | transcript.whisperx[4].text | 顯然在這個報告裡面我說真的是看不出來真的是看不出來我在講我們的許傳勝次長有特別提到嘛鄭雲峰組長有凌晨1點、5點船內在交辦事情而且還規定在10分鐘內要回復 | 
        
        | transcript.whisperx[5].start | 130.215 | 
        
        | transcript.whisperx[5].end | 149.966 | 
        
        | transcript.whisperx[5].text | 10分鐘內如果沒有回覆,隔天就叫到辦公室去罵這是你們的報告嘛,是次長所講的嘛,對不對好,針對這一位已經失去生命的同仁你們報告裡面說這個副處長對他沒有霸凌但在這個次長上,他確實有霸凌的行為這不是很衝突,不是很矛盾委員我剛剛已經解釋了,可以讓我解釋嗎 | 
        
        | transcript.whisperx[6].start | 159.912 | 
        
        | transcript.whisperx[6].end | 179.454 | 
        
        | transcript.whisperx[6].text | 我再講一下啦我一定給你時間解釋因為你講說他是因為領導統一的風格嘛對不對都在你報告裡面那與同仁互信破裂還要繼續執行職務恐有爭議且對機關生意有重大之影響建議先行調整職務 | 
        
        | transcript.whisperx[7].start | 180.595 | 
        
        | transcript.whisperx[7].end | 190.262 | 
        
        | transcript.whisperx[7].text | 所以分所長的調理限職是在他的領導統一不是讓同仁命上在這個辦公室而且我們只是擔心他繼續執行職務影響到機關的聲譽是這樣嗎 | 
        
        | transcript.whisperx[8].start | 198.724 | 
        
        | transcript.whisperx[8].end | 215.522 | 
        
        | transcript.whisperx[8].text | 委員就是說他是一個機關的最高首長他的任何行為一定會影響到每一個人所以他有對一級主管會影響到每一個人嘛所以一定包含這個11月4號在自己的辦公室結束生命的這個同仁我想透過層層傳導也會的 | 
        
        | transcript.whisperx[9].start | 217.242 | 
        
        | transcript.whisperx[9].end | 241.526 | 
        
        | transcript.whisperx[9].text | 對嘛對,可是不是直接原因不是直接他霸凌他他中間還隔著兩位主管就是我這一次也進行懲處的副分署長以及秘書室主任這就是這兩位主管才是直接督導這位離開的同仁那謝分署長的確有對其他的一級主管進行霸凌可是他是透過層層傳導的機制傳導到我們離開的同仁身上 | 
        
        | transcript.whisperx[10].start | 246.267 | 
        
        | transcript.whisperx[10].end | 272.84 | 
        
        | transcript.whisperx[10].text | 應該是這麼說部長我覺得你這麼講我可以理解你對這事情的認知跟感受還有你在公部門的職場的相關一些經驗但是有些事情是已經是整個系統已經出的很嚴重的問題對我覺得是要凸顯系統性的問題才去做這樣的調查這個系統性問題應該也不是只有北分署是的連老花署本身問題也非常嚴重 | 
        
        | transcript.whisperx[11].start | 275.339 | 
        
        | transcript.whisperx[11].end | 302.683 | 
        
        | transcript.whisperx[11].text | 要不要問一下我們的署長在他的任內他的任內中副署長還有相關的有多少同仁都被都被提早退休有多少個科長級的現在從九職等八職等自己調到地方的區公所署長要不要對外說明一下署已經出問題分署哪有不出問題的道理 | 
        
        | transcript.whisperx[12].start | 305.017 | 
        
        | transcript.whisperx[12].end | 320.169 | 
        
        | transcript.whisperx[12].text | 有沒有跟委員報告齁我們在今年如果以今年齁我們大概是有3名同仁退休對那其中都是借齡對對都是借齡不是提前退休就是達到退休的條件 | 
        
        | transcript.whisperx[13].start | 321.069 | 
        
        | transcript.whisperx[13].end | 342.803 | 
        
        | transcript.whisperx[13].text | 中戶也不是中戶署長也不是體檢退休薛組長也不是體檢退休陳峰署長也不是體檢退休都不是你把握明確跟委員會講對他們就是依法退休對是依法退休不是要做體檢退休你要看這幾天有其他的機關被提早退休引鬧的灰黑洋洋喔 | 
        
        | transcript.whisperx[14].start | 344.38 | 
        
        | transcript.whisperx[14].end | 364.96 | 
        
        | transcript.whisperx[14].text | 跟委員報告所以這三位都不是提早退休跟委員報告他們不是被提早退休那個是因為他們都有各自所以他們是自願提早退休都有各自因為每一位我都跟他懇談所以他們是自願的提前退休嘛對不對不是借領嘛不是借領是嗎是好所以這個因素我們在討論吼那是不是還有很多包含重規組訓練組有多位科長 | 
        
        | transcript.whisperx[15].start | 368.001 | 
        
        | transcript.whisperx[15].end | 388.683 | 
        
        | transcript.whisperx[15].text | 已經降調 只是已經請調降到降級 然後調到其他居公所去 有沒有有幾位 有幾位就好我們今年有兩位是有商調到其他機關 對但是他的商調了解的原因有些真的是因為家庭上的因素或是其他的因素他的主管都有去 | 
        
        | transcript.whisperx[16].start | 391.138 | 
        
        | transcript.whisperx[16].end | 409.518 | 
        
        | transcript.whisperx[16].text | 他商調他調到那個單位有沒有志祺降級才有辦法調到那個單位有嘛對不對因為這個是有這個情形是有嘛是你說今年只有兩位你們在你們在中規組還有訓練組只有兩位而已嗎這兩組只有兩位今年對今年就兩位啊去年呢 | 
        
        | transcript.whisperx[17].start | 413.758 | 
        
        | transcript.whisperx[17].end | 435.868 | 
        
        | transcript.whisperx[17].text | 那個在去年齁去年在評調到其他機關是有16位16位對評調到其他機關16位16位所以書本部這樣這一兩年來講總共已經提前退休然後調離現職然後明明總總啦反正就這樣加起來總共有幾位 | 
        
        | transcript.whisperx[18].start | 437.691 | 
        
        | transcript.whisperx[18].end | 458.045 | 
        
        | transcript.whisperx[18].text | 我們大概如果以今年到目前大概有總共是36位這裡面含這個約用人員、臨時人員你什麼時候到今年?去年到今年是不是?只有今年只有今年就票了36位?36位阿去年有沒有辦法馬上做報告?對,去年有總共是有65位總共有65位嘛36加65,101嘛對不對?你們離開了101 | 
        
        | transcript.whisperx[19].start | 464.549 | 
        
        | transcript.whisperx[19].end | 488.152 | 
        
        | transcript.whisperx[19].text | 對老化署有期待的同仁,你覺得這樣正常嗎?署長你自己跟部長講,跟委員會講,你覺得這樣正常嗎?跟委員報告,因為他的離開的原因真的是很多啦,有些是退休,有些是考試,所以他有離開,他離開有很多原因,所以你認定是正常就對了?這每一位我們其實都能看看。就是說在職場上,在公部的職場上,他是一個算是一個正常的樣態,你要回答我是這樣是不是? | 
        
        | transcript.whisperx[20].start | 490.608 | 
        
        | transcript.whisperx[20].end | 504.365 | 
        
        | transcript.whisperx[20].text | 部長請你慎重回答好不好署裡面因為他在北部北部因為各行政機關的職缺很多有時候這個選擇性確實是存在我要回到昨天記者會我看部長的說法裡面有一段話齁 | 
        
        | transcript.whisperx[21].start | 506.396 | 
        
        | transcript.whisperx[21].end | 533.169 | 
        
        | transcript.whisperx[21].text | 認為有制度性人力缺乏問題是這樣嗎我想我在這個委會不只一次提起當然有人力缺乏的問題嘛所以我也希望部長要積極爭取這個人力的補給嘛但是如果像老花署這樣的單位自己的署本部單位兩年就掉了不到兩年就這樣請掉提前退休一百零一位然後我們再看到北分署 | 
        
        | transcript.whisperx[22].start | 534.5 | 
        
        | transcript.whisperx[22].end | 536.341 | 
        
        | transcript.whisperx[22].text | 所以部長你講的系統性問題確實如此啊 | 
        
        | transcript.whisperx[23].start | 565.031 | 
        
        | transcript.whisperx[23].end | 585.541 | 
        
        | transcript.whisperx[23].text | 確實如此啊那跟你自由性能力缺乏有什麼關係而且你知道喔北溫署是17個主管桃枝腰腰的你書本部有幾個主管還有副書長級的他需要提前退休還有幾個組長還有志願將級到地方公所去 | 
        
        | transcript.whisperx[24].start | 594.293 | 
        
        | transcript.whisperx[24].end | 606.36 | 
        
        | transcript.whisperx[24].text | 誰會希望說在中央單位待好好又跑到地方的區公所去怎麼會有這個狀況部長你有深刻的去理解深刻去調查深刻去知道到底原因何在嗎 | 
        
        | transcript.whisperx[25].start | 607.976 | 
        
        | transcript.whisperx[25].end | 630.598 | 
        
        | transcript.whisperx[25].text | 委員我想喔就是這個管理風格的問題確實是要檢討啦是究竟是管理風格導致人留不住還是說這個勞動署本身是因為勞動條件太差這只有管理風格問題嗎如果是所謂的管理風格問題就會回到北溫署長的身上發生了這樣的憾事嘛在他的領導不統一之下嘛對不對 | 
        
        | transcript.whisperx[26].start | 631.178 | 
        
        | transcript.whisperx[26].end | 652.316 | 
        
        | transcript.whisperx[26].text | 這就是當然就是署本身領導者的責任嘛當然署長他的管理風格恰不恰當我會要他檢討好嗎對我也在這一次也一遍把他送考機會了我們會在這裡面來檢討他好不好這是考機問題嗎當然考機裡面你管理得不當也是一個問題啊也是一個評分的標準 | 
        
        | transcript.whisperx[27].start | 654.899 | 
        
        | transcript.whisperx[27].end | 669.096 | 
        
        | transcript.whisperx[27].text | 從署本部一直到分署被分署發生這樣的事情他是考機問題嗎?考機裡面包含了對你管理的這個你怎麼去管理這個機關這當然也是一個部長你到勞動部時間真的不長啊 | 
        
        | transcript.whisperx[28].start | 670.257 | 
        
        | transcript.whisperx[28].end | 688.517 | 
        
        | transcript.whisperx[28].text | 我知道很多事情你還要再去摸索再去理解嘛但是有時候有一件有發生這樣的憾事反而可以讓你更快速的了解到勞動部上上下下到底出了什麼樣的嚴重性的問題嘛對不對但是有時候當你知道這問題所在的時候你就是該斷則斷了 | 
        
        | transcript.whisperx[29].start | 692.692 | 
        
        | transcript.whisperx[29].end | 713.386 | 
        
        | transcript.whisperx[29].text | 該段就要折斷了如果這單純是一個領導統一出這個問題我覺得我覺得這樣的延伸會很可怕應該也不是只有勞化署因為時間的關係我們從勞化署的世界裡面可以看到勞動部真的是真的是很嚴重出現的結構性問題最後再給部長看一個數據我為什麼講113.446 | 
        
        | transcript.whisperx[30].start | 721.229 | 
        
        | transcript.whisperx[30].end | 733.26 | 
        
        | transcript.whisperx[30].text | 我們都知道是81嘛,北溫署這兩年,不到兩年時間有81位的同仁,包含17位主管,要調理他其實他真正的數字是82了 | 
        
        | transcript.whisperx[31].start | 736.249 | 
        
        | transcript.whisperx[31].end | 757.72 | 
        
        | transcript.whisperx[31].text | 就包含11月4號這位這位生命不見的同仁他也有要請調他也走不了因為他同仁寫這篇文章我不想護送請部長你自己過目我都有看如果他當時請調順利的話 | 
        
        | transcript.whisperx[32].start | 760.862 | 
        
        | transcript.whisperx[32].end | 780.757 | 
        
        | transcript.whisperx[32].text | 他當時如果不要因為跟同仁彼此之間這種感情的羈絆太甜就對了或許他請掉離開他是有生命的離開他今天是他今天也算是離開了啦但是是生命喪失的離開 | 
        
        | transcript.whisperx[33].start | 788.729 | 
        
        | transcript.whisperx[33].end | 806.928 | 
        
        | transcript.whisperx[33].text | 我最後是不是請銓敘部跟人事總處兩位單位來一下好不好你們這個一個單位、一個機關、一個機構人員異常的異動站在人事的管理上你們都沒有相關的預警機制嗎 | 
        
        | transcript.whisperx[34].start | 809.708 | 
        
        | transcript.whisperx[34].end | 831.748 | 
        
        | transcript.whisperx[34].text | 還是都是後知後覺我們如果保障這個辛苦考進來的這些國考的這些公務人員可以在職場上得到一定程度的這樣的一個保障而不是因為他們的主管機關領導同意出了問題然後就讓這個單位可以好像幾乎快瓦解了 | 
        
        | transcript.whisperx[35].start | 833.7 | 
        
        | transcript.whisperx[35].end | 833.84 | 
        
        | transcript.whisperx[35].text | 報告.劉建國 | 
        
        | transcript.whisperx[36].start | 864.32 | 
        
        | transcript.whisperx[36].end | 893.022 | 
        
        | transcript.whisperx[36].text | 你們上網公告是什麼資料?就是辭職,辭職嘛,啊調離的都沒有嗎?調離的部分我們現在正在跟,我們為了要讓資料更加精準,因為我們部裡面只有現在才要做?是因為這個事件才要做?不是,不是,在我們之前就已經在跟人事總處在密集的開會你們的之前是多久之前?從今年的6月份開始,我們就在處理這件事情你們6月份到現在還沒有辦法把這樣的機制建立完成? | 
        
        | transcript.whisperx[37].start | 893.442 | 
        
        | transcript.whisperx[37].end | 912.274 | 
        
        | transcript.whisperx[37].text | 因為這個部分涉及到WebHR的這個系統的建構我們要把它在系統上面我們已經有速發部了我們已經走到AI了創新行動內閣了你們從六月討論到現在連一個掌控所有單位的禮職的這樣的一個系統沒辦法建置起來 | 
        
        | transcript.whisperx[38].start | 917.246 | 
        
        | transcript.whisperx[38].end | 942.939 | 
        
        | transcript.whisperx[38].text | 現在正在努力啦包括我們大概預計是在明年會完成要到明年因為這部分涉及到系統要徵修要發包要你們有系統可以馬上查閱到這個離職的嘛請辭的嘛辭職的嘛對不對你們有這個系統然後要有另外一個系統就是調職的還要到明年才能夠建設完成而且從6月討論到現在 | 
        
        | transcript.whisperx[39].start | 944.84 | 
        
        | transcript.whisperx[39].end | 950.482 | 
        
        | transcript.whisperx[39].text | 這兩個系統加起來就可以把整個機關有送審和沒送審的人做一個完整的呈現那這兩個系統目前是不相容我們希望把他兩個系統能夠整合在一起所以到明年了我們盡量 | 
        
        | transcript.whisperx[40].start | 968.223 | 
        
        | transcript.whisperx[40].end | 997.407 | 
        
        | transcript.whisperx[40].text | 要到明年 盡量希望能夠提前啦 這個部分我們不堅持很努力可以提前多早啊 時間到了 一個月可不可以一個月不行啦 那我到時候再拜託兩位召委我們再排特別針對你們的針對這些事情的整個疫情機制看怎樣來做回報好不好 OK一個月內我就請他們兩位召委一定要排來做這樣處理 好不好 好 謝謝 | 
        
        | transcript.whisperx[41].start | 998.635 | 
        
        | transcript.whisperx[41].end | 998.958 | 
        
        | transcript.whisperx[41].text | 好 謝謝 謝謝劉建國 | 
        
        | gazette.lineno | 706 | 
        
        | gazette.blocks[0][0] | 劉委員建國:(10時26分)來,有請部長,蔡署長,你一併上來吧。 | 
        
        | gazette.blocks[1][0] | 何部長佩珊:委員好。 | 
        
        | gazette.blocks[2][0] | 劉委員建國:部長辛苦了。 | 
        
        | gazette.blocks[3][0] | 何部長佩珊:謝謝。 | 
        
        | gazette.blocks[4][0] | 劉委員建國:這件事情從11月4號發生到現在,如果再處理不好,你會越來越苦,勞動部上上下下的同仁也一樣會越來越苦,會發生這樣的憾事絕對不是一個單一事件,所以你們的調查報告裡面,我覺得有很多討論的空間,雖然是外部委員的調查,但畢竟是經過您跟次長對外公開說明,所以你就必須要概括承受。 | 
        
        | gazette.blocks[5][0] | 何部長佩珊:當然、當然。 | 
        
        | gazette.blocks[6][0] | 劉委員建國:今天北分署發生這個憾事,會有這麼多執政黨的地方議員到現在還窮追不捨,也有執政黨的委員看不下去,今天蘇召委排這樣的專案報告,當然就是要趕快來釐清,不要讓這樣的憾事再持續發生下去,但是我們真的有這樣的決心、魄力跟反省,確實不要讓這樣的憾事再發生下去嗎?顯然在這個報告裡面,我說真的,看不出來,真的是看不出來。 | 
        
        | gazette.blocks[7][0] | 何部長佩珊:委員,我…… | 
        
        | gazette.blocks[8][0] | 劉委員建國:我再講許傳盛次長有特別提到,這名分署長有凌晨1點、5點傳LINE在交辦事情,而且還規定在10分鐘內要回復,10分鐘內如果沒有回復,隔天就叫到辦公室去罵,這是你們的報告,是次長所講的,對不對?好,針對這一位已經失去生命的同仁,你們的報告裡面說這個分署長對他沒有霸凌,但在這個職場上,他確實有霸凌的行為,這不是很衝突、不是很矛盾? | 
        
        | gazette.blocks[9][0] | 何部長佩珊:委員,我剛剛已經解釋了,可以讓我解釋嗎? | 
        
        | gazette.blocks[10][0] | 劉委員建國:我再講一下啦!我一定給你時間解釋啦。 | 
        
        | gazette.blocks[11][0] | 何部長佩珊:好、是。 | 
        
        | gazette.blocks[12][0] | 劉委員建國:你們報告裡面說考量他的領導統御風格,與同仁互信破裂,若還要繼續執行職務,恐有爭議且對機關聲譽有重大之影響,建議先行調整職務。所以分署長的調離現職是因為他的領導統御,不是讓同仁命喪在這個辦公室,而且你們只是擔心他繼續執行職務,影響到機關的聲譽。是這樣嗎? | 
        
        | gazette.blocks[13][0] | 何部長佩珊:委員,他是一個機關的最高首長,他的任何行為一定會影響到每一個人,所以他有對一級主管…… | 
        
        | gazette.blocks[14][0] | 劉委員建國:會影響到每一個人,所以一定包含11月4號在自己辦公室結束生命的這個同仁。 | 
        
        | gazette.blocks[15][0] | 何部長佩珊:我想透過層層傳導也會的。 | 
        
        | gazette.blocks[16][0] | 劉委員建國:對嘛! | 
        
        | gazette.blocks[17][0] | 何部長佩珊:可是不是直接原因,不是直接他霸凌他,他中間還隔著兩位主管,就是我這一次也進行懲處的副分署長以及秘書室主任,這兩位主管才是直接督導這位離開的同仁,而謝分署長的確有對其他的一級主管進行霸凌,可是他是透過層層傳導的機制傳導到我們離開的同仁身上,應該是這麼說。 | 
        
        | gazette.blocks[18][0] | 劉委員建國:部長,我覺得你這麼講,我可以理解你對這件事情的認知跟感受啦,還有你在公部門職場相關的一些經驗,但是有些事情已經是整個系統出了很嚴重的問題。 | 
        
        | gazette.blocks[19][0] | 何部長佩珊:對,我就是要凸顯系統性的問題,才去做這樣的調查。 | 
        
        | gazette.blocks[20][0] | 劉委員建國:這個系統性問題應該也不是只有北分署。 | 
        
        | gazette.blocks[21][0] | 何部長佩珊:是的。 | 
        
        | gazette.blocks[22][0] | 劉委員建國:連勞發署本身問題也非常嚴重,要不要問一下我們的署長,在他的任內中,鍾副署長、還有相關的多少同仁都被提早退休?有多少個科長級的現在從九職等、八職等自己調到地方區公所?署長,要不要對外說明一下?署已經出問題,分署哪有不出問題的道理?有沒有? | 
        
        | gazette.blocks[23][0] | 蔡署長孟良:跟委員報告,我們在今年,如果以今年來看,我們大概有3名同仁退休,其中…… | 
        
        | gazette.blocks[24][0] | 劉委員建國:對,都是屆齡? | 
        
        | gazette.blocks[25][0] | 蔡署長孟良:對。 | 
        
        | gazette.blocks[26][0] | 劉委員建國:都是屆齡,不是提前退休? | 
        
        | gazette.blocks[27][0] | 蔡署長孟良:就是達到退休的條件。 | 
        
        | gazette.blocks[28][0] | 劉委員建國:鍾副署長也不是提前退休? | 
        
        | gazette.blocks[29][0] | 蔡署長孟良:對,他是…… | 
        
        | gazette.blocks[30][0] | 劉委員建國:薛組長也不是提前退休?陳分署長也不是提前退休?都不是?你把握?明確的跟委員會講。 | 
        
        | gazette.blocks[31][0] | 蔡署長孟良:他們就是依法退休…… | 
        
        | gazette.blocks[32][0] | 劉委員建國:對,是依法退休,不是叫做提前退休? | 
        
        | gazette.blocks[33][0] | 蔡署長孟良:是。 | 
        
        | gazette.blocks[34][0] | 劉委員建國:你要看這幾天有其他機關被提早退休也鬧得沸沸揚揚喔! | 
        
        | gazette.blocks[35][0] | 蔡署長孟良:跟委員報告…… | 
        
        | gazette.blocks[36][0] | 劉委員建國:所以這三位都不是提早退休? | 
        
        | gazette.blocks[37][0] | 蔡署長孟良:跟委員報告,他們不是被提早退休,那個是因為他們都有…… | 
        
        | gazette.blocks[38][0] | 劉委員建國:所以他們是自願提早退休? | 
        
        | gazette.blocks[39][0] | 蔡署長孟良:都有各自……因為每一位我都有跟他懇談。 | 
        
        | gazette.blocks[40][0] | 劉委員建國:所以他們是自願的提前退休,對不對? | 
        
        | gazette.blocks[41][0] | 蔡署長孟良:對、是。 | 
        
        | gazette.blocks[42][0] | 劉委員建國:不是屆齡? | 
        
        | gazette.blocks[43][0] | 蔡署長孟良:不是屆齡。 | 
        
        | gazette.blocks[44][0] | 劉委員建國:是嘛! | 
        
        | gazette.blocks[45][0] | 蔡署長孟良:是。 | 
        
        | gazette.blocks[46][0] | 劉委員建國:好。所以這個因素,我們再來討論啦,是不是還有很多,包含綜規組、訓練組有多位科長已經降調、請調,降級調到其他區公所去,有沒有?有幾位就好。 | 
        
        | gazette.blocks[47][0] | 蔡署長孟良:跟委員報告,我們今年有兩位是有商調到其他機關。 | 
        
        | gazette.blocks[48][0] | 劉委員建國:今年兩位? | 
        
        | gazette.blocks[49][0] | 蔡署長孟良:對。但是他的商調我們了解原因,有些真的是因為家庭上的因素或是其他的因素,他的主管…… | 
        
        | gazette.blocks[50][0] | 劉委員建國:他商調有沒有等同降調?他商調調到那個單位,有沒有自己降級才有辦法調到那個單位?有嘛!對不對? | 
        
        | gazette.blocks[51][0] | 蔡署長孟良:因為是有這個情形。 | 
        
        | gazette.blocks[52][0] | 劉委員建國:是有嘛! | 
        
        | gazette.blocks[53][0] | 蔡署長孟良:是。 | 
        
        | gazette.blocks[54][0] | 劉委員建國:你說今年只有兩位?你們綜規組、訓練組只有兩位而已嗎?這兩組只有兩位,今年? | 
        
        | gazette.blocks[55][0] | 蔡署長孟良:對,今年只有兩位。 | 
        
        | gazette.blocks[56][0] | 劉委員建國:去年呢? | 
        
        | gazette.blocks[57][0] | 蔡署長孟良:去年平調到其他機關的是有16位。 | 
        
        | gazette.blocks[58][0] | 劉委員建國:16位? | 
        
        | gazette.blocks[59][0] | 蔡署長孟良:對,平調到其他機關16位。 | 
        
        | gazette.blocks[60][0] | 劉委員建國:16位,所以署本部這一、兩年來,總共已經提前退休、調離現職,林林總總反正這樣加起來總共有幾位? | 
        
        | gazette.blocks[61][0] | 蔡署長孟良:如果以今年到目前大概總共是36位,這裡面含約用人員、臨時人員。 | 
        
        | gazette.blocks[62][0] | 劉委員建國:你什麼時候到今年?去年到今年是不是? | 
        
        | gazette.blocks[63][0] | 蔡署長孟良:只有今年。 | 
        
        | gazette.blocks[64][0] | 劉委員建國:只有今年就調了36位? | 
        
        | gazette.blocks[65][0] | 蔡署長孟良:36位。 | 
        
        | gazette.blocks[66][0] | 劉委員建國:去年的有沒有辦法馬上報告? | 
        
        | gazette.blocks[67][0] | 蔡署長孟良:去年總共是有65位。 | 
        
        | gazette.blocks[68][0] | 劉委員建國:總共有65位,36加65是101,對不對?你們離開了101位對勞發署有期待的同仁,你覺得這樣正常嗎?署長,你自己跟部長講,跟委員會講,你覺得這樣正常嗎? | 
        
        | gazette.blocks[69][0] | 蔡署長孟良:跟委員報告,因為離開的原因真的很多,有些是退休,有些是考試分發…… | 
        
        | gazette.blocks[70][0] | 劉委員建國:離開有很多原因,所以你認定是正常就對了? | 
        
        | gazette.blocks[71][0] | 蔡署長孟良:這每一位我們其實都有…… | 
        
        | gazette.blocks[72][0] | 劉委員建國:就是在職場上、在公部門職場上,這算是一個正常的樣態,你要回答我是這樣,是不是? | 
        
        | gazette.blocks[73][0] | 蔡署長孟良:跟委員報告,因為我們…… | 
        
        | gazette.blocks[74][0] | 劉委員建國:署長,請你慎重回答,好不好? | 
        
        | gazette.blocks[75][0] | 蔡署長孟良:因為署在北部,而北部各行政機關的職缺很多,所以有時候選擇性確實存在。 | 
        
        | gazette.blocks[76][0] | 劉委員建國:回到昨天的記者會,我們看部長的說法,裡面有一段話提到,認為這有制度性人力缺乏問題,是這樣嗎?我在這個委員會我不只一次提過,當然有人力缺乏的問題,所以我也希望部長要積極爭取人力的補給,但是如果像勞發署這樣的單位,自己的署本部單位不到兩年,請調、提前退休的有101位,然後我們再看北分署,也不遑多讓,異動人數從109年的19人、110年12人、111年18人、112年36人,到113年,你們給我的數字是45,等一下我再跟各位報告為什麼是46,再對照其他分署,並沒有像北分署這樣啊!沒有像署本部這樣啊!部長你說的系統性問題,確實如此啊!確實如此!那跟你制度性人力缺乏有什麼關係?而且你要知道,北分署是17個主管逃之夭夭,署本部有幾個主管?有副署長級要提前退休,還有幾個組長自願降級到地方公所,誰會在中央單位待得好好的,又跑到地方區公所去?怎麼會有這樣的狀況?部長,你有深刻去理解、深刻去調查、深刻去知道到底原因何在嗎? | 
        
        | gazette.blocks[77][0] | 何部長佩珊:委員,我想管理風格的問題確實要檢討,究竟是管理風格導致人留不住,還是勞發署本身勞動條件太差…… | 
        
        | gazette.blocks[78][0] | 劉委員建國:只有管理風格的問題嗎?如果是所謂的管理風格問題,那就回到北分署署長身上,在他的領導統御之下,發生了這樣的憾事,對不對? | 
        
        | gazette.blocks[79][0] | 何部長佩珊:這當然就是署本身領導者的責任,當然署長的管理風格恰不恰當,我會要他檢討,然後這一次我也會一併把他送考績會,我們會在這裡面來檢討他,好不好? | 
        
        | gazette.blocks[80][0] | 劉委員建國:這是考績問題嗎? | 
        
        | gazette.blocks[81][0] | 何部長佩珊:當然,在考績部分,管理不當也是一個評分標準。 | 
        
        | gazette.blocks[82][0] | 劉委員建國:這個單位這麼多人調動、調職,自願降調,從署本部一直到分署,北分署發生這樣的事情,是考績問題嗎? | 
        
        | gazette.blocks[83][0] | 何部長佩珊:考績也包含管理的一面,你怎麼去管理這個機關,當然也是一個…… | 
        
        | gazette.blocks[84][0] | 劉委員建國:部長,你到勞動部的時間真的不長,我知道很多事情你還在摸索、理解,但是有時候發生了這樣的憾事,反而可以讓你更快速了解勞動部上上下下到底出了什麼嚴重問題,對不對? | 
        
        | gazette.blocks[85][0] | 何部長佩珊:是,是。 | 
        
        | gazette.blocks[86][0] | 劉委員建國:有時候當你知道問題所在時,你就要該斷則斷。 | 
        
        | gazette.blocks[87][0] | 何部長佩珊:是,我了解,我了解。 | 
        
        | gazette.blocks[88][0] | 劉委員建國:該斷就要斷啊!如果單純只是一個領導統御出問題,我覺得這樣的問題衍生會很可怕,應該也不是只有勞發署。因為時間關係,我們從勞發署的事件可以看到勞動部真的是嚴重出現了結構性問題。 | 
        
        | gazette.blocks[88][1] | 我再給部長看一個數據,為什麼我講113年是46位?我們都知道北分署這兩年、不到兩年時間,有81位同仁,包含17位主管調離職位,其實真正的數字是82位,就包含11月4號這位生命不見的同仁,他也有請調,但他走不了,他的同仁寫了這篇文章,我不想複誦,請部長你自己過目。 | 
        
        | gazette.blocks[89][0] | 何部長佩珊:我都有看,我都有看。 | 
        
        | gazette.blocks[90][0] | 劉委員建國:好,如果他當時請調順利的話,如果不要因為跟同仁彼此之間感情的羈絆,就是相挺,或許他請調離開,他是有生命的離開,他今天也算是離開了,但是是生命喪失的離開。 | 
        
        | gazette.blocks[90][1] | 最後請教銓敘部和人事總處兩個單位,對於一個單位、一個機關、一個機構人員異常的異動,站在人事管理上,你們沒有相關預警機制嗎?還是都是後知後覺? | 
        
        | gazette.blocks[91][0] | 雷司長諶:報告委員,我們之前是…… | 
        
        | gazette.blocks[92][0] | 劉委員建國:你們如何保障?讓這些辛苦經過國考考進來的公務人員,可以在職場上得到一定程度的保障,而不是因為他們的主管機關領導統御出了問題,然後就讓這個單位幾乎好像要瓦解了,有時候這個不是缺乏人力的問題,是這個主管要讓這個機關瓦解,那站在兩個單位的立場,你們怎麼看待這個事情?有沒有什麼預警機制?還是完全都沒有? | 
        
        | gazette.blocks[93][0] | 雷司長諶:報告委員,我們目前是有針對每年各機關的辭職情形做統計,然後會上網公告,我們覺得一年的時間比較久,而且我們部裡面掌握的只有銓敘審定的人數…… | 
        
        | gazette.blocks[94][0] | 劉委員建國:你們有上網公告?你們上網公告是什麼資料? | 
        
        | gazette.blocks[95][0] | 雷司長諶:就是辭職、辭職率…… | 
        
        | gazette.blocks[96][0] | 劉委員建國:辭職嗎? | 
        
        | gazette.blocks[97][0] | 雷司長諶:對,對。 | 
        
        | gazette.blocks[98][0] | 劉委員建國:調離的沒有嗎? | 
        
        | gazette.blocks[99][0] | 雷司長諶:調離的部分,為了要讓資料更加精準,因為我們部裡只有銓敍審定的…… | 
        
        | gazette.blocks[100][0] | 劉委員建國:現在才要做?是因為這個事件才要做? | 
        
        | gazette.blocks[101][0] | 雷司長諶:不是,不是,在之前我們就已經有跟人事總處密集開會,我們要…… | 
        
        | gazette.blocks[102][0] | 劉委員建國:你們的之前是多久之前? | 
        
        | gazette.blocks[103][0] | 雷司長諶:從今年6月份開始,我們就有在處理這件事情。 | 
        
        | gazette.blocks[104][0] | 劉委員建國:6月份到現在,還沒有辦法把這樣的機制建立完成? | 
        
        | gazette.blocks[105][0] | 雷司長諶:因為這個部分涉及到WebHR系統的建構,我們要把它在系統上面…… | 
        
        | gazette.blocks[106][0] | 劉委員建國:我們已經有數發部了,已經走到AI、創新行動內閣,你們從6月討論到現在,連一個掌控所有單位離職情形的一個系統都沒辦法建置起來? | 
        
        | gazette.blocks[107][0] | 雷司長諶:現在正在努力啦!預計大概明年會完成。 | 
        
        | gazette.blocks[108][0] | 劉委員建國:要到明年? | 
        
        | gazette.blocks[109][0] | 雷司長諶:這部分涉及到系統要增修、發包,要…… | 
        
        | gazette.blocks[110][0] | 劉委員建國:你們有系統可以馬上查閱到請辭…… | 
        
        | gazette.blocks[111][0] | 雷司長諶:辭職和調動有,但是…… | 
        
        | gazette.blocks[112][0] | 劉委員建國:辭職的,對不對?你們有這個系統,然後還要有另外一個調職的系統,這要到明年才有辦法建置完成,而且從6月討論到現在,這太離譜了! | 
        
        | gazette.blocks[113][0] | 雷司長諶:報告委員,銓敘部是銓敘審定的部分,人事總處那邊會有WebHR,他們有未送審人員,這兩個系統加起來,就可以把整個機關有送審和沒送審的人員做完整的呈現,而這兩個系統目前不相容,所以我們是希望把這兩個系統整合在一起。 | 
        
        | gazette.blocks[114][0] | 劉委員建國:所以要到明年? | 
        
        | gazette.blocks[115][0] | 雷司長諶:我們希望儘量可以提前,這個部分我們部裡面很努力…… | 
        
        | gazette.blocks[116][0] | 劉委員建國:對啦!那可以提前多早?簡單一句話,我時間到了,一個月,可不可以? | 
        
        | gazette.blocks[117][0] | 雷司長諶:一個月可能…… | 
        
        | gazette.blocks[118][0] | 劉委員建國:一個月不行?到時候我再拜託兩位召委排案,特別針對你們這部分的整個預警機制,看要怎麼回報。 | 
        
        | gazette.blocks[119][0] | 雷司長諶:我們儘速來處理。 | 
        
        | gazette.blocks[120][0] | 劉委員建國:一個月內我請他們兩位召委一定要排,做這樣的處理,好不好?謝謝。 | 
        
        | gazette.blocks[121][0] | 主席:好,謝謝劉建國委員。 | 
        
        | gazette.blocks[121][1] | 休息10分鐘。 | 
        
        | gazette.blocks[121][2] | 休息(10時42分) | 
        
        | gazette.blocks[121][3] | 繼續開會(10時54分) | 
        
        | gazette.blocks[122][0] | 主席:我們繼續開會。 | 
        
        | gazette.blocks[122][1] | 請黃秀芳委員質詢。 | 
        
        | gazette.agenda.page_end | 360 | 
        
        | gazette.agenda.meet_id | 委員會-11-2-26-9 | 
        
        | gazette.agenda.speakers[0] | 蘇清泉 | 
        
        | gazette.agenda.speakers[1] | 陳昭姿 | 
        
        | gazette.agenda.speakers[2] | 陳菁徽 | 
        
        | gazette.agenda.speakers[3] | 林淑芬 | 
        
        | gazette.agenda.speakers[4] | 王育敏 | 
        
        | gazette.agenda.speakers[5] | 劉建國 | 
        
        | gazette.agenda.speakers[6] | 黃秀芳 | 
        
        | gazette.agenda.speakers[7] | 王正旭 | 
        
        | gazette.agenda.speakers[8] | 林月琴 | 
        
        | gazette.agenda.speakers[9] | 邱鎮軍 | 
        
        | gazette.agenda.speakers[10] | 王育敏 | 
        
        | gazette.agenda.speakers[11] | 陳瑩 | 
        
        | gazette.agenda.speakers[12] | 楊曜 | 
        
        | gazette.agenda.speakers[13] | 涂權吉 | 
        
        | gazette.agenda.speakers[14] | 盧縣一 | 
        
        | gazette.agenda.speakers[15] | 廖偉翔 | 
        
        | gazette.agenda.speakers[16] | 郭國文 | 
        
        | gazette.agenda.speakers[17] | 楊瓊瓔 | 
        
        | gazette.agenda.speakers[18] | 黃健豪 | 
        
        | gazette.agenda.speakers[19] | 徐巧芯 | 
        
        | gazette.agenda.speakers[20] | 麥玉珍 | 
        
        | gazette.agenda.speakers[21] | 伍麗華Saidhai‧Tahovecahe | 
        
        | gazette.agenda.speakers[22] | 洪孟楷 | 
        
        | gazette.agenda.speakers[23] | 李彥秀 | 
        
        | gazette.agenda.speakers[24] | 黃國昌 | 
        
        | gazette.agenda.speakers[25] | 葉元之 | 
        
        | gazette.agenda.speakers[26] | 邱若華 | 
        
        | gazette.agenda.speakers[27] | 洪申翰 | 
        
        | gazette.agenda.speakers[28] | 牛煦庭 | 
        
        | gazette.agenda.speakers[29] | 羅智強 | 
        
        | gazette.agenda.speakers[30] | 鄭正鈐 | 
        
        | gazette.agenda.speakers[31] | 林倩綺 | 
        
        | gazette.agenda.speakers[32] | 羅廷瑋 | 
        
        | gazette.agenda.speakers[33] | 張雅琳 | 
        
        | gazette.agenda.speakers[34] | 林國成 | 
        
        | gazette.agenda.speakers[35] | 張嘉郡 | 
        
        | gazette.agenda.speakers[36] | 柯志恩 | 
        
        | gazette.agenda.speakers[37] | 萬美玲 | 
        
        | gazette.agenda.page_start | 231 | 
        
        | gazette.agenda.meetingDate[0] | 2024-11-20 | 
        
        | gazette.agenda.gazette_id | 11310201 | 
        
        | gazette.agenda.agenda_lcidc_ids[0] | 11310201_00010 | 
        
        | gazette.agenda.meet_name | 立法院第11屆第2會期社會福利及衛生環境委員會第9次全體委員會議紀錄 | 
        
        | gazette.agenda.content | 邀請勞動部部長、銓敘部、國防部、內政部警政署、內政部消防署、行政院人事行政總處、考試
院、公務人員保障暨培訓委員會、教育部及國家科學及技術委員會就「職場霸凌防治與處理作
業」進行專題報告,並備質詢 | 
        
        | gazette.agenda.agenda_id | 11310201_00012 |