iVOD / 158106

Field Value
IVOD_ID 158106
IVOD_URL https://ivod.ly.gov.tw/Play/Clip/1M/158106
日期 2024-12-12
影片種類 Clip
開始時間 2024-12-12T11:31:58+08:00
結束時間 2024-12-12T11:52:05+08:00
影片長度 00:20:07
支援功能[0] ai-transcript
video_url https://ivod-lyvod.cdn.hinet.net/vod_1/_definst_/mp4:1MClips/50d02d9c955f8e2d932b42ebf8c01e060341d36cd1de3acc905041b311685818d25b08c110ea79ab5ea18f28b6918d91.mp4/playlist.m3u8
委員名稱 陳玉珍
委員發言時間 11:31:58 - 11:52:05
會議時間 2024-12-12T09:00:00+08:00
會議名稱 第11屆第2會期第2次全院委員會(事由:總統咨,茲依據中華民國憲法增修條文第5條規定,提名張文貞、姚立明、何賴傑、陳運財、王碧芳、廖福特、劉靜怡7位為司法院大法官,並以張文貞為院長、姚立明為副院長,咨請同意案。)
transcript.pyannote[0].speaker SPEAKER_02
transcript.pyannote[0].start 1.75221875
transcript.pyannote[0].end 6.37596875
transcript.pyannote[1].speaker SPEAKER_02
transcript.pyannote[1].start 6.51096875
transcript.pyannote[1].end 36.63284375
transcript.pyannote[2].speaker SPEAKER_02
transcript.pyannote[2].start 36.93659375
transcript.pyannote[2].end 39.61971875
transcript.pyannote[3].speaker SPEAKER_02
transcript.pyannote[3].start 39.95721875
transcript.pyannote[3].end 50.85846875
transcript.pyannote[4].speaker SPEAKER_02
transcript.pyannote[4].start 51.33096875
transcript.pyannote[4].end 54.11534375
transcript.pyannote[5].speaker SPEAKER_02
transcript.pyannote[5].start 55.07721875
transcript.pyannote[5].end 55.80284375
transcript.pyannote[6].speaker SPEAKER_02
transcript.pyannote[6].start 56.51159375
transcript.pyannote[6].end 62.33346875
transcript.pyannote[7].speaker SPEAKER_02
transcript.pyannote[7].start 62.73846875
transcript.pyannote[7].end 65.97846875
transcript.pyannote[8].speaker SPEAKER_02
transcript.pyannote[8].start 66.33284375
transcript.pyannote[8].end 76.47471875
transcript.pyannote[9].speaker SPEAKER_02
transcript.pyannote[9].start 76.72784375
transcript.pyannote[9].end 87.52784375
transcript.pyannote[10].speaker SPEAKER_02
transcript.pyannote[10].start 87.79784375
transcript.pyannote[10].end 99.76221875
transcript.pyannote[11].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[11].start 100.21784375
transcript.pyannote[11].end 100.79159375
transcript.pyannote[12].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[12].start 101.28096875
transcript.pyannote[12].end 102.90096875
transcript.pyannote[13].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[13].start 102.96846875
transcript.pyannote[13].end 108.55409375
transcript.pyannote[14].speaker SPEAKER_02
transcript.pyannote[14].start 106.61346875
transcript.pyannote[14].end 106.90034375
transcript.pyannote[15].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[15].start 108.75659375
transcript.pyannote[15].end 119.72534375
transcript.pyannote[16].speaker SPEAKER_02
transcript.pyannote[16].start 115.18596875
transcript.pyannote[16].end 116.26596875
transcript.pyannote[17].speaker SPEAKER_03
transcript.pyannote[17].start 119.21909375
transcript.pyannote[17].end 119.23596875
transcript.pyannote[18].speaker SPEAKER_02
transcript.pyannote[18].start 119.23596875
transcript.pyannote[18].end 119.96159375
transcript.pyannote[19].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[19].start 120.23159375
transcript.pyannote[19].end 120.45096875
transcript.pyannote[20].speaker SPEAKER_02
transcript.pyannote[20].start 120.45096875
transcript.pyannote[20].end 120.61971875
transcript.pyannote[21].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[21].start 120.61971875
transcript.pyannote[21].end 123.74159375
transcript.pyannote[22].speaker SPEAKER_02
transcript.pyannote[22].start 120.67034375
transcript.pyannote[22].end 121.44659375
transcript.pyannote[23].speaker SPEAKER_02
transcript.pyannote[23].start 122.66159375
transcript.pyannote[23].end 127.26846875
transcript.pyannote[24].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[24].start 124.02846875
transcript.pyannote[24].end 124.38284375
transcript.pyannote[25].speaker SPEAKER_02
transcript.pyannote[25].start 127.67346875
transcript.pyannote[25].end 137.29221875
transcript.pyannote[26].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[26].start 128.31471875
transcript.pyannote[26].end 128.77034375
transcript.pyannote[27].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[27].start 137.64659375
transcript.pyannote[27].end 149.17221875
transcript.pyannote[28].speaker SPEAKER_03
transcript.pyannote[28].start 147.38346875
transcript.pyannote[28].end 147.73784375
transcript.pyannote[29].speaker SPEAKER_03
transcript.pyannote[29].start 149.49284375
transcript.pyannote[29].end 149.56034375
transcript.pyannote[30].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[30].start 149.72909375
transcript.pyannote[30].end 156.86721875
transcript.pyannote[31].speaker SPEAKER_03
transcript.pyannote[31].start 150.77534375
transcript.pyannote[31].end 151.97346875
transcript.pyannote[32].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[32].start 151.97346875
transcript.pyannote[32].end 152.02409375
transcript.pyannote[33].speaker SPEAKER_02
transcript.pyannote[33].start 152.02409375
transcript.pyannote[33].end 154.01534375
transcript.pyannote[34].speaker SPEAKER_02
transcript.pyannote[34].start 156.86721875
transcript.pyannote[34].end 159.16221875
transcript.pyannote[35].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[35].start 156.88409375
transcript.pyannote[35].end 156.96846875
transcript.pyannote[36].speaker SPEAKER_02
transcript.pyannote[36].start 159.76971875
transcript.pyannote[36].end 189.45284375
transcript.pyannote[37].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[37].start 159.92159375
transcript.pyannote[37].end 160.51221875
transcript.pyannote[38].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[38].start 165.94596875
transcript.pyannote[38].end 166.38471875
transcript.pyannote[39].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[39].start 175.71659375
transcript.pyannote[39].end 175.75034375
transcript.pyannote[40].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[40].start 175.75034375
transcript.pyannote[40].end 176.10471875
transcript.pyannote[41].speaker SPEAKER_02
transcript.pyannote[41].start 190.02659375
transcript.pyannote[41].end 217.12784375
transcript.pyannote[42].speaker SPEAKER_02
transcript.pyannote[42].start 217.43159375
transcript.pyannote[42].end 231.52221875
transcript.pyannote[43].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[43].start 231.74159375
transcript.pyannote[43].end 235.48784375
transcript.pyannote[44].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[44].start 235.90971875
transcript.pyannote[44].end 240.58409375
transcript.pyannote[45].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[45].start 240.58409375
transcript.pyannote[45].end 240.60096875
transcript.pyannote[46].speaker SPEAKER_02
transcript.pyannote[46].start 240.60096875
transcript.pyannote[46].end 242.67659375
transcript.pyannote[47].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[47].start 241.02284375
transcript.pyannote[47].end 242.00159375
transcript.pyannote[48].speaker SPEAKER_02
transcript.pyannote[48].start 243.03096875
transcript.pyannote[48].end 249.47721875
transcript.pyannote[49].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[49].start 249.32534375
transcript.pyannote[49].end 250.25346875
transcript.pyannote[50].speaker SPEAKER_02
transcript.pyannote[50].start 249.49409375
transcript.pyannote[50].end 252.07596875
transcript.pyannote[51].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[51].start 251.56971875
transcript.pyannote[51].end 256.64909375
transcript.pyannote[52].speaker SPEAKER_02
transcript.pyannote[52].start 254.67471875
transcript.pyannote[52].end 254.80971875
transcript.pyannote[53].speaker SPEAKER_02
transcript.pyannote[53].start 256.14284375
transcript.pyannote[53].end 259.43346875
transcript.pyannote[54].speaker SPEAKER_02
transcript.pyannote[54].start 259.75409375
transcript.pyannote[54].end 272.47784375
transcript.pyannote[55].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[55].start 271.07721875
transcript.pyannote[55].end 275.65034375
transcript.pyannote[56].speaker SPEAKER_02
transcript.pyannote[56].start 275.65034375
transcript.pyannote[56].end 287.66534375
transcript.pyannote[57].speaker SPEAKER_02
transcript.pyannote[57].start 288.05346875
transcript.pyannote[57].end 291.69846875
transcript.pyannote[58].speaker SPEAKER_02
transcript.pyannote[58].start 292.05284375
transcript.pyannote[58].end 299.10659375
transcript.pyannote[59].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[59].start 292.60971875
transcript.pyannote[59].end 293.14971875
transcript.pyannote[60].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[60].start 297.92534375
transcript.pyannote[60].end 298.26284375
transcript.pyannote[61].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[61].start 299.62971875
transcript.pyannote[61].end 305.70471875
transcript.pyannote[62].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[62].start 306.02534375
transcript.pyannote[62].end 317.77034375
transcript.pyannote[63].speaker SPEAKER_02
transcript.pyannote[63].start 313.68659375
transcript.pyannote[63].end 313.72034375
transcript.pyannote[64].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[64].start 313.72034375
transcript.pyannote[64].end 315.39096875
transcript.pyannote[65].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[65].start 318.04034375
transcript.pyannote[65].end 320.38596875
transcript.pyannote[66].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[66].start 321.31409375
transcript.pyannote[66].end 328.51971875
transcript.pyannote[67].speaker SPEAKER_02
transcript.pyannote[67].start 328.51971875
transcript.pyannote[67].end 332.01284375
transcript.pyannote[68].speaker SPEAKER_02
transcript.pyannote[68].start 332.24909375
transcript.pyannote[68].end 364.85159375
transcript.pyannote[69].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[69].start 332.67096875
transcript.pyannote[69].end 333.14346875
transcript.pyannote[70].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[70].start 335.92784375
transcript.pyannote[70].end 337.56471875
transcript.pyannote[71].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[71].start 339.37034375
transcript.pyannote[71].end 341.05784375
transcript.pyannote[72].speaker SPEAKER_03
transcript.pyannote[72].start 341.85096875
transcript.pyannote[72].end 341.86784375
transcript.pyannote[73].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[73].start 341.86784375
transcript.pyannote[73].end 343.97721875
transcript.pyannote[74].speaker SPEAKER_03
transcript.pyannote[74].start 343.97721875
transcript.pyannote[74].end 344.09534375
transcript.pyannote[75].speaker SPEAKER_02
transcript.pyannote[75].start 365.07096875
transcript.pyannote[75].end 369.57659375
transcript.pyannote[76].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[76].start 370.35284375
transcript.pyannote[76].end 370.38659375
transcript.pyannote[77].speaker SPEAKER_02
transcript.pyannote[77].start 370.38659375
transcript.pyannote[77].end 383.02596875
transcript.pyannote[78].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[78].start 383.02596875
transcript.pyannote[78].end 388.51034375
transcript.pyannote[79].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[79].start 388.64534375
transcript.pyannote[79].end 391.36221875
transcript.pyannote[80].speaker SPEAKER_02
transcript.pyannote[80].start 391.34534375
transcript.pyannote[80].end 392.67846875
transcript.pyannote[81].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[81].start 392.67846875
transcript.pyannote[81].end 394.48409375
transcript.pyannote[82].speaker SPEAKER_02
transcript.pyannote[82].start 392.88096875
transcript.pyannote[82].end 417.70409375
transcript.pyannote[83].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[83].start 394.97346875
transcript.pyannote[83].end 396.96471875
transcript.pyannote[84].speaker SPEAKER_03
transcript.pyannote[84].start 396.96471875
transcript.pyannote[84].end 397.06596875
transcript.pyannote[85].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[85].start 397.06596875
transcript.pyannote[85].end 397.16721875
transcript.pyannote[86].speaker SPEAKER_03
transcript.pyannote[86].start 397.16721875
transcript.pyannote[86].end 397.23471875
transcript.pyannote[87].speaker SPEAKER_02
transcript.pyannote[87].start 417.87284375
transcript.pyannote[87].end 442.83096875
transcript.pyannote[88].speaker SPEAKER_02
transcript.pyannote[88].start 442.94909375
transcript.pyannote[88].end 445.29471875
transcript.pyannote[89].speaker SPEAKER_02
transcript.pyannote[89].start 445.93596875
transcript.pyannote[89].end 458.54159375
transcript.pyannote[90].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[90].start 446.62784375
transcript.pyannote[90].end 447.21846875
transcript.pyannote[91].speaker SPEAKER_02
transcript.pyannote[91].start 459.01409375
transcript.pyannote[91].end 474.55596875
transcript.pyannote[92].speaker SPEAKER_02
transcript.pyannote[92].start 475.07909375
transcript.pyannote[92].end 479.24721875
transcript.pyannote[93].speaker SPEAKER_02
transcript.pyannote[93].start 479.51721875
transcript.pyannote[93].end 484.19159375
transcript.pyannote[94].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[94].start 483.90471875
transcript.pyannote[94].end 485.44034375
transcript.pyannote[95].speaker SPEAKER_02
transcript.pyannote[95].start 484.47846875
transcript.pyannote[95].end 486.79034375
transcript.pyannote[96].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[96].start 486.46971875
transcript.pyannote[96].end 491.73471875
transcript.pyannote[97].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[97].start 492.07221875
transcript.pyannote[97].end 492.35909375
transcript.pyannote[98].speaker SPEAKER_02
transcript.pyannote[98].start 492.25784375
transcript.pyannote[98].end 492.47721875
transcript.pyannote[99].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[99].start 492.47721875
transcript.pyannote[99].end 495.66659375
transcript.pyannote[100].speaker SPEAKER_02
transcript.pyannote[100].start 495.24471875
transcript.pyannote[100].end 497.86034375
transcript.pyannote[101].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[101].start 497.33721875
transcript.pyannote[101].end 500.66159375
transcript.pyannote[102].speaker SPEAKER_02
transcript.pyannote[102].start 498.45096875
transcript.pyannote[102].end 499.48034375
transcript.pyannote[103].speaker SPEAKER_02
transcript.pyannote[103].start 500.08784375
transcript.pyannote[103].end 512.84534375
transcript.pyannote[104].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[104].start 513.08159375
transcript.pyannote[104].end 519.30846875
transcript.pyannote[105].speaker SPEAKER_02
transcript.pyannote[105].start 519.27471875
transcript.pyannote[105].end 519.76409375
transcript.pyannote[106].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[106].start 519.59534375
transcript.pyannote[106].end 524.75909375
transcript.pyannote[107].speaker SPEAKER_02
transcript.pyannote[107].start 524.25284375
transcript.pyannote[107].end 552.85596875
transcript.pyannote[108].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[108].start 527.88096875
transcript.pyannote[108].end 527.96534375
transcript.pyannote[109].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[109].start 550.24034375
transcript.pyannote[109].end 551.87721875
transcript.pyannote[110].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[110].start 552.88971875
transcript.pyannote[110].end 556.75409375
transcript.pyannote[111].speaker SPEAKER_02
transcript.pyannote[111].start 554.49284375
transcript.pyannote[111].end 561.68159375
transcript.pyannote[112].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[112].start 559.90971875
transcript.pyannote[112].end 569.79846875
transcript.pyannote[113].speaker SPEAKER_02
transcript.pyannote[113].start 569.78159375
transcript.pyannote[113].end 582.79221875
transcript.pyannote[114].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[114].start 570.15284375
transcript.pyannote[114].end 571.01346875
transcript.pyannote[115].speaker SPEAKER_02
transcript.pyannote[115].start 583.53471875
transcript.pyannote[115].end 595.38096875
transcript.pyannote[116].speaker SPEAKER_02
transcript.pyannote[116].start 595.92096875
transcript.pyannote[116].end 608.79659375
transcript.pyannote[117].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[117].start 596.71409375
transcript.pyannote[117].end 596.81534375
transcript.pyannote[118].speaker SPEAKER_03
transcript.pyannote[118].start 596.81534375
transcript.pyannote[118].end 596.96721875
transcript.pyannote[119].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[119].start 596.96721875
transcript.pyannote[119].end 598.03034375
transcript.pyannote[120].speaker SPEAKER_03
transcript.pyannote[120].start 598.03034375
transcript.pyannote[120].end 598.36784375
transcript.pyannote[121].speaker SPEAKER_02
transcript.pyannote[121].start 609.58971875
transcript.pyannote[121].end 610.55159375
transcript.pyannote[122].speaker SPEAKER_02
transcript.pyannote[122].start 610.77096875
transcript.pyannote[122].end 611.42909375
transcript.pyannote[123].speaker SPEAKER_02
transcript.pyannote[123].start 611.58096875
transcript.pyannote[123].end 620.37284375
transcript.pyannote[124].speaker SPEAKER_02
transcript.pyannote[124].start 620.49096875
transcript.pyannote[124].end 621.53721875
transcript.pyannote[125].speaker SPEAKER_02
transcript.pyannote[125].start 622.11096875
transcript.pyannote[125].end 624.35534375
transcript.pyannote[126].speaker SPEAKER_02
transcript.pyannote[126].start 624.79409375
transcript.pyannote[126].end 628.55721875
transcript.pyannote[127].speaker SPEAKER_02
transcript.pyannote[127].start 628.91159375
transcript.pyannote[127].end 629.26596875
transcript.pyannote[128].speaker SPEAKER_02
transcript.pyannote[128].start 629.40096875
transcript.pyannote[128].end 630.02534375
transcript.pyannote[129].speaker SPEAKER_02
transcript.pyannote[129].start 630.27846875
transcript.pyannote[129].end 632.15159375
transcript.pyannote[130].speaker SPEAKER_02
transcript.pyannote[130].start 632.50596875
transcript.pyannote[130].end 632.80971875
transcript.pyannote[131].speaker SPEAKER_02
transcript.pyannote[131].start 634.09221875
transcript.pyannote[131].end 634.64909375
transcript.pyannote[132].speaker SPEAKER_02
transcript.pyannote[132].start 634.88534375
transcript.pyannote[132].end 637.48409375
transcript.pyannote[133].speaker SPEAKER_02
transcript.pyannote[133].start 637.82159375
transcript.pyannote[133].end 639.64409375
transcript.pyannote[134].speaker SPEAKER_02
transcript.pyannote[134].start 639.84659375
transcript.pyannote[134].end 643.62659375
transcript.pyannote[135].speaker SPEAKER_02
transcript.pyannote[135].start 643.72784375
transcript.pyannote[135].end 646.25909375
transcript.pyannote[136].speaker SPEAKER_02
transcript.pyannote[136].start 646.84971875
transcript.pyannote[136].end 648.79034375
transcript.pyannote[137].speaker SPEAKER_02
transcript.pyannote[137].start 649.02659375
transcript.pyannote[137].end 653.85284375
transcript.pyannote[138].speaker SPEAKER_02
transcript.pyannote[138].start 654.76409375
transcript.pyannote[138].end 664.14659375
transcript.pyannote[139].speaker SPEAKER_02
transcript.pyannote[139].start 664.45034375
transcript.pyannote[139].end 670.17096875
transcript.pyannote[140].speaker SPEAKER_02
transcript.pyannote[140].start 670.57596875
transcript.pyannote[140].end 675.31784375
transcript.pyannote[141].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[141].start 676.81971875
transcript.pyannote[141].end 681.12284375
transcript.pyannote[142].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[142].start 680.07659375
transcript.pyannote[142].end 680.61659375
transcript.pyannote[143].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[143].start 681.22409375
transcript.pyannote[143].end 684.97034375
transcript.pyannote[144].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[144].start 684.22784375
transcript.pyannote[144].end 690.16784375
transcript.pyannote[145].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[145].start 685.84784375
transcript.pyannote[145].end 686.65784375
transcript.pyannote[146].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[146].start 688.59846875
transcript.pyannote[146].end 692.31096875
transcript.pyannote[147].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[147].start 692.68221875
transcript.pyannote[147].end 708.91596875
transcript.pyannote[148].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[148].start 698.30159375
transcript.pyannote[148].end 698.60534375
transcript.pyannote[149].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[149].start 709.11846875
transcript.pyannote[149].end 712.57784375
transcript.pyannote[150].speaker SPEAKER_02
transcript.pyannote[150].start 710.14784375
transcript.pyannote[150].end 710.16471875
transcript.pyannote[151].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[151].start 710.16471875
transcript.pyannote[151].end 710.18159375
transcript.pyannote[152].speaker SPEAKER_02
transcript.pyannote[152].start 710.18159375
transcript.pyannote[152].end 712.51034375
transcript.pyannote[153].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[153].start 713.05034375
transcript.pyannote[153].end 713.06721875
transcript.pyannote[154].speaker SPEAKER_02
transcript.pyannote[154].start 713.06721875
transcript.pyannote[154].end 713.21909375
transcript.pyannote[155].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[155].start 713.21909375
transcript.pyannote[155].end 713.57346875
transcript.pyannote[156].speaker SPEAKER_02
transcript.pyannote[156].start 713.57346875
transcript.pyannote[156].end 722.77034375
transcript.pyannote[157].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[157].start 713.65784375
transcript.pyannote[157].end 714.50159375
transcript.pyannote[158].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[158].start 716.79659375
transcript.pyannote[158].end 717.50534375
transcript.pyannote[159].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[159].start 720.27284375
transcript.pyannote[159].end 721.67346875
transcript.pyannote[160].speaker SPEAKER_02
transcript.pyannote[160].start 723.34409375
transcript.pyannote[160].end 728.03534375
transcript.pyannote[161].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[161].start 726.22971875
transcript.pyannote[161].end 731.74784375
transcript.pyannote[162].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[162].start 731.96721875
transcript.pyannote[162].end 735.91596875
transcript.pyannote[163].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[163].start 736.01721875
transcript.pyannote[163].end 744.67409375
transcript.pyannote[164].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[164].start 737.75534375
transcript.pyannote[164].end 737.82284375
transcript.pyannote[165].speaker SPEAKER_02
transcript.pyannote[165].start 737.82284375
transcript.pyannote[165].end 740.62409375
transcript.pyannote[166].speaker SPEAKER_03
transcript.pyannote[166].start 743.45909375
transcript.pyannote[166].end 743.47596875
transcript.pyannote[167].speaker SPEAKER_02
transcript.pyannote[167].start 743.47596875
transcript.pyannote[167].end 746.51346875
transcript.pyannote[168].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[168].start 746.31096875
transcript.pyannote[168].end 746.42909375
transcript.pyannote[169].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[169].start 746.51346875
transcript.pyannote[169].end 746.76659375
transcript.pyannote[170].speaker SPEAKER_02
transcript.pyannote[170].start 746.54721875
transcript.pyannote[170].end 751.03596875
transcript.pyannote[171].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[171].start 751.03596875
transcript.pyannote[171].end 756.41909375
transcript.pyannote[172].speaker SPEAKER_02
transcript.pyannote[172].start 755.76096875
transcript.pyannote[172].end 766.71284375
transcript.pyannote[173].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[173].start 766.96596875
transcript.pyannote[173].end 767.01659375
transcript.pyannote[174].speaker SPEAKER_02
transcript.pyannote[174].start 767.01659375
transcript.pyannote[174].end 767.28659375
transcript.pyannote[175].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[175].start 767.28659375
transcript.pyannote[175].end 767.38784375
transcript.pyannote[176].speaker SPEAKER_02
transcript.pyannote[176].start 767.48909375
transcript.pyannote[176].end 770.18909375
transcript.pyannote[177].speaker SPEAKER_02
transcript.pyannote[177].start 770.25659375
transcript.pyannote[177].end 774.30659375
transcript.pyannote[178].speaker SPEAKER_02
transcript.pyannote[178].start 775.62284375
transcript.pyannote[178].end 776.95596875
transcript.pyannote[179].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[179].start 776.80409375
transcript.pyannote[179].end 777.76596875
transcript.pyannote[180].speaker SPEAKER_02
transcript.pyannote[180].start 777.41159375
transcript.pyannote[180].end 778.99784375
transcript.pyannote[181].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[181].start 778.05284375
transcript.pyannote[181].end 780.12846875
transcript.pyannote[182].speaker SPEAKER_02
transcript.pyannote[182].start 780.12846875
transcript.pyannote[182].end 788.75159375
transcript.pyannote[183].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[183].start 785.71409375
transcript.pyannote[183].end 786.23721875
transcript.pyannote[184].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[184].start 788.65034375
transcript.pyannote[184].end 789.07221875
transcript.pyannote[185].speaker SPEAKER_02
transcript.pyannote[185].start 788.98784375
transcript.pyannote[185].end 793.54409375
transcript.pyannote[186].speaker SPEAKER_02
transcript.pyannote[186].start 794.11784375
transcript.pyannote[186].end 797.56034375
transcript.pyannote[187].speaker SPEAKER_02
transcript.pyannote[187].start 798.65721875
transcript.pyannote[187].end 804.44534375
transcript.pyannote[188].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[188].start 803.78721875
transcript.pyannote[188].end 805.50846875
transcript.pyannote[189].speaker SPEAKER_02
transcript.pyannote[189].start 805.57596875
transcript.pyannote[189].end 806.53784375
transcript.pyannote[190].speaker SPEAKER_02
transcript.pyannote[190].start 806.74034375
transcript.pyannote[190].end 807.70221875
transcript.pyannote[191].speaker SPEAKER_02
transcript.pyannote[191].start 808.12409375
transcript.pyannote[191].end 809.03534375
transcript.pyannote[192].speaker SPEAKER_02
transcript.pyannote[192].start 809.08596875
transcript.pyannote[192].end 811.16159375
transcript.pyannote[193].speaker SPEAKER_02
transcript.pyannote[193].start 811.65096875
transcript.pyannote[193].end 812.17409375
transcript.pyannote[194].speaker SPEAKER_02
transcript.pyannote[194].start 812.46096875
transcript.pyannote[194].end 813.03471875
transcript.pyannote[195].speaker SPEAKER_02
transcript.pyannote[195].start 813.64221875
transcript.pyannote[195].end 815.85284375
transcript.pyannote[196].speaker SPEAKER_02
transcript.pyannote[196].start 817.38846875
transcript.pyannote[196].end 818.73846875
transcript.pyannote[197].speaker SPEAKER_02
transcript.pyannote[197].start 819.39659375
transcript.pyannote[197].end 820.93221875
transcript.pyannote[198].speaker SPEAKER_02
transcript.pyannote[198].start 821.64096875
transcript.pyannote[198].end 834.82034375
transcript.pyannote[199].speaker SPEAKER_02
transcript.pyannote[199].start 835.19159375
transcript.pyannote[199].end 842.05971875
transcript.pyannote[200].speaker SPEAKER_02
transcript.pyannote[200].start 842.21159375
transcript.pyannote[200].end 842.71784375
transcript.pyannote[201].speaker SPEAKER_02
transcript.pyannote[201].start 843.10596875
transcript.pyannote[201].end 845.14784375
transcript.pyannote[202].speaker SPEAKER_02
transcript.pyannote[202].start 845.53596875
transcript.pyannote[202].end 847.02096875
transcript.pyannote[203].speaker SPEAKER_02
transcript.pyannote[203].start 847.91534375
transcript.pyannote[203].end 850.24409375
transcript.pyannote[204].speaker SPEAKER_02
transcript.pyannote[204].start 851.27346875
transcript.pyannote[204].end 853.18034375
transcript.pyannote[205].speaker SPEAKER_02
transcript.pyannote[205].start 853.88909375
transcript.pyannote[205].end 854.19284375
transcript.pyannote[206].speaker SPEAKER_02
transcript.pyannote[206].start 854.66534375
transcript.pyannote[206].end 855.50909375
transcript.pyannote[207].speaker SPEAKER_02
transcript.pyannote[207].start 855.82971875
transcript.pyannote[207].end 859.42409375
transcript.pyannote[208].speaker SPEAKER_02
transcript.pyannote[208].start 860.84159375
transcript.pyannote[208].end 865.07721875
transcript.pyannote[209].speaker SPEAKER_02
transcript.pyannote[209].start 865.33034375
transcript.pyannote[209].end 869.44784375
transcript.pyannote[210].speaker SPEAKER_03
transcript.pyannote[210].start 869.98784375
transcript.pyannote[210].end 870.13971875
transcript.pyannote[211].speaker SPEAKER_02
transcript.pyannote[211].start 870.13971875
transcript.pyannote[211].end 873.00846875
transcript.pyannote[212].speaker SPEAKER_02
transcript.pyannote[212].start 873.68346875
transcript.pyannote[212].end 883.30221875
transcript.pyannote[213].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[213].start 883.85909375
transcript.pyannote[213].end 898.06784375
transcript.pyannote[214].speaker SPEAKER_02
transcript.pyannote[214].start 884.19659375
transcript.pyannote[214].end 884.98971875
transcript.pyannote[215].speaker SPEAKER_02
transcript.pyannote[215].start 897.29159375
transcript.pyannote[215].end 900.93659375
transcript.pyannote[216].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[216].start 899.55284375
transcript.pyannote[216].end 904.19346875
transcript.pyannote[217].speaker SPEAKER_02
transcript.pyannote[217].start 903.77159375
transcript.pyannote[217].end 912.31034375
transcript.pyannote[218].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[218].start 904.41284375
transcript.pyannote[218].end 904.42971875
transcript.pyannote[219].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[219].start 904.44659375
transcript.pyannote[219].end 904.48034375
transcript.pyannote[220].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[220].start 904.51409375
transcript.pyannote[220].end 904.69971875
transcript.pyannote[221].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[221].start 907.33221875
transcript.pyannote[221].end 907.78784375
transcript.pyannote[222].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[222].start 908.71596875
transcript.pyannote[222].end 910.31909375
transcript.pyannote[223].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[223].start 912.05721875
transcript.pyannote[223].end 912.27659375
transcript.pyannote[224].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[224].start 912.31034375
transcript.pyannote[224].end 917.86221875
transcript.pyannote[225].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[225].start 914.14971875
transcript.pyannote[225].end 914.47034375
transcript.pyannote[226].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[226].start 917.20409375
transcript.pyannote[226].end 919.56659375
transcript.pyannote[227].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[227].start 918.03096875
transcript.pyannote[227].end 926.04659375
transcript.pyannote[228].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[228].start 926.41784375
transcript.pyannote[228].end 930.87284375
transcript.pyannote[229].speaker SPEAKER_02
transcript.pyannote[229].start 930.33284375
transcript.pyannote[229].end 937.79159375
transcript.pyannote[230].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[230].start 937.92659375
transcript.pyannote[230].end 940.71096875
transcript.pyannote[231].speaker SPEAKER_02
transcript.pyannote[231].start 939.54659375
transcript.pyannote[231].end 942.55034375
transcript.pyannote[232].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[232].start 941.03159375
transcript.pyannote[232].end 941.20034375
transcript.pyannote[233].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[233].start 942.11159375
transcript.pyannote[233].end 952.35471875
transcript.pyannote[234].speaker SPEAKER_02
transcript.pyannote[234].start 950.92034375
transcript.pyannote[234].end 958.95284375
transcript.pyannote[235].speaker SPEAKER_02
transcript.pyannote[235].start 959.20596875
transcript.pyannote[235].end 962.00721875
transcript.pyannote[236].speaker SPEAKER_02
transcript.pyannote[236].start 962.80034375
transcript.pyannote[236].end 965.65221875
transcript.pyannote[237].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[237].start 965.93909375
transcript.pyannote[237].end 966.12471875
transcript.pyannote[238].speaker SPEAKER_02
transcript.pyannote[238].start 966.12471875
transcript.pyannote[238].end 974.22471875
transcript.pyannote[239].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[239].start 974.64659375
transcript.pyannote[239].end 982.81409375
transcript.pyannote[240].speaker SPEAKER_02
transcript.pyannote[240].start 980.80596875
transcript.pyannote[240].end 984.40034375
transcript.pyannote[241].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[241].start 983.38784375
transcript.pyannote[241].end 989.61471875
transcript.pyannote[242].speaker SPEAKER_02
transcript.pyannote[242].start 987.99471875
transcript.pyannote[242].end 1010.52284375
transcript.pyannote[243].speaker SPEAKER_02
transcript.pyannote[243].start 1010.92784375
transcript.pyannote[243].end 1014.80909375
transcript.pyannote[244].speaker SPEAKER_02
transcript.pyannote[244].start 1014.99471875
transcript.pyannote[244].end 1022.38596875
transcript.pyannote[245].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[245].start 1022.48721875
transcript.pyannote[245].end 1023.04409375
transcript.pyannote[246].speaker SPEAKER_02
transcript.pyannote[246].start 1023.76971875
transcript.pyannote[246].end 1032.00471875
transcript.pyannote[247].speaker SPEAKER_02
transcript.pyannote[247].start 1032.40971875
transcript.pyannote[247].end 1034.45159375
transcript.pyannote[248].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[248].start 1034.85659375
transcript.pyannote[248].end 1036.20659375
transcript.pyannote[249].speaker SPEAKER_02
transcript.pyannote[249].start 1035.85221875
transcript.pyannote[249].end 1040.96534375
transcript.pyannote[250].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[250].start 1040.96534375
transcript.pyannote[250].end 1061.45159375
transcript.pyannote[251].speaker SPEAKER_03
transcript.pyannote[251].start 1050.63471875
transcript.pyannote[251].end 1050.97221875
transcript.pyannote[252].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[252].start 1050.97221875
transcript.pyannote[252].end 1051.15784375
transcript.pyannote[253].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[253].start 1056.99659375
transcript.pyannote[253].end 1057.41846875
transcript.pyannote[254].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[254].start 1061.89034375
transcript.pyannote[254].end 1062.51471875
transcript.pyannote[255].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[255].start 1062.66659375
transcript.pyannote[255].end 1069.18034375
transcript.pyannote[256].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[256].start 1069.31534375
transcript.pyannote[256].end 1074.17534375
transcript.pyannote[257].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[257].start 1074.34409375
transcript.pyannote[257].end 1078.30971875
transcript.pyannote[258].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[258].start 1078.47846875
transcript.pyannote[258].end 1085.16096875
transcript.pyannote[259].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[259].start 1085.90346875
transcript.pyannote[259].end 1088.65409375
transcript.pyannote[260].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[260].start 1088.90721875
transcript.pyannote[260].end 1097.47971875
transcript.pyannote[261].speaker SPEAKER_02
transcript.pyannote[261].start 1095.85971875
transcript.pyannote[261].end 1113.35909375
transcript.pyannote[262].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[262].start 1113.84846875
transcript.pyannote[262].end 1119.19784375
transcript.pyannote[263].speaker SPEAKER_02
transcript.pyannote[263].start 1117.93221875
transcript.pyannote[263].end 1119.82221875
transcript.pyannote[264].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[264].start 1120.54784375
transcript.pyannote[264].end 1122.91034375
transcript.pyannote[265].speaker SPEAKER_02
transcript.pyannote[265].start 1122.06659375
transcript.pyannote[265].end 1124.68221875
transcript.pyannote[266].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[266].start 1123.77096875
transcript.pyannote[266].end 1124.98596875
transcript.pyannote[267].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[267].start 1125.55971875
transcript.pyannote[267].end 1146.97409375
transcript.pyannote[268].speaker SPEAKER_02
transcript.pyannote[268].start 1129.10346875
transcript.pyannote[268].end 1130.65596875
transcript.pyannote[269].speaker SPEAKER_02
transcript.pyannote[269].start 1134.63846875
transcript.pyannote[269].end 1135.36409375
transcript.pyannote[270].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[270].start 1138.40159375
transcript.pyannote[270].end 1138.89096875
transcript.pyannote[271].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[271].start 1141.89471875
transcript.pyannote[271].end 1141.94534375
transcript.pyannote[272].speaker SPEAKER_02
transcript.pyannote[272].start 1141.94534375
transcript.pyannote[272].end 1142.33346875
transcript.pyannote[273].speaker SPEAKER_02
transcript.pyannote[273].start 1144.94909375
transcript.pyannote[273].end 1145.32034375
transcript.pyannote[274].speaker SPEAKER_02
transcript.pyannote[274].start 1146.70409375
transcript.pyannote[274].end 1163.61284375
transcript.pyannote[275].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[275].start 1150.77096875
transcript.pyannote[275].end 1151.19284375
transcript.pyannote[276].speaker SPEAKER_02
transcript.pyannote[276].start 1163.98409375
transcript.pyannote[276].end 1168.43909375
transcript.pyannote[277].speaker SPEAKER_02
transcript.pyannote[277].start 1168.55721875
transcript.pyannote[277].end 1182.46221875
transcript.pyannote[278].speaker SPEAKER_02
transcript.pyannote[278].start 1183.13721875
transcript.pyannote[278].end 1192.78971875
transcript.pyannote[279].speaker SPEAKER_02
transcript.pyannote[279].start 1192.82346875
transcript.pyannote[279].end 1197.07596875
transcript.pyannote[280].speaker SPEAKER_02
transcript.pyannote[280].start 1197.63284375
transcript.pyannote[280].end 1202.23971875
transcript.pyannote[281].speaker SPEAKER_02
transcript.pyannote[281].start 1204.56846875
transcript.pyannote[281].end 1207.16721875
transcript.whisperx[0].start 1.869
transcript.whisperx[0].end 25.801
transcript.whisperx[0].text 劉教授我看您剛剛這個回答的都不卑不亢非常的好那但是我也要請您大概注意一下像剛剛所說的這個尤其您說這個憲法法庭的如果總額的這個問題可能還有配套那事實上翁小林委員所提出來這個憲法總額是有把該迴避的名額扣掉的所以也說在接受資訊的時候要做判斷的時候
transcript.whisperx[1].start 26.181
transcript.whisperx[1].end 53.803
transcript.whisperx[1].text 有的人準備不全或是不了解事情的全貌但是事實上你們在做相關的這個時候是需要做全面性的了解在這個配套說是有的那我想跟您討論一下我發現您的這個我對這個大法官被提名的這個標準我大概自己把它分為這四項學術專業國家認同品德操守跟人權保障這四項那我剛剛看到我看您的這個回答事實上是比較就是
transcript.whisperx[2].start 56.57
transcript.whisperx[2].end 86.233
transcript.whisperx[2].text 比較直接的就是說事實上敢勇於承擔的比起我昨天質詢這個前天質詢張文貞女士跟這個昨天陳運財先生對於事情都不願意就是有點微微諾我還是對您相對是敬佩的我想請教您您知道您被提名的這個原因我們看到按照依法來講這個大概您不是沒有任過國際法庭的法官嗎沒有嗎所以您應該是有在學術機關從事公法學或比較法學研究對吧
transcript.whisperx[3].start 86.733
transcript.whisperx[3].end 87.093
transcript.whisperx[3].text 兒有權威著作權威著作是哪一本?
transcript.whisperx[4].start 101.628
transcript.whisperx[4].end 123.622
transcript.whisperx[4].text 謝謝委員的提問我當然不敢說自己是權威雖然法律上面是這樣規定不過呢我個人在言論自由、新聞自由跟資訊隱私的這個幾個領域我其實有非常多的專論我看到你有很多文章有兩本專書那其他大部分都是
transcript.whisperx[5].start 127.826
transcript.whisperx[5].end 136.386
transcript.whisperx[5].text 文章收錄還有一些未出版的因為還要經匿名審查還有未出版的一些文章收錄所以這兩本書是所謂的權威著作嗎?您會這樣認為嗎?
transcript.whisperx[6].start 138.334
transcript.whisperx[6].end 158.802
transcript.whisperx[6].text 我不敢說權威但是呢這兩本書裡面所引用的文章很多呢所收錄的論文很多是我自己的這個升等論文所以這樣怎麼來說服我你是在國內受到非常多的引用是所以你也不認為是權威著作了
transcript.whisperx[7].start 159.967
transcript.whisperx[7].end 160.007
transcript.whisperx[7].text 陳玉珍
transcript.whisperx[8].start 190.347
transcript.whisperx[8].end 211.975
transcript.whisperx[8].text 普遍任命為大法官的標準品德操守人非聖賢 孰人無過知錯人改善莫大焉注意到媒體我今天特別給您一個說明的空間我注意到您曾經在臉書上說我們廣東名校長就是負下大勢違法兼職又稱他兼職台灣大讀懂
transcript.whisperx[9].start 215.416
transcript.whisperx[9].end 231.284
transcript.whisperx[9].text 那這個臺大有一個認定喔這個管中銘未附陸兼職符合教育部規定這個臺大認定你覺得是臺大是你認知的學校嘛臺大認知認定說管中銘沒有附大陸兼職您說他違法兼職那你覺得臺大這個認定是正確的嗎
transcript.whisperx[10].start 232.206
transcript.whisperx[10].end 248.113
transcript.whisperx[10].text 台大當時的認定基本上是用廈門大學的回函來做認定這是一個行政上的認定所以你認為台大的因為台大有這個新聞這個台大這個認定是正確還是不正確或者是一個偏頗的認定我認為是一個不盡正確的偏頗認定所以你認為台大的認定是一個
transcript.whisperx[11].start 259.798
transcript.whisperx[11].end 264.801
transcript.whisperx[11].text 因為我自己本身不是當事人所以我不可能有陳述的機會那又說到管中銘違規兼職列教育部的這個名單就台大說當時已經卸任讀董那這個東西比較明確了吧
transcript.whisperx[12].start 288.092
transcript.whisperx[12].end 288.232
transcript.whisperx[12].text 委員報告
transcript.whisperx[13].start 306.115
transcript.whisperx[13].end 319.991
transcript.whisperx[13].text 在沒有獲得臺大校方的同意之前就去擔任臺歌大的讀董、新資委員會等等的這個事情呢其實事後在
transcript.whisperx[14].start 321.532
transcript.whisperx[14].end 341.077
transcript.whisperx[14].text 檢察院的彈劾案裡面講得非常清楚所以這個部分我並沒有講錯台大說他當時已經卸任讀董了已經辭卸任所以你說辭卸任沒有問題你說他去擔任以前沒有去那個嘛他擔任之前沒有經過台大就已經有違法事實了
transcript.whisperx[15].start 345.358
transcript.whisperx[15].end 367.849
transcript.whisperx[15].text 所以您到今天還是認為說臺大的這些認定或是偏頗或是不正確的您還是覺得您的指控是正確的接著您說對於我們管校長他說您的國發所的論文抄襲這個部分你說不回應是因為這個不確實還是怎樣
transcript.whisperx[16].start 370.784
transcript.whisperx[16].end 390.634
transcript.whisperx[16].text 我不知道委員是在講哪一件事情那個管宗敏校長說自己指您說國發所論文抄襲對你自己論文抄襲視而不見這件事情國發所論文抄襲並不是我抄襲不是你抄襲不是我抄襲所以我不知道我要回應什麼
transcript.whisperx[17].start 391.374
transcript.whisperx[17].end 391.854
transcript.whisperx[17].text 對於臨近改革的視線裡頭你有做鑑定的意見嗎?
transcript.whisperx[18].start 418.015
transcript.whisperx[18].end 441.652
transcript.whisperx[18].text 就是說這個年金改革的改變無涉於是否違反法律不溯及既往的原則也沒有侵害到受規範對象之財產權這些意見您看您有講過這些嗎還有未違反法律不溯及既往原則難認定違反憲法第15條的生存權的保障沒有違反沒有侵害受規範者的財產權也沒有這個都是您說過的話這個應該是
transcript.whisperx[19].start 446.367
transcript.whisperx[19].end 474.343
transcript.whisperx[19].text 您確定嗎?我沒有說錯,您說過這話您的第三頁,意見書第三頁有提到公共年金制度本質上必須含納動態調整的可能性對退伏基金、財務收支平衡的基本目標要怎麼達成?您說的是本應容許政府與立法者定期共同檢討的空間以便能夠是實際需要進行調整的以確保公共年金制度的
transcript.whisperx[20].start 475.268
transcript.whisperx[20].end 475.628
transcript.whisperx[20].text 我曾經研究過的事情
transcript.whisperx[21].start 492.816
transcript.whisperx[21].end 496.197
transcript.whisperx[21].text 民進黨有可能還會提出釋憲,您是不是還會認為這是政府與立法者定期共同檢討的空間?
transcript.whisperx[22].start 513.163
transcript.whisperx[22].end 533.986
transcript.whisperx[22].text 我認為這個事情當然如果有具體個案進來的話我就不便表示意見那如果這個是一個潛在的釋憲案的話我在這裡也不方便講太多不一定是一個釋憲啦民進黨不一定會提出釋憲啦如果就您以前因為您現在不是大法官的人選只是被提名有沒有根據您的這個
transcript.whisperx[23].start 535.247
transcript.whisperx[23].end 558.519
transcript.whisperx[23].text 過往的這個信念價值我看您也一向信念價值是怎樣就怎樣也不會說是自無為聞或會迴避問題不像前面那兩位會迴避問題但是您本來做的就是本應容許政府與立法者共同定期檢討空間那過了好幾年我們現在又打算定期檢討了我還是抱持同樣的態度所以也是認為這應該是政府與立法者應該可以有
transcript.whisperx[24].start 563.563
transcript.whisperx[24].end 582.538
transcript.whisperx[24].text 政府立法部門跟行政部門必須要共同來維護大家的最低的生存權反正您肯定說還有檢討空間那這一點就可以至少你的心內沒有改變有關國家認同的部分你認為說國家定位是政治問題不應該率有回答我也尊重但是
transcript.whisperx[25].start 583.599
transcript.whisperx[25].end 590.524
transcript.whisperx[25].text 有時候因為這個憲法的這個規定那影響到人民實際的權利的時候這時候這個當然你就要有您的這個看法了我舉一個金門的例子來給你聽您知道我是來自金門縣嘛福建省金門 中華民國福建省金門知道吧我們這個因為這個國家的一些定位問題造成人民權益受損工作財產都受到損害你應該不能保持緘默啦然後給人家看一下這個圖齁您看一下這個
transcript.whisperx[26].start 609.959
transcript.whisperx[26].end 630.734
transcript.whisperx[26].text 現實案例齁這個你知道中華民國憲法有規定中華民國的這個固有疆域這個沒問題嘛齁這個憲法裡頭有明文規定嘛齁您看看這個圖上面有藍色的跟紅色的齁這個就是禁憲制水域這個是我們這個之前這個國防部畫出的金門的這個禁憲制水域齁那金門民眾因為齁
transcript.whisperx[27].start 634.127
transcript.whisperx[27].end 653.696
transcript.whisperx[27].text 你船開出了這個所謂的禁限制水域所以被處罰這個案子在金門發生了數百個案例你怎麼而且被地檢署起訴那根據這個中華民國憲法這個有超出故有疆域嗎在金門的四周圍內幾海里內啊
transcript.whisperx[28].start 655.757
transcript.whisperx[28].end 675.092
transcript.whisperx[28].text 為如果大陸的說大陸的船要進來對我們做什麼事情我們還可以說基於這個安全保障我們對大陸的進行這個我這個是可以接受的但是對金門我們中華民國的國民因為船開出我們自己劃的進限制水域而因此被地檢署起訴在金門數百案件你怎麼看
transcript.whisperx[29].start 677.152
transcript.whisperx[29].end 685.581
transcript.whisperx[29].text 好那個謝謝委員告訴我這個案例因為我對於離島的相關的事務我現在要回答委員就是說
transcript.whisperx[30].start 692.788
transcript.whisperx[30].end 711.363
transcript.whisperx[30].text 我們 我想委員也知道我們的憲法 憲法增修條文跟兩岸條例基本上是一個非常特殊的一個架構它事實上就是以這個所謂的主權跟治權這樣子的一個合一還是分立的一個狀況弄起來
transcript.whisperx[31].start 714.225
transcript.whisperx[31].end 735.458
transcript.whisperx[31].text 所以我們限制不讓大陸的漁船進來這個是合理的,我也接受啊在你那個前提下中華民國自己的國民不能行駛在中華民國自己這些還是我們認知的隨意喔我想在這個部分基本上就是必須要去考量說在這樣子的一個架構底下對於本國人民
transcript.whisperx[32].start 736.198
transcript.whisperx[32].end 736.538
transcript.whisperx[32].text 下一題喔
transcript.whisperx[33].start 757.253
transcript.whisperx[33].end 759.435
transcript.whisperx[33].text 《中華民國憲法》第148條《中華民國領域內一切互應許自由流通》
transcript.whisperx[34].start 775.643
transcript.whisperx[34].end 796.898
transcript.whisperx[34].text 您是哪裡人?宜蘭人嗎?我是宜蘭人。我們也有很多走私的問題。我現在不是要問走私,我問中華民國境內,台澎金馬,我就問台澎金馬境內,兩岸人民關係的自由地區裡頭。你如果從高雄帶宜蘭雞蛋上來,請問你是不是應該要經過檢查?從宜蘭就好了,從宜蘭帶到台北,是不是應該要經過檢查?
transcript.whisperx[35].start 798.855
transcript.whisperx[35].end 814.722
transcript.whisperx[35].text 經過什麼檢查?檢查看你這個雞蛋安不安全?檢查這個雞蛋有沒有病啊?檢查這個雞蛋帶了幾顆啊?食物上應該是沒有沒有嘛 對不對?你知道嗎?我給你看一下金門人的金門如果帶雞蛋到台灣島來要坐飛機嘛我們是要經過檢查的這個符合中華民國憲法嗎?那來我跟你說齁
transcript.whisperx[36].start 821.653
transcript.whisperx[36].end 846.967
transcript.whisperx[36].text 不只一樣 帶牛肉 帶豬肉 帶雞蛋好 我跟您說 如果牛肉你說 可能有一些什麼病菌啊 什麼 或什麼或豬的什麼口蹄啊 什麼豬瘟啊 這一點我說為了必要的這個一些防止其他的法醫的被侵害喔 這個我倒是還說 這個勉強我們來配合政府說怎麼來做 對不對 這樣子算才是可以接受啦但是 您知道嗎 在我質詢的那個時候 在兩年前
transcript.whisperx[37].start 851.328
transcript.whisperx[37].end 859.005
transcript.whisperx[37].text 屏東地區有禽流感金門地區沒有禽流感金門沒有禽流感沒有任何的
transcript.whisperx[38].start 865.871
transcript.whisperx[38].end 881.339
transcript.whisperx[38].text 請問在這個情況下從屏東到台北帶雞蛋來是不用檢查是沒有限制從金門到台灣來是被限制的是要被檢查的當然在有爭取後現在說放寬一點可以帶20顆啦但是我想請教這個沒有違反憲法嗎
transcript.whisperx[39].start 884.3
transcript.whisperx[39].end 884.641
transcript.whisperx[39].text 法定人數不足
transcript.whisperx[40].start 898.831
transcript.whisperx[40].end 900.732
transcript.whisperx[40].text 如果是這樣的話我修正我的講法如果事實是這樣的話如果是這個樣子那麼主管機關要做這樣的規範的時候就必須要負責舉證
transcript.whisperx[41].start 927.322
transcript.whisperx[41].end 950.394
transcript.whisperx[41].text 為什麼金門必須要受到不一樣的限制?這樣算不算一個國家內實行兩種制度?請問你這樣算不算一個國家內實行兩種制度?我不同意你不同意他實施這個制度還是你不同意這是一國兩制?我不同意在同一個國家裡面沒有特殊的公共利益的要求的時候去做這樣子的區分的限制
transcript.whisperx[42].start 951.374
transcript.whisperx[42].end 973.587
transcript.whisperx[42].text 所以現在的制度我跟妳講這都是事實現在的制度就是在一個國家內實施兩種制度你從宜蘭帶過來台北不用檢查我從金門帶過來就是要檢查就是要檢查而且金門沒有禽流感屏東那時候那時候還有禽流感他們還不用檢查你覺得如果你是身為離島的居民因為身為金門居民你不會覺得備受歧視嗎
transcript.whisperx[43].start 974.868
transcript.whisperx[43].end 975.549
transcript.whisperx[43].text 中華民國憲法增修條文第10條第12項
transcript.whisperx[44].start 996.881
transcript.whisperx[44].end 1022.851
transcript.whisperx[44].text 國家應依民族意願保障原住民族之地位及政治參與.並對其教育文化、交通、水利、衛生、醫療.經濟、土地及社會福利事項予以保障.並輔助並促其發展其辦法令與法律定制.對澎湖、金門、馬祖地區民眾一同.這個是在憲法裡頭明文規定的.所以我們知道現在對原住民有什麼.原住民有原住民基本法.您知道嗎我知道
transcript.whisperx[45].start 1023.817
transcript.whisperx[45].end 1034.006
transcript.whisperx[45].text 那請問呢:在這個情況下:憲法竟然有這樣明文規定:如果金馬鵬民眾要訂一個金馬鵬人民基本法:您是否也覺得是可行的呢:
transcript.whisperx[46].start 1035.693
transcript.whisperx[46].end 1060.871
transcript.whisperx[46].text 就是離島基本法或是金馬鵬人民基本法都可以如果要對離島的人民做特殊的保障我想我們憲法裡面其實並不是沒有依據的就是剛剛委員所提到的那些那我覺得不管是過去我想委員也知道過去曾經有離島條例的這些倡議的立法朝野都有很大的爭執
transcript.whisperx[47].start 1062.793
transcript.whisperx[47].end 1084.753
transcript.whisperx[47].text 然後呢這裡其實會涉及到的問題其實是一個所謂的資源分配的問題那我個人向來認為我是宜蘭人宜蘭有很多偏鄉我認為我們在偏鄉的保護上面或者是離島的保護上面呢的確呢是有在討論的空間所以我坦白講
transcript.whisperx[48].start 1085.974
transcript.whisperx[48].end 1113.087
transcript.whisperx[48].text 我不反對呢在金馬鵬人民的這個部分呢做一些呢比較架構性的基本權益的保障就像設立一個基本法嘛就是比如說原住民原住民有的這個原住民基本法客家居民有的什麼客家基本法那這個金馬鵬人民就是離島也設一個理論上這也應該我要問的是因為你是大法官的提名這樣有違反憲法嗎
transcript.whisperx[49].start 1114.166
transcript.whisperx[49].end 1118.362
transcript.whisperx[49].text 我其實不認為定基本法會有違反憲法的問題那這樣會有什麼問題嗎?
transcript.whisperx[50].start 1122.17
transcript.whisperx[50].end 1145.905
transcript.whisperx[50].text 你支持這樣嗎?如果說有這樣的立法,你覺得是...如果我當立法委員的話,我大致上是可以支持的也是支持這樣的立法嗎?那這裡會有的問題是說基本法只是一個架構性的立法它必須要有其他的作用法,我想委員員是學法律的,應該知道必須要有其他的作用法來分配資源那作用法是不是合憲,就必須要用個案來檢驗
transcript.whisperx[51].start 1147.547
transcript.whisperx[51].end 1169.904
transcript.whisperx[51].text 後續當然我們這個相關法律我們在立法院裡頭會做充分的這個討論不過我是對今天一些部分的答案還算是滿意的第一個就是對於年金的這個部分這個當然可以定期的來做檢討就是政府跟立法之間可以定一下看是不是對人民的一些基本生存權有受到侵犯那第二點對於這個金門這個農業尤其是農業部違反了中華民國憲法148條中華民國境內會不會應該獲唱其流
transcript.whisperx[52].start 1175.928
transcript.whisperx[52].end 1176.749
transcript.whisperx[52].text 謝謝陳委員的詢問,也謝謝被提名的
transcript.whisperx[53].start 1204.74
transcript.whisperx[53].end 1206.366
transcript.whisperx[53].text 報告全院委員會上午會議進行