iVOD / 158093

Field Value
IVOD_ID 158093
IVOD_URL https://ivod.ly.gov.tw/Play/Clip/1M/158093
日期 2024-12-11
影片種類 Clip
開始時間 2024-12-11T16:08:34+08:00
結束時間 2024-12-11T16:29:17+08:00
影片長度 00:20:43
支援功能[0] ai-transcript
video_url https://ivod-lyvod.cdn.hinet.net/vod_1/_definst_/mp4:1MClips/7bc6073edac3146d38ddf79972baca387bc0e35bc25a01cc78ec33fa255ee16961f4198ff1cb05dc5ea18f28b6918d91.mp4/playlist.m3u8
委員名稱 鄭天財Sra Kacaw
委員發言時間 16:08:34 - 16:29:17
會議時間 2024-12-11T09:00:00+08:00
會議名稱 第11屆第2會期第2次全院委員會(事由:總統咨,茲依據中華民國憲法增修條文第5條規定,提名張文貞、姚立明、何賴傑、陳運財、王碧芳、廖福特、劉靜怡7位為司法院大法官,並以張文貞為院長、姚立明為副院長,咨請同意案。)
transcript.pyannote[0].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[0].start 6.46034375
transcript.pyannote[0].end 8.04659375
transcript.pyannote[1].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[1].start 8.36721875
transcript.pyannote[1].end 9.41346875
transcript.pyannote[2].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[2].start 9.68346875
transcript.pyannote[2].end 10.71284375
transcript.pyannote[3].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[3].start 10.96596875
transcript.pyannote[3].end 12.82221875
transcript.pyannote[4].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[4].start 21.68159375
transcript.pyannote[4].end 22.91346875
transcript.pyannote[5].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[5].start 22.99784375
transcript.pyannote[5].end 23.82471875
transcript.pyannote[6].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[6].start 23.82471875
transcript.pyannote[6].end 25.14096875
transcript.pyannote[7].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[7].start 25.25909375
transcript.pyannote[7].end 26.33909375
transcript.pyannote[8].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[8].start 26.33909375
transcript.pyannote[8].end 27.18284375
transcript.pyannote[9].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[9].start 28.11096875
transcript.pyannote[9].end 28.81971875
transcript.pyannote[10].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[10].start 29.10659375
transcript.pyannote[10].end 31.60409375
transcript.pyannote[11].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[11].start 32.31284375
transcript.pyannote[11].end 33.83159375
transcript.pyannote[12].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[12].start 34.70909375
transcript.pyannote[12].end 36.58221875
transcript.pyannote[13].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[13].start 37.29096875
transcript.pyannote[13].end 38.60721875
transcript.pyannote[14].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[14].start 39.19784375
transcript.pyannote[14].end 41.96534375
transcript.pyannote[15].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[15].start 42.60659375
transcript.pyannote[15].end 45.86346875
transcript.pyannote[16].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[16].start 46.26846875
transcript.pyannote[16].end 49.54221875
transcript.pyannote[17].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[17].start 50.20034375
transcript.pyannote[17].end 52.15784375
transcript.pyannote[18].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[18].start 54.21659375
transcript.pyannote[18].end 55.21221875
transcript.pyannote[19].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[19].start 56.78159375
transcript.pyannote[19].end 57.96284375
transcript.pyannote[20].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[20].start 58.46909375
transcript.pyannote[20].end 59.71784375
transcript.pyannote[21].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[21].start 60.62909375
transcript.pyannote[21].end 63.76784375
transcript.pyannote[22].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[22].start 64.42596875
transcript.pyannote[22].end 66.50159375
transcript.pyannote[23].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[23].start 66.94034375
transcript.pyannote[23].end 68.23971875
transcript.pyannote[24].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[24].start 69.04971875
transcript.pyannote[24].end 69.65721875
transcript.pyannote[25].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[25].start 70.66971875
transcript.pyannote[25].end 71.61471875
transcript.pyannote[26].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[26].start 72.57659375
transcript.pyannote[26].end 74.11221875
transcript.pyannote[27].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[27].start 74.97284375
transcript.pyannote[27].end 78.34784375
transcript.pyannote[28].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[28].start 79.15784375
transcript.pyannote[28].end 79.73159375
transcript.pyannote[29].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[29].start 80.96346875
transcript.pyannote[29].end 81.40221875
transcript.pyannote[30].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[30].start 83.88284375
transcript.pyannote[30].end 86.21159375
transcript.pyannote[31].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[31].start 86.53221875
transcript.pyannote[31].end 88.65846875
transcript.pyannote[32].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[32].start 89.53596875
transcript.pyannote[32].end 94.17659375
transcript.pyannote[33].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[33].start 95.52659375
transcript.pyannote[33].end 99.05346875
transcript.pyannote[34].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[34].start 99.84659375
transcript.pyannote[34].end 100.45409375
transcript.pyannote[35].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[35].start 101.77034375
transcript.pyannote[35].end 102.58034375
transcript.pyannote[36].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[36].start 102.93471875
transcript.pyannote[36].end 106.98471875
transcript.pyannote[37].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[37].start 108.28409375
transcript.pyannote[37].end 109.68471875
transcript.pyannote[38].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[38].start 110.29221875
transcript.pyannote[38].end 111.92909375
transcript.pyannote[39].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[39].start 112.55346875
transcript.pyannote[39].end 113.16096875
transcript.pyannote[40].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[40].start 114.30846875
transcript.pyannote[40].end 115.84409375
transcript.pyannote[41].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[41].start 117.51471875
transcript.pyannote[41].end 118.12221875
transcript.pyannote[42].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[42].start 118.42596875
transcript.pyannote[42].end 119.20221875
transcript.pyannote[43].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[43].start 119.72534375
transcript.pyannote[43].end 120.29909375
transcript.pyannote[44].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[44].start 121.14284375
transcript.pyannote[44].end 121.90221875
transcript.pyannote[45].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[45].start 122.89784375
transcript.pyannote[45].end 123.60659375
transcript.pyannote[46].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[46].start 124.55159375
transcript.pyannote[46].end 127.84221875
transcript.pyannote[47].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[47].start 129.14159375
transcript.pyannote[47].end 130.74471875
transcript.pyannote[48].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[48].start 131.20034375
transcript.pyannote[48].end 133.10721875
transcript.pyannote[49].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[49].start 134.55846875
transcript.pyannote[49].end 139.30034375
transcript.pyannote[50].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[50].start 139.87409375
transcript.pyannote[50].end 141.27471875
transcript.pyannote[51].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[51].start 142.35471875
transcript.pyannote[51].end 143.82284375
transcript.pyannote[52].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[52].start 145.44284375
transcript.pyannote[52].end 148.37909375
transcript.pyannote[53].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[53].start 148.61534375
transcript.pyannote[53].end 149.18909375
transcript.pyannote[54].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[54].start 149.88096875
transcript.pyannote[54].end 151.01159375
transcript.pyannote[55].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[55].start 152.17596875
transcript.pyannote[55].end 153.47534375
transcript.pyannote[56].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[56].start 154.35284375
transcript.pyannote[56].end 158.06534375
transcript.pyannote[57].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[57].start 158.75721875
transcript.pyannote[57].end 159.58409375
transcript.pyannote[58].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[58].start 160.52909375
transcript.pyannote[58].end 161.05221875
transcript.pyannote[59].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[59].start 161.47409375
transcript.pyannote[59].end 162.75659375
transcript.pyannote[60].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[60].start 163.39784375
transcript.pyannote[60].end 164.71409375
transcript.pyannote[61].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[61].start 167.85284375
transcript.pyannote[61].end 173.11784375
transcript.pyannote[62].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[62].start 173.70846875
transcript.pyannote[62].end 177.92721875
transcript.pyannote[63].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[63].start 178.36596875
transcript.pyannote[63].end 179.07471875
transcript.pyannote[64].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[64].start 180.12096875
transcript.pyannote[64].end 182.41596875
transcript.pyannote[65].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[65].start 183.37784375
transcript.pyannote[65].end 184.74471875
transcript.pyannote[66].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[66].start 185.08221875
transcript.pyannote[66].end 186.34784375
transcript.pyannote[67].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[67].start 187.46159375
transcript.pyannote[67].end 188.18721875
transcript.pyannote[68].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[68].start 188.72721875
transcript.pyannote[68].end 189.50346875
transcript.pyannote[69].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[69].start 190.95471875
transcript.pyannote[69].end 192.92909375
transcript.pyannote[70].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[70].start 194.56596875
transcript.pyannote[70].end 194.88659375
transcript.pyannote[71].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[71].start 195.02159375
transcript.pyannote[71].end 195.03846875
transcript.pyannote[72].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[72].start 195.05534375
transcript.pyannote[72].end 195.52784375
transcript.pyannote[73].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[73].start 195.78096875
transcript.pyannote[73].end 196.64159375
transcript.pyannote[74].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[74].start 198.53159375
transcript.pyannote[74].end 199.02096875
transcript.pyannote[75].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[75].start 199.35846875
transcript.pyannote[75].end 202.05846875
transcript.pyannote[76].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[76].start 202.12596875
transcript.pyannote[76].end 205.41659375
transcript.pyannote[77].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[77].start 205.50096875
transcript.pyannote[77].end 224.95784375
transcript.pyannote[78].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[78].start 210.39471875
transcript.pyannote[78].end 211.50846875
transcript.pyannote[79].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[79].start 225.04221875
transcript.pyannote[79].end 225.39659375
transcript.pyannote[80].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[80].start 226.44284375
transcript.pyannote[80].end 228.40034375
transcript.pyannote[81].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[81].start 229.10909375
transcript.pyannote[81].end 229.37909375
transcript.pyannote[82].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[82].start 230.02034375
transcript.pyannote[82].end 231.31971875
transcript.pyannote[83].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[83].start 231.55596875
transcript.pyannote[83].end 232.55159375
transcript.pyannote[84].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[84].start 233.39534375
transcript.pyannote[84].end 233.69909375
transcript.pyannote[85].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[85].start 234.76221875
transcript.pyannote[85].end 236.04471875
transcript.pyannote[86].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[86].start 236.21346875
transcript.pyannote[86].end 237.37784375
transcript.pyannote[87].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[87].start 237.49596875
transcript.pyannote[87].end 238.20471875
transcript.pyannote[88].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[88].start 239.13284375
transcript.pyannote[88].end 240.01034375
transcript.pyannote[89].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[89].start 240.92159375
transcript.pyannote[89].end 241.98471875
transcript.pyannote[90].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[90].start 243.94221875
transcript.pyannote[90].end 246.69284375
transcript.pyannote[91].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[91].start 247.11471875
transcript.pyannote[91].end 248.38034375
transcript.pyannote[92].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[92].start 249.10596875
transcript.pyannote[92].end 253.25721875
transcript.pyannote[93].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[93].start 253.72971875
transcript.pyannote[93].end 255.85596875
transcript.pyannote[94].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[94].start 255.97409375
transcript.pyannote[94].end 256.37909375
transcript.pyannote[95].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[95].start 256.51409375
transcript.pyannote[95].end 260.04096875
transcript.pyannote[96].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[96].start 259.90596875
transcript.pyannote[96].end 260.49659375
transcript.pyannote[97].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[97].start 260.49659375
transcript.pyannote[97].end 261.03659375
transcript.pyannote[98].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[98].start 261.30659375
transcript.pyannote[98].end 263.98971875
transcript.pyannote[99].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[99].start 264.36096875
transcript.pyannote[99].end 265.37346875
transcript.pyannote[100].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[100].start 265.72784375
transcript.pyannote[100].end 268.51221875
transcript.pyannote[101].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[101].start 268.93409375
transcript.pyannote[101].end 269.67659375
transcript.pyannote[102].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[102].start 269.86221875
transcript.pyannote[102].end 270.63846875
transcript.pyannote[103].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[103].start 271.14471875
transcript.pyannote[103].end 278.08034375
transcript.pyannote[104].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[104].start 277.59096875
transcript.pyannote[104].end 278.78909375
transcript.pyannote[105].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[105].start 279.27846875
transcript.pyannote[105].end 280.30784375
transcript.pyannote[106].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[106].start 281.01659375
transcript.pyannote[106].end 285.31971875
transcript.pyannote[107].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[107].start 286.50096875
transcript.pyannote[107].end 289.55534375
transcript.pyannote[108].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[108].start 290.14596875
transcript.pyannote[108].end 291.14159375
transcript.pyannote[109].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[109].start 291.73221875
transcript.pyannote[109].end 294.31409375
transcript.pyannote[110].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[110].start 295.20846875
transcript.pyannote[110].end 296.50784375
transcript.pyannote[111].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[111].start 297.16596875
transcript.pyannote[111].end 300.57471875
transcript.pyannote[112].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[112].start 300.94596875
transcript.pyannote[112].end 303.00471875
transcript.pyannote[113].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[113].start 303.27471875
transcript.pyannote[113].end 307.99971875
transcript.pyannote[114].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[114].start 308.23596875
transcript.pyannote[114].end 311.35784375
transcript.pyannote[115].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[115].start 312.16784375
transcript.pyannote[115].end 313.41659375
transcript.pyannote[116].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[116].start 314.74971875
transcript.pyannote[116].end 317.34846875
transcript.pyannote[117].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[117].start 318.73221875
transcript.pyannote[117].end 318.93471875
transcript.pyannote[118].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[118].start 320.08221875
transcript.pyannote[118].end 320.99346875
transcript.pyannote[119].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[119].start 321.44909375
transcript.pyannote[119].end 322.37721875
transcript.pyannote[120].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[120].start 322.84971875
transcript.pyannote[120].end 325.81971875
transcript.pyannote[121].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[121].start 326.27534375
transcript.pyannote[121].end 328.87409375
transcript.pyannote[122].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[122].start 329.09346875
transcript.pyannote[122].end 331.15221875
transcript.pyannote[123].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[123].start 331.40534375
transcript.pyannote[123].end 332.23221875
transcript.pyannote[124].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[124].start 333.16034375
transcript.pyannote[124].end 333.43034375
transcript.pyannote[125].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[125].start 334.17284375
transcript.pyannote[125].end 343.70721875
transcript.pyannote[126].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[126].start 344.24721875
transcript.pyannote[126].end 345.15846875
transcript.pyannote[127].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[127].start 345.86721875
transcript.pyannote[127].end 348.49971875
transcript.pyannote[128].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[128].start 349.03971875
transcript.pyannote[128].end 350.50784375
transcript.pyannote[129].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[129].start 351.16596875
transcript.pyannote[129].end 352.24596875
transcript.pyannote[130].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[130].start 352.75221875
transcript.pyannote[130].end 353.81534375
transcript.pyannote[131].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[131].start 354.79409375
transcript.pyannote[131].end 355.04721875
transcript.pyannote[132].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[132].start 355.97534375
transcript.pyannote[132].end 356.65034375
transcript.pyannote[133].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[133].start 357.13971875
transcript.pyannote[133].end 358.13534375
transcript.pyannote[134].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[134].start 359.09721875
transcript.pyannote[134].end 360.68346875
transcript.pyannote[135].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[135].start 361.47659375
transcript.pyannote[135].end 363.01221875
transcript.pyannote[136].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[136].start 363.46784375
transcript.pyannote[136].end 365.50971875
transcript.pyannote[137].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[137].start 366.75846875
transcript.pyannote[137].end 371.31471875
transcript.pyannote[138].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[138].start 372.12471875
transcript.pyannote[138].end 372.96846875
transcript.pyannote[139].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[139].start 373.52534375
transcript.pyannote[139].end 375.51659375
transcript.pyannote[140].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[140].start 375.95534375
transcript.pyannote[140].end 377.33909375
transcript.pyannote[141].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[141].start 377.76096875
transcript.pyannote[141].end 380.05596875
transcript.pyannote[142].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[142].start 380.49471875
transcript.pyannote[142].end 384.49409375
transcript.pyannote[143].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[143].start 385.21971875
transcript.pyannote[143].end 387.14346875
transcript.pyannote[144].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[144].start 387.83534375
transcript.pyannote[144].end 389.37096875
transcript.pyannote[145].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[145].start 390.48471875
transcript.pyannote[145].end 392.71221875
transcript.pyannote[146].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[146].start 393.08346875
transcript.pyannote[146].end 393.70784375
transcript.pyannote[147].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[147].start 393.99471875
transcript.pyannote[147].end 403.51221875
transcript.pyannote[148].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[148].start 404.05221875
transcript.pyannote[148].end 404.99721875
transcript.pyannote[149].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[149].start 405.36846875
transcript.pyannote[149].end 413.23221875
transcript.pyannote[150].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[150].start 405.43596875
transcript.pyannote[150].end 407.20784375
transcript.pyannote[151].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[151].start 408.33846875
transcript.pyannote[151].end 408.89534375
transcript.pyannote[152].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[152].start 411.59534375
transcript.pyannote[152].end 414.07596875
transcript.pyannote[153].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[153].start 413.55284375
transcript.pyannote[153].end 413.72159375
transcript.pyannote[154].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[154].start 414.07596875
transcript.pyannote[154].end 414.51471875
transcript.pyannote[155].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[155].start 415.07159375
transcript.pyannote[155].end 416.16846875
transcript.pyannote[156].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[156].start 416.57346875
transcript.pyannote[156].end 417.23159375
transcript.pyannote[157].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[157].start 417.90659375
transcript.pyannote[157].end 419.66159375
transcript.pyannote[158].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[158].start 420.15096875
transcript.pyannote[158].end 421.07909375
transcript.pyannote[159].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[159].start 421.73721875
transcript.pyannote[159].end 424.08284375
transcript.pyannote[160].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[160].start 424.28534375
transcript.pyannote[160].end 425.78721875
transcript.pyannote[161].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[161].start 425.97284375
transcript.pyannote[161].end 428.55471875
transcript.pyannote[162].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[162].start 429.19596875
transcript.pyannote[162].end 431.33909375
transcript.pyannote[163].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[163].start 431.60909375
transcript.pyannote[163].end 432.28409375
transcript.pyannote[164].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[164].start 433.27971875
transcript.pyannote[164].end 436.11471875
transcript.pyannote[165].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[165].start 436.53659375
transcript.pyannote[165].end 437.22846875
transcript.pyannote[166].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[166].start 438.10596875
transcript.pyannote[166].end 441.12659375
transcript.pyannote[167].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[167].start 442.22346875
transcript.pyannote[167].end 443.99534375
transcript.pyannote[168].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[168].start 444.55221875
transcript.pyannote[168].end 449.66534375
transcript.pyannote[169].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[169].start 449.66534375
transcript.pyannote[169].end 451.89284375
transcript.pyannote[170].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[170].start 449.68221875
transcript.pyannote[170].end 451.97721875
transcript.pyannote[171].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[171].start 452.09534375
transcript.pyannote[171].end 457.93409375
transcript.pyannote[172].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[172].start 457.22534375
transcript.pyannote[172].end 461.03909375
transcript.pyannote[173].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[173].start 461.44409375
transcript.pyannote[173].end 462.74346875
transcript.pyannote[174].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[174].start 462.89534375
transcript.pyannote[174].end 464.71784375
transcript.pyannote[175].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[175].start 464.98784375
transcript.pyannote[175].end 466.70909375
transcript.pyannote[176].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[176].start 465.49409375
transcript.pyannote[176].end 469.81409375
transcript.pyannote[177].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[177].start 468.64971875
transcript.pyannote[177].end 493.00034375
transcript.pyannote[178].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[178].start 476.31096875
transcript.pyannote[178].end 477.89721875
transcript.pyannote[179].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[179].start 493.43909375
transcript.pyannote[179].end 495.07596875
transcript.pyannote[180].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[180].start 496.88159375
transcript.pyannote[180].end 498.11346875
transcript.pyannote[181].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[181].start 498.80534375
transcript.pyannote[181].end 503.37846875
transcript.pyannote[182].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[182].start 504.30659375
transcript.pyannote[182].end 505.94346875
transcript.pyannote[183].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[183].start 506.01096875
transcript.pyannote[183].end 506.16284375
transcript.pyannote[184].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[184].start 506.70284375
transcript.pyannote[184].end 508.01909375
transcript.pyannote[185].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[185].start 508.59284375
transcript.pyannote[185].end 512.65971875
transcript.pyannote[186].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[186].start 513.08159375
transcript.pyannote[186].end 516.01784375
transcript.pyannote[187].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[187].start 516.65909375
transcript.pyannote[187].end 519.19034375
transcript.pyannote[188].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[188].start 520.54034375
transcript.pyannote[188].end 521.75534375
transcript.pyannote[189].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[189].start 522.09284375
transcript.pyannote[189].end 525.43409375
transcript.pyannote[190].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[190].start 526.31159375
transcript.pyannote[190].end 527.39159375
transcript.pyannote[191].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[191].start 527.52659375
transcript.pyannote[191].end 532.31909375
transcript.pyannote[192].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[192].start 532.74096875
transcript.pyannote[192].end 535.60971875
transcript.pyannote[193].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[193].start 536.11596875
transcript.pyannote[193].end 536.79096875
transcript.pyannote[194].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[194].start 537.24659375
transcript.pyannote[194].end 539.77784375
transcript.pyannote[195].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[195].start 540.25034375
transcript.pyannote[195].end 542.05596875
transcript.pyannote[196].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[196].start 542.86596875
transcript.pyannote[196].end 545.46471875
transcript.pyannote[197].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[197].start 546.07221875
transcript.pyannote[197].end 546.54471875
transcript.pyannote[198].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[198].start 547.45596875
transcript.pyannote[198].end 547.99596875
transcript.pyannote[199].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[199].start 548.65409375
transcript.pyannote[199].end 549.36284375
transcript.pyannote[200].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[200].start 549.98721875
transcript.pyannote[200].end 553.24409375
transcript.pyannote[201].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[201].start 553.85159375
transcript.pyannote[201].end 556.38284375
transcript.pyannote[202].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[202].start 557.07471875
transcript.pyannote[202].end 558.03659375
transcript.pyannote[203].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[203].start 558.30659375
transcript.pyannote[203].end 561.09096875
transcript.pyannote[204].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[204].start 561.47909375
transcript.pyannote[204].end 563.09909375
transcript.pyannote[205].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[205].start 564.07784375
transcript.pyannote[205].end 565.81596875
transcript.pyannote[206].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[206].start 566.99721875
transcript.pyannote[206].end 568.12784375
transcript.pyannote[207].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[207].start 568.87034375
transcript.pyannote[207].end 570.74346875
transcript.pyannote[208].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[208].start 572.58284375
transcript.pyannote[208].end 576.27846875
transcript.pyannote[209].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[209].start 577.54409375
transcript.pyannote[209].end 579.28221875
transcript.pyannote[210].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[210].start 579.99096875
transcript.pyannote[210].end 582.06659375
transcript.pyannote[211].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[211].start 582.31971875
transcript.pyannote[211].end 583.01159375
transcript.pyannote[212].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[212].start 583.19721875
transcript.pyannote[212].end 584.96909375
transcript.pyannote[213].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[213].start 586.31909375
transcript.pyannote[213].end 586.97721875
transcript.pyannote[214].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[214].start 588.07409375
transcript.pyannote[214].end 589.39034375
transcript.pyannote[215].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[215].start 590.20034375
transcript.pyannote[215].end 593.22096875
transcript.pyannote[216].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[216].start 594.23346875
transcript.pyannote[216].end 599.49846875
transcript.pyannote[217].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[217].start 600.64596875
transcript.pyannote[217].end 601.64159375
transcript.pyannote[218].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[218].start 602.19846875
transcript.pyannote[218].end 602.45159375
transcript.pyannote[219].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[219].start 603.21096875
transcript.pyannote[219].end 603.73409375
transcript.pyannote[220].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[220].start 605.84346875
transcript.pyannote[220].end 606.78846875
transcript.pyannote[221].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[221].start 608.23971875
transcript.pyannote[221].end 609.28596875
transcript.pyannote[222].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[222].start 609.96096875
transcript.pyannote[222].end 610.23096875
transcript.pyannote[223].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[223].start 611.71596875
transcript.pyannote[223].end 614.44971875
transcript.pyannote[224].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[224].start 614.48346875
transcript.pyannote[224].end 615.17534375
transcript.pyannote[225].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[225].start 615.79971875
transcript.pyannote[225].end 616.27221875
transcript.pyannote[226].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[226].start 617.13284375
transcript.pyannote[226].end 618.21284375
transcript.pyannote[227].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[227].start 618.71909375
transcript.pyannote[227].end 620.74409375
transcript.pyannote[228].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[228].start 620.98034375
transcript.pyannote[228].end 621.85784375
transcript.pyannote[229].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[229].start 622.63409375
transcript.pyannote[229].end 624.27096875
transcript.pyannote[230].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[230].start 625.63784375
transcript.pyannote[230].end 626.04284375
transcript.pyannote[231].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[231].start 627.02159375
transcript.pyannote[231].end 628.82721875
transcript.pyannote[232].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[232].start 629.90721875
transcript.pyannote[232].end 635.64471875
transcript.pyannote[233].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[233].start 636.16784375
transcript.pyannote[233].end 637.18034375
transcript.pyannote[234].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[234].start 637.77096875
transcript.pyannote[234].end 638.04096875
transcript.pyannote[235].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[235].start 638.29409375
transcript.pyannote[235].end 640.72409375
transcript.pyannote[236].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[236].start 641.31471875
transcript.pyannote[236].end 643.60971875
transcript.pyannote[237].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[237].start 644.21721875
transcript.pyannote[237].end 644.47034375
transcript.pyannote[238].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[238].start 644.84159375
transcript.pyannote[238].end 646.02284375
transcript.pyannote[239].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[239].start 646.88346875
transcript.pyannote[239].end 648.94221875
transcript.pyannote[240].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[240].start 649.54971875
transcript.pyannote[240].end 651.18659375
transcript.pyannote[241].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[241].start 651.40596875
transcript.pyannote[241].end 653.61659375
transcript.pyannote[242].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[242].start 654.07221875
transcript.pyannote[242].end 654.71346875
transcript.pyannote[243].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[243].start 655.27034375
transcript.pyannote[243].end 656.75534375
transcript.pyannote[244].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[244].start 656.99159375
transcript.pyannote[244].end 659.33721875
transcript.pyannote[245].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[245].start 660.70409375
transcript.pyannote[245].end 666.82971875
transcript.pyannote[246].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[246].start 667.72409375
transcript.pyannote[246].end 668.97284375
transcript.pyannote[247].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[247].start 669.88409375
transcript.pyannote[247].end 671.53784375
transcript.pyannote[248].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[248].start 671.97659375
transcript.pyannote[248].end 673.83284375
transcript.pyannote[249].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[249].start 674.92971875
transcript.pyannote[249].end 677.42721875
transcript.pyannote[250].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[250].start 678.08534375
transcript.pyannote[250].end 679.50284375
transcript.pyannote[251].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[251].start 680.39721875
transcript.pyannote[251].end 681.22409375
transcript.pyannote[252].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[252].start 681.86534375
transcript.pyannote[252].end 682.74284375
transcript.pyannote[253].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[253].start 683.24909375
transcript.pyannote[253].end 684.27846875
transcript.pyannote[254].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[254].start 684.75096875
transcript.pyannote[254].end 685.47659375
transcript.pyannote[255].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[255].start 686.01659375
transcript.pyannote[255].end 687.80534375
transcript.pyannote[256].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[256].start 688.46346875
transcript.pyannote[256].end 689.39159375
transcript.pyannote[257].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[257].start 690.06659375
transcript.pyannote[257].end 692.12534375
transcript.pyannote[258].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[258].start 692.85096875
transcript.pyannote[258].end 694.31909375
transcript.pyannote[259].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[259].start 694.77471875
transcript.pyannote[259].end 695.95596875
transcript.pyannote[260].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[260].start 696.44534375
transcript.pyannote[260].end 697.39034375
transcript.pyannote[261].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[261].start 697.91346875
transcript.pyannote[261].end 698.20034375
transcript.pyannote[262].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[262].start 698.75721875
transcript.pyannote[262].end 700.27596875
transcript.pyannote[263].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[263].start 700.96784375
transcript.pyannote[263].end 702.89159375
transcript.pyannote[264].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[264].start 703.48221875
transcript.pyannote[264].end 707.80221875
transcript.pyannote[265].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[265].start 709.99596875
transcript.pyannote[265].end 711.02534375
transcript.pyannote[266].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[266].start 711.41346875
transcript.pyannote[266].end 715.36221875
transcript.pyannote[267].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[267].start 715.90221875
transcript.pyannote[267].end 716.79659375
transcript.pyannote[268].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[268].start 717.38721875
transcript.pyannote[268].end 718.46721875
transcript.pyannote[269].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[269].start 719.07471875
transcript.pyannote[269].end 721.20096875
transcript.pyannote[270].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[270].start 722.28096875
transcript.pyannote[270].end 723.74909375
transcript.pyannote[271].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[271].start 723.85034375
transcript.pyannote[271].end 727.09034375
transcript.pyannote[272].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[272].start 727.98471875
transcript.pyannote[272].end 731.20784375
transcript.pyannote[273].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[273].start 731.71409375
transcript.pyannote[273].end 733.89096875
transcript.pyannote[274].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[274].start 734.11034375
transcript.pyannote[274].end 734.92034375
transcript.pyannote[275].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[275].start 736.35471875
transcript.pyannote[275].end 740.21909375
transcript.pyannote[276].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[276].start 740.86034375
transcript.pyannote[276].end 745.31534375
transcript.pyannote[277].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[277].start 745.77096875
transcript.pyannote[277].end 746.47971875
transcript.pyannote[278].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[278].start 747.62721875
transcript.pyannote[278].end 750.73221875
transcript.pyannote[279].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[279].start 751.06971875
transcript.pyannote[279].end 752.45346875
transcript.pyannote[280].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[280].start 753.28034375
transcript.pyannote[280].end 754.05659375
transcript.pyannote[281].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[281].start 755.11971875
transcript.pyannote[281].end 757.36409375
transcript.pyannote[282].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[282].start 757.90409375
transcript.pyannote[282].end 759.37221875
transcript.pyannote[283].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[283].start 759.97971875
transcript.pyannote[283].end 760.78971875
transcript.pyannote[284].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[284].start 761.29596875
transcript.pyannote[284].end 761.98784375
transcript.pyannote[285].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[285].start 762.34221875
transcript.pyannote[285].end 764.38409375
transcript.pyannote[286].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[286].start 765.02534375
transcript.pyannote[286].end 767.23596875
transcript.pyannote[287].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[287].start 768.01221875
transcript.pyannote[287].end 768.45096875
transcript.pyannote[288].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[288].start 768.73784375
transcript.pyannote[288].end 772.43346875
transcript.pyannote[289].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[289].start 773.00721875
transcript.pyannote[289].end 774.94784375
transcript.pyannote[290].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[290].start 776.53409375
transcript.pyannote[290].end 778.28909375
transcript.pyannote[291].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[291].start 779.74034375
transcript.pyannote[291].end 781.66409375
transcript.pyannote[292].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[292].start 782.33909375
transcript.pyannote[292].end 783.77346875
transcript.pyannote[293].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[293].start 784.90409375
transcript.pyannote[293].end 785.98409375
transcript.pyannote[294].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[294].start 786.43971875
transcript.pyannote[294].end 786.91221875
transcript.pyannote[295].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[295].start 787.45221875
transcript.pyannote[295].end 789.62909375
transcript.pyannote[296].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[296].start 791.18159375
transcript.pyannote[296].end 792.51471875
transcript.pyannote[297].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[297].start 793.07159375
transcript.pyannote[297].end 793.91534375
transcript.pyannote[298].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[298].start 795.01221875
transcript.pyannote[298].end 797.79659375
transcript.pyannote[299].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[299].start 798.62346875
transcript.pyannote[299].end 800.04096875
transcript.pyannote[300].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[300].start 801.05346875
transcript.pyannote[300].end 801.32346875
transcript.pyannote[301].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[301].start 801.74534375
transcript.pyannote[301].end 802.36971875
transcript.pyannote[302].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[302].start 803.01096875
transcript.pyannote[302].end 807.49971875
transcript.pyannote[303].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[303].start 808.34346875
transcript.pyannote[303].end 809.67659375
transcript.pyannote[304].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[304].start 810.92534375
transcript.pyannote[304].end 811.68471875
transcript.pyannote[305].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[305].start 812.20784375
transcript.pyannote[305].end 813.45659375
transcript.pyannote[306].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[306].start 813.86159375
transcript.pyannote[306].end 814.85721875
transcript.pyannote[307].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[307].start 815.21159375
transcript.pyannote[307].end 816.07221875
transcript.pyannote[308].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[308].start 816.76409375
transcript.pyannote[308].end 818.95784375
transcript.pyannote[309].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[309].start 818.97471875
transcript.pyannote[309].end 819.02534375
transcript.pyannote[310].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[310].start 819.04221875
transcript.pyannote[310].end 820.56096875
transcript.pyannote[311].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[311].start 821.30346875
transcript.pyannote[311].end 823.29471875
transcript.pyannote[312].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[312].start 823.44659375
transcript.pyannote[312].end 824.86409375
transcript.pyannote[313].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[313].start 825.42096875
transcript.pyannote[313].end 826.04534375
transcript.pyannote[314].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[314].start 826.97346875
transcript.pyannote[314].end 827.49659375
transcript.pyannote[315].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[315].start 828.47534375
transcript.pyannote[315].end 829.97721875
transcript.pyannote[316].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[316].start 831.15846875
transcript.pyannote[316].end 833.70659375
transcript.pyannote[317].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[317].start 834.14534375
transcript.pyannote[317].end 834.76971875
transcript.pyannote[318].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[318].start 836.67659375
transcript.pyannote[318].end 839.00534375
transcript.pyannote[319].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[319].start 839.56221875
transcript.pyannote[319].end 840.62534375
transcript.pyannote[320].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[320].start 841.84034375
transcript.pyannote[320].end 842.88659375
transcript.pyannote[321].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[321].start 844.20284375
transcript.pyannote[321].end 845.83971875
transcript.pyannote[322].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[322].start 846.34596875
transcript.pyannote[322].end 849.55221875
transcript.pyannote[323].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[323].start 850.22721875
transcript.pyannote[323].end 850.61534375
transcript.pyannote[324].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[324].start 851.76284375
transcript.pyannote[324].end 852.20159375
transcript.pyannote[325].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[325].start 852.74159375
transcript.pyannote[325].end 853.78784375
transcript.pyannote[326].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[326].start 854.78346875
transcript.pyannote[326].end 855.23909375
transcript.pyannote[327].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[327].start 857.12909375
transcript.pyannote[327].end 858.10784375
transcript.pyannote[328].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[328].start 858.52971875
transcript.pyannote[328].end 860.97659375
transcript.pyannote[329].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[329].start 862.30971875
transcript.pyannote[329].end 863.38971875
transcript.pyannote[330].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[330].start 864.19971875
transcript.pyannote[330].end 866.07284375
transcript.pyannote[331].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[331].start 866.27534375
transcript.pyannote[331].end 867.05159375
transcript.pyannote[332].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[332].start 867.40596875
transcript.pyannote[332].end 868.82346875
transcript.pyannote[333].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[333].start 869.59971875
transcript.pyannote[333].end 870.44346875
transcript.pyannote[334].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[334].start 871.57409375
transcript.pyannote[334].end 874.54409375
transcript.pyannote[335].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[335].start 876.18096875
transcript.pyannote[335].end 878.22284375
transcript.pyannote[336].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[336].start 880.28159375
transcript.pyannote[336].end 883.16721875
transcript.pyannote[337].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[337].start 883.80846875
transcript.pyannote[337].end 885.19221875
transcript.pyannote[338].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[338].start 885.47909375
transcript.pyannote[338].end 886.49159375
transcript.pyannote[339].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[339].start 887.48721875
transcript.pyannote[339].end 890.01846875
transcript.pyannote[340].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[340].start 890.59221875
transcript.pyannote[340].end 891.40221875
transcript.pyannote[341].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[341].start 892.27971875
transcript.pyannote[341].end 894.18659375
transcript.pyannote[342].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[342].start 894.97971875
transcript.pyannote[342].end 896.07659375
transcript.pyannote[343].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[343].start 896.93721875
transcript.pyannote[343].end 899.26596875
transcript.pyannote[344].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[344].start 900.54846875
transcript.pyannote[344].end 902.10096875
transcript.pyannote[345].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[345].start 903.83909375
transcript.pyannote[345].end 904.39596875
transcript.pyannote[346].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[346].start 904.93596875
transcript.pyannote[346].end 905.49284375
transcript.pyannote[347].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[347].start 907.11284375
transcript.pyannote[347].end 908.47971875
transcript.pyannote[348].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[348].start 909.28971875
transcript.pyannote[348].end 912.04034375
transcript.pyannote[349].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[349].start 913.57596875
transcript.pyannote[349].end 914.30159375
transcript.pyannote[350].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[350].start 914.70659375
transcript.pyannote[350].end 916.07346875
transcript.pyannote[351].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[351].start 917.10284375
transcript.pyannote[351].end 919.58346875
transcript.pyannote[352].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[352].start 920.54534375
transcript.pyannote[352].end 921.69284375
transcript.pyannote[353].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[353].start 922.06409375
transcript.pyannote[353].end 922.68846875
transcript.pyannote[354].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[354].start 923.43096875
transcript.pyannote[354].end 924.66284375
transcript.pyannote[355].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[355].start 925.35471875
transcript.pyannote[355].end 928.29096875
transcript.pyannote[356].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[356].start 928.57784375
transcript.pyannote[356].end 930.11346875
transcript.pyannote[357].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[357].start 932.07096875
transcript.pyannote[357].end 932.39159375
transcript.pyannote[358].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[358].start 933.58971875
transcript.pyannote[358].end 939.42846875
transcript.pyannote[359].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[359].start 940.15409375
transcript.pyannote[359].end 956.77596875
transcript.pyannote[360].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[360].start 956.99534375
transcript.pyannote[360].end 962.00721875
transcript.pyannote[361].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[361].start 963.05346875
transcript.pyannote[361].end 971.91284375
transcript.pyannote[362].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[362].start 972.13221875
transcript.pyannote[362].end 977.44784375
transcript.pyannote[363].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[363].start 977.54909375
transcript.pyannote[363].end 981.19409375
transcript.pyannote[364].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[364].start 981.58221875
transcript.pyannote[364].end 983.11784375
transcript.pyannote[365].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[365].start 983.72534375
transcript.pyannote[365].end 984.38346875
transcript.pyannote[366].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[366].start 984.88971875
transcript.pyannote[366].end 985.83471875
transcript.pyannote[367].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[367].start 986.94846875
transcript.pyannote[367].end 988.82159375
transcript.pyannote[368].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[368].start 989.12534375
transcript.pyannote[368].end 990.93096875
transcript.pyannote[369].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[369].start 991.23471875
transcript.pyannote[369].end 993.49596875
transcript.pyannote[370].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[370].start 993.68159375
transcript.pyannote[370].end 994.62659375
transcript.pyannote[371].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[371].start 995.79096875
transcript.pyannote[371].end 996.88784375
transcript.pyannote[372].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[372].start 999.13221875
transcript.pyannote[372].end 1000.33034375
transcript.pyannote[373].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[373].start 1000.65096875
transcript.pyannote[373].end 1003.58721875
transcript.pyannote[374].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[374].start 1005.27471875
transcript.pyannote[374].end 1006.86096875
transcript.pyannote[375].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[375].start 1007.83971875
transcript.pyannote[375].end 1010.69159375
transcript.pyannote[376].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[376].start 1013.22284375
transcript.pyannote[376].end 1016.26034375
transcript.pyannote[377].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[377].start 1019.26409375
transcript.pyannote[377].end 1021.35659375
transcript.pyannote[378].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[378].start 1022.01471875
transcript.pyannote[378].end 1025.50784375
transcript.pyannote[379].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[379].start 1025.72721875
transcript.pyannote[379].end 1027.07721875
transcript.pyannote[380].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[380].start 1028.15721875
transcript.pyannote[380].end 1030.77284375
transcript.pyannote[381].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[381].start 1031.93721875
transcript.pyannote[381].end 1032.96659375
transcript.pyannote[382].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[382].start 1033.82721875
transcript.pyannote[382].end 1034.38409375
transcript.pyannote[383].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[383].start 1035.05909375
transcript.pyannote[383].end 1036.47659375
transcript.pyannote[384].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[384].start 1036.78034375
transcript.pyannote[384].end 1039.09221875
transcript.pyannote[385].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[385].start 1040.37471875
transcript.pyannote[385].end 1043.41221875
transcript.pyannote[386].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[386].start 1043.88471875
transcript.pyannote[386].end 1044.71159375
transcript.pyannote[387].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[387].start 1045.94346875
transcript.pyannote[387].end 1047.32721875
transcript.pyannote[388].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[388].start 1047.85034375
transcript.pyannote[388].end 1048.33971875
transcript.pyannote[389].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[389].start 1048.60971875
transcript.pyannote[389].end 1049.94284375
transcript.pyannote[390].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[390].start 1050.29721875
transcript.pyannote[390].end 1050.90471875
transcript.pyannote[391].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[391].start 1051.81596875
transcript.pyannote[391].end 1055.68034375
transcript.pyannote[392].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[392].start 1056.16971875
transcript.pyannote[392].end 1058.86971875
transcript.pyannote[393].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[393].start 1059.91596875
transcript.pyannote[393].end 1061.97471875
transcript.pyannote[394].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[394].start 1062.83534375
transcript.pyannote[394].end 1064.08409375
transcript.pyannote[395].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[395].start 1065.11346875
transcript.pyannote[395].end 1065.83909375
transcript.pyannote[396].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[396].start 1066.98659375
transcript.pyannote[396].end 1067.30721875
transcript.pyannote[397].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[397].start 1067.64471875
transcript.pyannote[397].end 1068.92721875
transcript.pyannote[398].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[398].start 1069.61909375
transcript.pyannote[398].end 1070.29409375
transcript.pyannote[399].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[399].start 1070.59784375
transcript.pyannote[399].end 1072.89284375
transcript.pyannote[400].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[400].start 1073.51721875
transcript.pyannote[400].end 1074.05721875
transcript.pyannote[401].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[401].start 1074.52971875
transcript.pyannote[401].end 1075.00221875
transcript.pyannote[402].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[402].start 1075.62659375
transcript.pyannote[402].end 1077.01034375
transcript.pyannote[403].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[403].start 1077.43221875
transcript.pyannote[403].end 1078.46159375
transcript.pyannote[404].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[404].start 1082.05596875
transcript.pyannote[404].end 1084.35096875
transcript.pyannote[405].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[405].start 1085.80221875
transcript.pyannote[405].end 1087.01721875
transcript.pyannote[406].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[406].start 1087.21971875
transcript.pyannote[406].end 1088.13096875
transcript.pyannote[407].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[407].start 1088.70471875
transcript.pyannote[407].end 1089.27846875
transcript.pyannote[408].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[408].start 1089.44721875
transcript.pyannote[408].end 1090.03784375
transcript.pyannote[409].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[409].start 1090.76346875
transcript.pyannote[409].end 1092.33284375
transcript.pyannote[410].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[410].start 1092.90659375
transcript.pyannote[410].end 1093.75034375
transcript.pyannote[411].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[411].start 1095.97784375
transcript.pyannote[411].end 1096.92284375
transcript.pyannote[412].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[412].start 1097.20971875
transcript.pyannote[412].end 1098.76221875
transcript.pyannote[413].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[413].start 1099.30221875
transcript.pyannote[413].end 1100.60159375
transcript.pyannote[414].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[414].start 1100.82096875
transcript.pyannote[414].end 1102.27221875
transcript.pyannote[415].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[415].start 1103.47034375
transcript.pyannote[415].end 1104.49971875
transcript.pyannote[416].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[416].start 1105.22534375
transcript.pyannote[416].end 1106.30534375
transcript.pyannote[417].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[417].start 1107.48659375
transcript.pyannote[417].end 1108.12784375
transcript.pyannote[418].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[418].start 1108.61721875
transcript.pyannote[418].end 1109.44409375
transcript.pyannote[419].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[419].start 1109.83221875
transcript.pyannote[419].end 1111.13159375
transcript.pyannote[420].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[420].start 1111.31721875
transcript.pyannote[420].end 1112.68409375
transcript.pyannote[421].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[421].start 1113.27471875
transcript.pyannote[421].end 1114.23659375
transcript.pyannote[422].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[422].start 1115.16471875
transcript.pyannote[422].end 1117.10534375
transcript.pyannote[423].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[423].start 1118.87721875
transcript.pyannote[423].end 1124.20971875
transcript.pyannote[424].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[424].start 1124.81721875
transcript.pyannote[424].end 1126.09971875
transcript.pyannote[425].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[425].start 1126.65659375
transcript.pyannote[425].end 1128.09096875
transcript.pyannote[426].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[426].start 1129.30596875
transcript.pyannote[426].end 1131.70221875
transcript.pyannote[427].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[427].start 1131.78659375
transcript.pyannote[427].end 1132.37721875
transcript.pyannote[428].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[428].start 1132.79909375
transcript.pyannote[428].end 1133.13659375
transcript.pyannote[429].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[429].start 1133.62596875
transcript.pyannote[429].end 1136.12346875
transcript.pyannote[430].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[430].start 1136.84909375
transcript.pyannote[430].end 1137.84471875
transcript.pyannote[431].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[431].start 1138.31721875
transcript.pyannote[431].end 1139.26221875
transcript.pyannote[432].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[432].start 1139.36346875
transcript.pyannote[432].end 1141.67534375
transcript.pyannote[433].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[433].start 1142.28284375
transcript.pyannote[433].end 1143.37971875
transcript.pyannote[434].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[434].start 1144.10534375
transcript.pyannote[434].end 1145.91096875
transcript.pyannote[435].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[435].start 1147.12596875
transcript.pyannote[435].end 1148.83034375
transcript.pyannote[436].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[436].start 1149.23534375
transcript.pyannote[436].end 1149.99471875
transcript.pyannote[437].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[437].start 1151.56409375
transcript.pyannote[437].end 1151.83409375
transcript.pyannote[438].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[438].start 1152.61034375
transcript.pyannote[438].end 1153.47096875
transcript.pyannote[439].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[439].start 1155.05721875
transcript.pyannote[439].end 1156.67721875
transcript.pyannote[440].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[440].start 1157.20034375
transcript.pyannote[440].end 1158.71909375
transcript.pyannote[441].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[441].start 1160.60909375
transcript.pyannote[441].end 1162.98846875
transcript.pyannote[442].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[442].start 1163.51159375
transcript.pyannote[442].end 1165.77284375
transcript.pyannote[443].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[443].start 1166.29596875
transcript.pyannote[443].end 1166.98784375
transcript.pyannote[444].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[444].start 1168.00034375
transcript.pyannote[444].end 1173.07971875
transcript.pyannote[445].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[445].start 1173.60284375
transcript.pyannote[445].end 1175.81346875
transcript.pyannote[446].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[446].start 1176.60659375
transcript.pyannote[446].end 1182.58034375
transcript.pyannote[447].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[447].start 1183.49159375
transcript.pyannote[447].end 1183.76159375
transcript.pyannote[448].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[448].start 1184.30159375
transcript.pyannote[448].end 1184.58846875
transcript.pyannote[449].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[449].start 1184.77409375
transcript.pyannote[449].end 1186.66409375
transcript.pyannote[450].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[450].start 1186.95096875
transcript.pyannote[450].end 1187.84534375
transcript.pyannote[451].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[451].start 1189.93784375
transcript.pyannote[451].end 1192.28346875
transcript.pyannote[452].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[452].start 1192.55346875
transcript.pyannote[452].end 1193.59971875
transcript.pyannote[453].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[453].start 1194.22409375
transcript.pyannote[453].end 1208.17971875
transcript.pyannote[454].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[454].start 1208.38221875
transcript.pyannote[454].end 1212.31409375
transcript.pyannote[455].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[455].start 1212.85409375
transcript.pyannote[455].end 1213.47846875
transcript.pyannote[456].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[456].start 1213.95096875
transcript.pyannote[456].end 1216.44846875
transcript.pyannote[457].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[457].start 1216.88721875
transcript.pyannote[457].end 1218.69284375
transcript.pyannote[458].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[458].start 1219.36784375
transcript.pyannote[458].end 1222.64159375
transcript.pyannote[459].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[459].start 1222.82721875
transcript.pyannote[459].end 1225.13909375
transcript.pyannote[460].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[460].start 1234.38659375
transcript.pyannote[460].end 1239.92159375
transcript.whisperx[0].start 7.419
transcript.whisperx[0].end 33.551
transcript.whisperx[0].text 副院長有請王備提名人請備提名人答詢你好委員好你好嗎的意思好今天我們審查大法官備提名人
transcript.whisperx[1].start 34.755
transcript.whisperx[1].end 63.482
transcript.whisperx[1].text 我們看這個憲法很清楚憲法第62條立法院為國家最高立法機關由人民選舉之立法委員組織之代表人民行使立法前尤其是法律案的制定而我們的憲法增修條文第12條對於修憲的門檻非常的高
transcript.whisperx[2].start 64.845
transcript.whisperx[2].end 93.512
transcript.whisperx[2].text 要四分之三的立法委員的的決議不僅僅是四分之三的立法委員而且還要經過公民投票附解是不是這樣所以我們看這個憲法第78條司法院解釋憲法並有統一解釋法律及命令之前是解釋憲法
transcript.whisperx[3].start 95.578
transcript.whisperx[3].end 123.345
transcript.whisperx[3].text 所以在做相關的違憲的審查的時候不應該一頁立法委員、立法院的立法簽而我們看這幾年幾個重大的這些解釋大法官的解釋都被批評為造反甚至修憲了
transcript.whisperx[4].start 124.611
transcript.whisperx[4].end 150.678
transcript.whisperx[4].text 甚至修憲 等一下會再跟你做一個討論所以大法官不應造法不應修憲不應一頁立法院的立法權跟修憲權尤其是修憲這還要經過人民的公投覆決我們看這個113年憲判制第8號最有爭議的這個廢除死刑
transcript.whisperx[5].start 154.56
transcript.whisperx[5].end 182.147
transcript.whisperx[5].text 雖然沒有完全廢除但是對於有幾條刑法的條文認為違憲而且相關的機制還要從你看還要什麼我們就以判決主文的第6條科處死刑之判決應經各級法院和議庭法官一致解而且還沒有修法之前
transcript.whisperx[6].start 183.567
transcript.whisperx[6].end 191.529
transcript.whisperx[6].text 委員關於宪判制113年宪判8號.這個判決本身當然就是基於這個宪法訴訟法38條.
transcript.whisperx[7].start 211.778
transcript.whisperx[7].end 232.665
transcript.whisperx[7].text 第一項的規定就是居宿全國各機關及人民有居宿全國各機關及人民的效力所以我們也就是先尊重就是這樣子事實上如果這個案子要做公投絕對不會過高達83%的民眾不贊同廢除事項
transcript.whisperx[8].start 241.127
transcript.whisperx[8].end 267.678
transcript.whisperx[8].text 所以這個部分呢這樣的一個幾次的判決之後因為你之前在大法官的書記處當處長現在是嗎現在是最高行政法院的法官你之前在那邊你也推動了這個憲法訴訟法對不對所以這個憲法訴訟法顯然是要去檢討以這最近的幾個判決來看的話
transcript.whisperx[9].start 271.233
transcript.whisperx[9].end 294.191
transcript.whisperx[9].text 大法官的實體判決跟憲法訴訟法的程序規定這是兩件事情我知道但是相關的這些規定絕對有影響我們就看這個好接下來看這個103年4月18號釋制第719號對於原住民族工作權保障法
transcript.whisperx[10].start 295.693
transcript.whisperx[10].end 317.004
transcript.whisperx[10].text 當時的大法官.尚無違背憲法第7條平等原則及第23條比例原則.以憲法第15條保障之財產權及其工作權之內涵.之營業自由之意旨並無不符.當時的大法官.然後會因為大法官的一個.
transcript.whisperx[11].start 320.197
transcript.whisperx[11].end 342.822
transcript.whisperx[11].text 思維不同、見解不同:又改變了這你的報告裡面有提到110年10月8號釋字第810號就變成對人民受憲法第15條保障之財產權所為限制顯不符相當性而有違憲法第23條比例原則
transcript.whisperx[12].start 345.942
transcript.whisperx[12].end 371.079
transcript.whisperx[12].text 前面103年的時候沒有過了7年:因為大法官不同、見解不同:就改變了這樣的一個:而且規定呢:重點是你可以:經過民國90年:制定的工作權保障法:研究民主工作權保障法:經過多年之後:
transcript.whisperx[13].start 372.199
transcript.whisperx[13].end 374.001
transcript.whisperx[13].text 委員這件案子我可以說明一下嗎?
transcript.whisperx[14].start 394.16
transcript.whisperx[14].end 420.908
transcript.whisperx[14].text 請說這件案子其實就是我們在行政法院在遇到這樣的一個這個貸金的案件裡頭就遇到這種採購法裡面那個小案件大公司去接小案件對於這個貸金對於原住民我沒有否認要修正但是你不可以當然不是你了
transcript.whisperx[15].start 421.806
transcript.whisperx[15].end 440.974
transcript.whisperx[15].text 大法官不可以直接一頁立法前.你可以請立法院或相關機關.確實有不符比例原則要修.但是不可以直接就要求法院.這種案子你就要依本院的意旨.
transcript.whisperx[16].start 442.524
transcript.whisperx[16].end 460.791
transcript.whisperx[16].text 還是有還是要經過修法修法還是交給立法前我的重點在這邊好不好因為這不是你判的了這個案子是我們何議廷申請的所以委員我再補充一句好不好我知道你的這個範疇我都看了我都看了
transcript.whisperx[17].start 462.292
transcript.whisperx[17].end 477.071
transcript.whisperx[17].text 這個當初這個原住民族採購法在您訂的時候我在人民會服務啦我們完全肯定要對於原住民有很好的保障只是這一件就是他的這個貸金的金額已經超過他的採購案
transcript.whisperx[18].start 478.613
transcript.whisperx[18].end 483.656
transcript.whisperx[18].text 原住民身份法106年8月8號行政院含送到立法院他最主要的就是針對
transcript.whisperx[19].start 506.769
transcript.whisperx[19].end 524.798
transcript.whisperx[19].text 平埔原住民納入在這個原住民身份法的草案裡面要列入106年8月8號行政院函送到立法院立法院經過內政委員會召開了多次的公聽會
transcript.whisperx[20].start 526.345
transcript.whisperx[20].end 545.255
transcript.whisperx[20].text 然後立法院的內政委員會也審查完成審查107年12月24號完成審查你也知道第9屆的立法院當時的立法院民進黨絕對多數而且是行政院送來的法案對不對
transcript.whisperx[21].start 547.489
transcript.whisperx[21].end 574.335
transcript.whisperx[21].text 但是第9屆從107年內政委員會審查到109年1月31號立法院民進黨團絕對多數的民進黨團都沒有把他列入要二讀三讀的這個議案裡面所以就沒有完成三讀成績第10屆的立法院109年到113年
transcript.whisperx[22].start 577.651
transcript.whisperx[22].end 606.58
transcript.whisperx[22].text 行政院就沒有再送來至少在第109年沒有送來110年也沒有送來但是呢司法院大法官在111年現判之第4號針對剛才講的那個原住民身份法第二條平埔原住民這個部分這是另外一個你看看這個部分
transcript.whisperx[23].start 608.297
transcript.whisperx[23].end 635.288
transcript.whisperx[23].text 相關的這個部分就做了這樣的一個判決所以我要講的是說原住民身份法涉及到原住民他是不是原住民 對不對要尊重原住民主你要知道原住民身份法的立法的歷程我跟你講我那時候是人民會的處長負責這個業務
transcript.whisperx[24].start 638.382
transcript.whisperx[24].end 665.783
transcript.whisperx[24].text 我要把原住民身份認定標準提升為法例的位階以前是認定標準提升為法例的位階在草擬的過程當中我們委託政治大學的民族研究所去做徵詢深度訪談原住民族包括我們的立法委員當時的前任的立法委員也做了部落的訪談
transcript.whisperx[25].start 668.423
transcript.whisperx[25].end 697.226
transcript.whisperx[25].text 經過這樣的一個深度訪談之後再經過相關的寫者的一個審查提供意見然後草擬了草案這個草案在園民會有族群委員這些族群委員各族都有來審查然後送到行政院行政院都沒有動喔尊重園民會的族群委員
transcript.whisperx[26].start 698.807
transcript.whisperx[26].end 725.576
transcript.whisperx[26].text 然後送到立法院.民國89年送到立法院.立法委員也有版本.經過立法委員的審查之後.三讀通過.是這樣的一個歷程.誰既被原住民身份.誰不是.應該是怎麼樣.應該是要尊重原住民族.因為聯合國原住民族前例先言.第33條規定.
transcript.whisperx[27].start 728.055
transcript.whisperx[27].end 753.545
transcript.whisperx[27].text 原住民族有權按照其習俗及傳統決定自己的身份或歸屬。憲法增修條文第10條第12項也規定國家因應民族意願保障原住民族之地位所以這個部分聯合國的原住民族權利宣言跟憲法增修條文都有這樣的一個規定我們看這個
transcript.whisperx[28].start 756.009
transcript.whisperx[28].end 783.508
transcript.whisperx[28].text 111年的憲判之第17號的主文特別規定這裡面就是談到平埔原住民的部分平埔原住民我剛有講了對不對行政院主動要修這個原住民身份法立法院經過多次的審查之後而且民進黨絕對多數他仍然不認同
transcript.whisperx[29].start 784.986
transcript.whisperx[29].end 808.865
transcript.whisperx[29].text 行政院的版本所以沒有讓他二讀三讀是這樣就是在尊重當時的原住民身份法的立法的過程原住民主的意見然後呢做這樣的一個111年憲判之第17號的主文這裡面就說違憲
transcript.whisperx[30].start 811.29
transcript.whisperx[30].end 840.422
transcript.whisperx[30].text 違憲而且還要定時間如果還定時間而且這三年內沒有修的話就直接就可以取得原住民身份這就是一頁的立法權不只是一頁立法權我告訴你 被聽命了而且也一頁了立法院的修憲權為什麼呢民國81年修憲的時候有兩個提案
transcript.whisperx[31].start 841.912
transcript.whisperx[31].end 870.302
transcript.whisperx[31].text 有兩個提案是要把平埔族納入到憲法所謂的三包裡面但是表決沒有通過不同意83年啊三包修正為原住民的時候也有一個提案就是要把平埔族納入到所謂的原住民原住民族
transcript.whisperx[32].start 872.562
transcript.whisperx[32].end 899.18
transcript.whisperx[32].text 經過審查之後表決不通過表決多少?四分之三啊!四分之三的表決啊!國民大會啊!就跟現在一樣啊!四分之三啊!四分之三的表決不通過而現在﹐大法官﹐幾位大法官﹐沒有人民的﹐沒有參採﹐也沒有問原住民族啊!
transcript.whisperx[33].start 900.592
transcript.whisperx[33].end 927.414
transcript.whisperx[33].text 你沒有遵循原住民主就說違憲這不是修憲嗎大法官就竟然做了修憲的一個一頁的憲法對於司法院你只有解釋憲法現在不只是修造法而且還修憲你認為這樣是不是修憲因為當初有討論國民大會有討論這個
transcript.whisperx[34].start 934.018
transcript.whisperx[34].end 938.942
transcript.whisperx[34].text 大法官對於憲法有解釋的權利當然就是說在
transcript.whisperx[35].start 940.33
transcript.whisperx[35].end 961.16
transcript.whisperx[35].text 是因為憲法的這個條文.包括即使我們有憲法徵修條文.條文還是非常的少.所以大法官就要依照他的這個.就是根據他的所調查的.所有的立法資料.所有案件的資料去解釋.去充實那個憲法規定的意義.
transcript.whisperx[36].start 963.189
transcript.whisperx[36].end 985.676
transcript.whisperx[36].text 所以大法官的解釋是有豐富憲法意涵但是跟修憲應該還是有距離的應該不能稱為修憲這樣子這是修憲因為當初在國民大會確實討論了平埔族要不要納入
transcript.whisperx[37].start 986.994
transcript.whisperx[37].end 1015.939
transcript.whisperx[37].text 而且是經過表決.討論之後經過表決.4分之3的決議不通過.所以這個部分.這個大法官.可能沒有去了解過去的歷史背景.而且最重要的就是沒有徵詢嚴肅民主的意見我給你讓貝提米納了解一下
transcript.whisperx[38].start 1019.618
transcript.whisperx[38].end 1044.543
transcript.whisperx[38].text 從清朝開始:可能清朝更早就有了:我是沒有那個資料:至少清朝:生番熟番的劃分:就很明確了:而且:定在法例裡面:清朝的法例:大清粒粒:明業界入生番地:勢同出道:入官善
transcript.whisperx[39].start 1046.01
transcript.whisperx[39].end 1068.755
transcript.whisperx[39].text 生番地就是生番,就算熟番要進去也不行所以相關的這些規定在清朝的規定裡面以至於到日本統治台灣也都是這樣生番熟番所以才後來在整個國民政府開始
transcript.whisperx[40].start 1069.676
transcript.whisperx[40].end 1093.602
transcript.whisperx[40].text 也就是一直沿用從清朝到日本到國民政府就這樣劃分台灣很多的族群對不對很多閩南人他不認同他是漢人你知道嗎不認同他是中華民族我們都尊重
transcript.whisperx[41].start 1096.041
transcript.whisperx[41].end 1123.181
transcript.whisperx[41].text 我們是從清朝就開始了很多從過去這樣的一個情形之下當然要尊重原住民族的本身就是憲法包括這是聯合國原住民族權利宣言所規範的尤其是剛才我特別提到國民大會在修憲的時候就曾經討論貧苦族
transcript.whisperx[42].start 1124.921
transcript.whisperx[42].end 1152.829
transcript.whisperx[42].text 是不是要納入.所以大法官.這個判決.這個憲法法庭的判決.是已經.不僅僅是一頁了.立法牆.尤其是一頁了立法院的修憲牆.所以這個部分.對原住民主的議題.絕對要去尊重原住民主我曾經.
transcript.whisperx[43].start 1155.097
transcript.whisperx[43].end 1182.368
transcript.whisperx[43].text 因為上一屆沒有通過我現在徵詢你的意見我在上一屆因為剛才講的判決憲法法庭的判決我提案涉及原住民族族群集體前者應先徵詢原住民族議員我是希望在憲法訴訟法裡面能夠增加這樣的條文當然當時立法院民進黨絕對多數不可能接受
transcript.whisperx[44].start 1184.912
transcript.whisperx[44].end 1212.137
transcript.whisperx[44].text 你過去誠心朝你的意見如何?我認為憲法法庭審理任何案件都應該要廣納各方面的意見所以憲法法庭也常常在行言詞辯論甚至於包括請鑑定人還包括有法庭之友的制度那當然委員您提的這個要去徵詢原族民族的意見是非常好的想法
transcript.whisperx[45].start 1212.975
transcript.whisperx[45].end 1239.256
transcript.whisperx[45].text 因為誰是中華民國的國民由中華民國來決定不可能由國際法庭來去決定一樣原住民主誰是原住民主謝謝曾委員謝謝貝提敏委員下一位請林國成委員詢問