iVOD / 170897

本逐字稿內容由 AI 自動生成,可能包含錯誤、遺漏或誤譯之處。請使用者務必與原始影片音訊內容交叉比對,以確保資訊正確性。另可參考立法院日後釋出的正式公報以取得最終權威版本。

賴士葆 @

Start Time End Time Text
00:00:00,000 00:00:15,440 謝謝主席江副院長以及各位先進
00:00:15,440 00:00:21,720 還有我們的監察院副院長被提名人王先生
00:00:21,720 00:00:24,920 以及各位先進大家早安大家好
00:00:25,880 00:00:28,360 你我是同事
00:00:28,360 00:00:30,680 在立法院財政委員會
00:00:30,680 00:00:33,760 我們那時候老實講我對你滿欣賞的
00:00:33,760 00:00:36,760 你堅持著公平正義
00:00:36,760 00:00:39,560 雖然你是民進黨的不溫區
00:00:39,560 00:00:40,840 你敢放炮
00:00:40,840 00:00:44,360 可是你進到監察院以後
00:00:44,360 00:00:45,880 變一個人啦
00:00:45,880 00:00:49,880 變一個最混的監委
00:00:49,880 00:00:51,960 最懶惰的監委
00:00:52,920 00:00:56,560 最聽話的監委聽誰的聽行政院的
00:00:56,560 00:00:59,800 你王龍章的代表
00:00:59,800 00:01:03,240 徹底的把監察院內閣化
00:01:03,240 00:01:05,120 把自我矮化
00:01:05,120 00:01:08,320 我還沒讓你講你先不要講
00:01:08,320 00:01:14,600 把監察院逐漸變成行政院的監察局
00:01:14,600 00:01:18,400 你現在來看大家統計啦
00:01:18,440 00:01:22,120 你的六年論內只有一件彈劾案
00:01:22,120 00:01:24,880 六件糾正案
00:01:24,880 00:01:28,880 二十五件的整個調查
00:01:28,880 00:01:30,600 這樣成績你怎麼好意思說
00:01:30,600 00:01:33,360 你要接受監察院的副院長
00:01:33,360 00:01:35,320 又再受傷
00:01:35,320 00:01:36,560 怎麼好意思
00:01:36,560 00:01:40,480 如果我是你啊修產的
00:01:40,480 00:01:42,200 他為什麼提名你就簡單啊
00:01:42,200 00:01:44,280 因為你的成績最爛
00:01:44,280 00:01:46,000 他就提名一個最爛的
00:01:46,040 00:01:47,840 那我們來砍
00:01:47,840 00:01:49,800 順勢的把監察院廢掉
00:01:49,800 00:01:52,040 所以王龍章是指標人物啊
00:01:52,040 00:01:53,280 你成績最爛
00:01:53,280 00:01:55,560 所有的監委裡面
00:01:55,560 00:01:58,480 二十幾個監委裡面你成績最爛
00:01:58,480 00:01:59,400 然後呢
00:01:59,400 00:02:01,400 你剛剛講的什麼什麼國防部
00:02:01,400 00:02:03,240 那都不痛不癢
00:02:03,240 00:02:05,520 對於行政院貴黨
00:02:05,520 00:02:09,600 民進黨的這些高官你碰都不敢碰
00:02:09,600 00:02:13,000 比如說高端的事件
00:02:13,040 00:02:17,040 2021年3加11爆發了
00:02:17,040 00:02:17,840 到現在為止
00:02:17,840 00:02:20,120 會議紀錄也沒有
00:02:20,120 00:02:22,840 說有監委提出來
00:02:22,840 00:02:26,520 要約談陳時中
00:02:26,520 00:02:28,600 這個委員就沒有你啊
00:02:28,600 00:02:29,320 有誰呢
00:02:29,320 00:02:31,280 我就點名給他表揚一下
00:02:31,280 00:02:32,920 敢提出來的
00:02:32,920 00:02:34,240 普總成
00:02:34,240 00:02:35,840 林立雄
00:02:35,840 00:02:36,920 王立榮
00:02:36,920 00:02:38,280 蕭志祐
00:02:38,280 00:02:39,920 王又龍
00:02:39,920 00:02:42,920 以及林美玉
00:02:43,839 00:02:46,040 好你最關心的人權
00:02:46,040 00:02:47,600 人他那份事
00:02:47,600 00:02:51,040 事路人事路的方向去調查
00:02:51,040 00:02:52,679 高端的事情
00:02:52,679 00:02:55,560 結果人權的東西就是王又齡跟林美玉
00:02:55,560 00:02:57,679 也沒有王龍章啊
00:02:57,679 00:03:00,640 這社會多麼重大的高端事情
00:03:00,640 00:03:02,560 你可以看到陳時中最近在講這些
00:03:02,560 00:03:04,679 五十三的
00:03:04,679 00:03:06,600 實際
00:03:06,600 00:03:08,320
00:03:08,320 00:03:10,440 裡面前客的弊端
00:03:10,440 00:03:11,839 那是一件事情
00:03:11,840 00:03:14,840 跟陳時中那時候
00:03:14,840 00:03:17,160 百般的阻撓
00:03:17,160 00:03:18,400 讓疫苗進來
00:03:18,400 00:03:20,560 就是護著大家打高端
00:03:20,560 00:03:22,600 委員請問需要我回答
00:03:22,600 00:03:23,360 不要急
00:03:23,360 00:03:25,240 我會讓你講
00:03:25,240 00:03:26,600 2021年
00:03:26,600 00:03:31,200 因為這樣一路把高端的股票炒到417塊
00:03:31,200 00:03:34,160 現在高端的股票50塊左右
00:03:34,160 00:03:35,520 總共
00:03:35,520 00:03:39,320 總共市值增發了600億之多
00:03:39,359 00:03:42,320 受害的人四萬人左右
00:03:42,320 00:03:44,799 這個也是人權問題
00:03:44,799 00:03:45,760 這個經濟問題
00:03:45,760 00:03:49,519 這裡面沒有看到王龍章任何一丁點
00:03:49,519 00:03:51,239 再來也看到
00:03:51,239 00:03:53,320 超失雞蛋
00:03:53,320 00:03:54,760 離譜的一套糊塗
00:03:54,760 00:03:56,560 你也都沒有動身色
00:03:56,560 00:03:58,120 光電閉案
00:03:58,120 00:03:59,560 你也都沒有動
00:03:59,560 00:04:00,959 所以這個監委
00:04:00,959 00:04:02,760 老實講這不是你而已
00:04:02,760 00:04:05,359 就是整個監察院是爛掉的
00:04:05,359 00:04:08,560 監察院把自己矮化成為
00:04:08,560 00:04:11,080 行政院的監察局
00:04:11,080 00:04:12,840 然後這幾個立委
00:04:12,840 00:04:14,640 要約談陳時中
00:04:14,640 00:04:17,640 被蘇貞昌吼下去
00:04:17,640 00:04:19,079 大家都生氣了
00:04:19,079 00:04:20,040 到現在為止
00:04:20,040 00:04:21,160 沒有人敢講話
00:04:21,160 00:04:22,240 包括你在內
00:04:22,240 00:04:23,120 一句都不吭
00:04:23,120 00:04:25,920 請問高端事情你有吭一句話嗎
00:04:25,920 00:04:27,440 一句話也沒有啊
00:04:27,440 00:04:29,440 王龍章這個監委
00:04:29,440 00:04:30,760 你一句話都沒有
00:04:30,760 00:04:31,880 我就想到說
00:04:31,880 00:04:34,200 這是我認識的王龍章嗎
00:04:34,200 00:04:36,320 以前在裁員會的時候
00:04:36,360 00:04:37,640 病病叫啊
00:04:37,640 00:04:39,000 還敢講這個講那個
00:04:39,000 00:04:41,080 監委歸說啊
00:04:41,080 00:04:42,400 一路歸說到底
00:04:42,400 00:04:44,200 六年
00:04:44,200 00:04:46,120 只有一件彈劾案
00:04:46,120 00:04:47,480 一年不到一件
00:04:47,480 00:04:49,080 只有六件糾正案
00:04:49,080 00:04:50,920 包括你剛剛講的國防部
00:04:50,920 00:04:51,760 一年一件
00:04:51,760 00:04:53,680 吼你這個官有夠好做啊
00:04:53,680 00:04:54,840 還要有辦法說
00:04:54,840 00:04:56,800 我就不要人家講你失德了
00:04:56,800 00:04:58,640 你用高風車去洗你的愛狗
00:04:58,640 00:05:00,039 這個我就不談了
00:05:00,039 00:05:01,320 我跟你談政策的東西
00:05:01,320 00:05:02,920 我以為你搞錯了
00:05:02,920 00:05:04,120 政策的東西
00:05:04,120 00:05:04,800 你先不要去
00:05:04,840 00:05:06,320 我先把問題講完
00:05:06,320 00:05:07,920 我把問題講完
00:05:07,920 00:05:08,680 你回答吧
00:05:08,680 00:05:10,280 你為什麼這麼懶惰
00:05:10,280 00:05:11,560 這麼混
00:05:11,560 00:05:12,640 績效這麼差
00:05:12,640 00:05:14,080 你講一下為什麼
00:05:14,080 00:05:14,920
00:05:14,920 00:05:16,600 向賴委員說明啊
00:05:16,600 00:05:17,760 王龍章
00:05:17,760 00:05:20,160 還是王龍章
00:05:20,160 00:05:21,360 在監察院的王龍章
00:05:21,360 00:05:22,480 你其實對我來講王龍章嗎
00:05:22,480 00:05:24,240 還是在立法院的王龍章
00:05:24,240 00:05:24,600
00:05:24,600 00:05:25,360 同一個人
00:05:25,360 00:05:27,960 我的作法跟我的原則沒有改變
00:05:27,960 00:05:30,840 我剛剛回答多位的委員
00:05:30,840 00:05:32,080 對於就說的
00:05:32,080 00:05:34,200 職權的行使的這個部分
00:05:34,240 00:05:36,200 我的選擇決定
00:05:36,200 00:05:38,159 符合國際的要求跟標準
00:05:38,159 00:05:41,280 在於人權相關的案件裡面
00:05:41,280 00:05:43,280 在人權的工作裡面
00:05:43,280 00:05:45,560 人權的就是說工作裡面
00:05:45,560 00:05:46,800 偉大東西也沒有啊
00:05:46,800 00:05:48,560 你人權有什麼偉大東西
00:05:48,560 00:05:49,360 你問人權
00:05:49,360 00:05:50,080 你講一個跡象
00:05:50,080 00:05:51,760 也沒什麼偉大東西啊
00:05:51,760 00:05:53,760 王龍章的國家人權委員會
00:05:53,760 00:05:55,039 人權來講
00:05:55,039 00:05:57,000 你沒有什麼東西拿出來啊
00:05:57,000 00:05:59,200 我剛剛在口頭報告裡面
00:05:59,200 00:06:01,480 有做了相關的說明
00:06:01,480 00:06:02,719 國家人權委員會
00:06:02,719 00:06:03,000 好啦
00:06:03,000 00:06:06,360 在第一屆是一個新設的機關
00:06:06,360 00:06:07,640 新設的組合
00:06:07,640 00:06:08,760 你回答我
00:06:08,760 00:06:10,480 委員你不需要我說明
00:06:10,480 00:06:11,680 你只是希望
00:06:11,680 00:06:12,680 你只是要講
00:06:12,680 00:06:14,680 你跟我講教科書的我不要聽
00:06:14,680 00:06:16,080 然後就說
00:06:16,080 00:06:17,640 還有一個部分的話
00:06:17,640 00:06:20,840 不屬於監察委員的職權範圍裡面
00:06:20,840 00:06:21,640 或者是說
00:06:21,640 00:06:21,960
00:06:21,960 00:06:23,560 委員沒有經過調查
00:06:23,560 00:06:24,560 你講這些教科書
00:06:24,560 00:06:26,000 你不要給我亂時間
00:06:26,000 00:06:27,400 你現在互相互衡的時間不行
00:06:27,400 00:06:28,160 我跟你講
00:06:28,160 00:06:29,200 那你就講
00:06:29,200 00:06:31,080 人權你有沒有彈劾哪一位官員
00:06:31,080 00:06:31,800 所有人權問題
00:06:31,800 00:06:32,880 霸凌
00:06:32,880 00:06:34,360 霸凌有沒有彈劾
00:06:34,360 00:06:36,360 人權會的工作
00:06:36,360 00:06:37,680 只有建議權
00:06:37,680 00:06:38,480 調查權
00:06:38,480 00:06:39,880 有沒有建議彈劾
00:06:39,880 00:06:44,000 在光紙在CRPD的這個部分的話
00:06:44,000 00:06:44,840 然後都不能霸凌
00:06:44,840 00:06:47,040 我提出了兩百多項
00:06:47,040 00:06:48,360 對於行政
00:06:48,360 00:06:49,880 就是說我們行政部門的
00:06:49,880 00:06:52,320 就是說做法不同的意見
00:06:52,320 00:06:54,520 國際審查的報告裡面的的話
00:06:54,520 00:06:56,320 我提出了兩百多項
00:06:56,320 00:06:58,120 你現在用教科書的事
00:06:58,120 00:06:59,920 如果只有你認為的
00:06:59,920 00:07:01,440 就是說才是事實
00:07:01,480 00:07:03,400 然後對於事實的數據
00:07:03,400 00:07:05,240 都不予採認的話
00:07:05,240 00:07:07,880 我想這樣子的質詢的話
00:07:07,880 00:07:11,840 是沒有辦法到真相的層次
00:07:11,840 00:07:12,840 你沒有辦法
00:07:12,840 00:07:14,440 讓我做出那種說明
00:07:14,440 00:07:15,160 可以了
00:07:15,160 00:07:16,840 因為你都用教科書來給我
00:07:16,840 00:07:18,280 讓我有了時間
00:07:18,280 00:07:19,480 大家最矚目的
00:07:19,480 00:07:21,520 時間應該是我們共有的
00:07:21,520 00:07:25,080 勞動部的長官霸凌不下
00:07:25,080 00:07:27,000 你有沒有參與人權問題
00:07:27,000 00:07:27,520 人權問題
00:07:27,520 00:07:28,400 那個部分的話
00:07:28,400 00:07:31,159 監察院的規定
00:07:31,200 00:07:33,840 一個調查案件裡面的話
00:07:33,840 00:07:36,360 最多只能夠有三個委員參與
00:07:36,360 00:07:38,840 在這裡裡面的話
00:07:38,840 00:07:39,920 對就是說
00:07:39,920 00:07:42,120 這個部分有關於
00:07:42,120 00:07:44,280 就是說調查的這個部分
00:07:44,280 00:07:46,680 我剛剛一開始的時候就承認
00:07:46,680 00:07:49,880 不是我在這個三任委員的工作的
00:07:49,880 00:07:51,560 就是說重心
00:07:51,560 00:07:54,880 委員如果只有認為您關心的議題
00:07:54,880 00:07:56,800 然後才是重要的
00:07:56,800 00:07:58,680 那其他的人群人
00:07:58,720 00:08:00,200 社會關心
00:08:00,200 00:08:02,000 每天新聞這麼大
00:08:02,000 00:08:04,920 人權的議題不重要的話
00:08:04,920 00:08:06,800 我想就是說在這樣子的情況
00:08:06,800 00:08:07,920 關員的霸凌
00:08:07,920 00:08:08,920 我也沒有辦法
00:08:08,920 00:08:10,120 就是我只能夠
00:08:10,120 00:08:11,800 就是說尊重您個人的意見
00:08:11,800 00:08:14,840 你回答的問題都沒辦法說服我
00:08:14,840 00:08:17,320 你是基校最差
00:08:17,320 00:08:18,480 團的人數最少
00:08:18,480 00:08:19,960 我當然沒有辦法說服你
00:08:19,960 00:08:21,280 最混
00:08:21,280 00:08:22,640 最擺爛的一個節目
00:08:22,640 00:08:23,640 我不接受
00:08:23,640 00:08:24,560 我不接受
00:08:24,560 00:08:25,560 那我就告訴你
00:08:25,560 00:08:27,360 這個部分可受社會公平
00:08:27,400 00:08:30,000 是 您這樣子的指責跟指控
00:08:30,000 00:08:30,840 我不接受
00:08:30,840 00:08:32,520 你們歐來講
00:08:32,520 00:08:33,840 監委都是很混的
00:08:33,840 00:08:35,760 因為基校都非常差
00:08:35,760 00:08:39,280 委員講的這樣子的評論是不公平
00:08:39,280 00:08:40,720 是不正確的
00:08:40,720 00:08:41,919 停了 停了
00:08:41,919 00:08:44,520 我來給你念給你聽
00:08:44,520 00:08:47,800 第六屆總共人民申請的案件
00:08:47,800 00:08:49,840 八點六案件
00:08:49,840 00:08:51,320 第六屆就這一屆
00:08:51,320 00:08:52,680 你這一屆
00:08:52,680 00:08:55,120 總共調查1541
00:08:55,160 00:08:57,560 九正案481
00:08:57,560 00:09:00,200 彈劾案120
00:09:00,200 00:09:03,800 第五屆人民請願八點六案件
00:09:03,800 00:09:05,240 結果第五屆
00:09:05,240 00:09:07,120 九正966
00:09:07,120 00:09:08,120 263
00:09:08,120 00:09:08,920 彈劾
00:09:08,920 00:09:10,840 這基校越來越差
00:09:10,840 00:09:13,440 王老五過年一年不如一年
00:09:13,440 00:09:15,760 你們的監委不是只有你而已
00:09:15,760 00:09:17,720 所有的監委都在混
00:09:17,720 00:09:20,320 監察院真的可以廢掉
00:09:20,320 00:09:21,240 學員
00:09:21,240 00:09:24,160 如果都是用數量來看的
00:09:24,199 00:09:25,120 這不是公平的
00:09:25,120 00:09:26,240 怎麼不公平奇怪
00:09:26,240 00:09:28,800 然後我想委員也應該會同意
00:09:28,800 00:09:33,120 在立法院提案最多的立法案件的委員
00:09:33,120 00:09:35,319 不一定是最優秀的委員
00:09:35,319 00:09:38,560 同樣的我在之前查過
00:09:38,560 00:09:41,560 在立法院的承諾案
00:09:41,560 00:09:43,719 立法院的最多承諾案
00:09:43,719 00:09:47,839 在去年一共有483件
00:09:47,839 00:09:50,280 但是就是說在這個部分
00:09:50,280 00:09:52,480 委員會就是說
00:09:52,520 00:09:54,320 你承案的一件都沒有
00:09:54,320 00:09:55,480 你成功的脫落了
00:09:55,480 00:09:56,480 實驗我最後一件
00:09:56,480 00:09:57,240 一件都沒有
00:09:57,240 00:09:58,920 我總結一句話
00:09:58,920 00:10:00,480 但是我不認為一監察
00:10:00,480 00:10:02,560 立法院在部分的的話
00:10:02,560 00:10:04,520 是能夠無效
00:10:04,520 00:10:08,600 你用公務書去洗你的愛狗
00:10:08,600 00:10:09,760 私德方面
00:10:09,760 00:10:10,760 我以為你搞錯了
00:10:10,760 00:10:11,760 你不配當監委
00:10:11,760 00:10:12,760 我沒有養狗
00:10:12,760 00:10:14,320 因為我沒有洗愛狗
00:10:14,320 00:10:16,080 第二個你不配當監委
00:10:16,080 00:10:18,080 第二個就是你的技巧
00:10:18,080 00:10:19,360 我沒有你的
00:10:19,360 00:10:20,400 所以
00:10:20,400 00:10:22,439