iVOD / 157737

Field Value
video_url https://ivod-lyvod.cdn.hinet.net/vod_1/_definst_/mp4:1MClips/28156fb6ec38ead32c4fdc1f2234155813383a67259e81584a235b3e6ccfe5f4cb8972f08e7de1aa5ea18f28b6918d91.mp4/playlist.m3u8
委員名稱 黃珊珊
委員發言時間 16:29:39 - 16:50:03
影片長度 1224
會議時間 2024-12-03T09:00:00+08:00
會議名稱 第11屆第2會期第1次全院委員會(事由:總統咨,為考試院第十三屆院長、副院長及考試委員任期於113年8月31日屆滿,茲依據憲法增修條文第6條第2項規定,提名周弘憲為考試院第十四屆院長,許舒翔為考試院第十四屆副院長,邱文彥、鄧家基、王秀紅、呂秋慧、柯麗鈴、黃東益、伊萬.納威Iwan Nawi 7位為考試院第十四屆考試委員,咨請同意案。)
transcript.pyannote[0].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[0].start 4.03034375
transcript.pyannote[0].end 5.68409375
transcript.pyannote[1].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[1].start 5.93721875
transcript.pyannote[1].end 8.78909375
transcript.pyannote[2].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[2].start 13.56471875
transcript.pyannote[2].end 13.59846875
transcript.pyannote[3].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[3].start 13.78409375
transcript.pyannote[3].end 13.80096875
transcript.pyannote[4].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[4].start 14.52659375
transcript.pyannote[4].end 15.23534375
transcript.pyannote[5].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[5].start 15.30284375
transcript.pyannote[5].end 21.59721875
transcript.pyannote[6].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[6].start 22.30596875
transcript.pyannote[6].end 27.03096875
transcript.pyannote[7].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[7].start 27.48659375
transcript.pyannote[7].end 28.21221875
transcript.pyannote[8].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[8].start 28.41471875
transcript.pyannote[8].end 28.90409375
transcript.pyannote[9].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[9].start 29.27534375
transcript.pyannote[9].end 32.70096875
transcript.pyannote[10].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[10].start 33.05534375
transcript.pyannote[10].end 34.79346875
transcript.pyannote[11].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[11].start 35.02971875
transcript.pyannote[11].end 35.67096875
transcript.pyannote[12].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[12].start 36.41346875
transcript.pyannote[12].end 37.20659375
transcript.pyannote[13].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[13].start 37.72971875
transcript.pyannote[13].end 38.38784375
transcript.pyannote[14].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[14].start 38.96159375
transcript.pyannote[14].end 40.04159375
transcript.pyannote[15].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[15].start 40.71659375
transcript.pyannote[15].end 45.54284375
transcript.pyannote[16].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[16].start 46.08284375
transcript.pyannote[16].end 46.77471875
transcript.pyannote[17].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[17].start 47.39909375
transcript.pyannote[17].end 49.15409375
transcript.pyannote[18].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[18].start 50.08221875
transcript.pyannote[18].end 50.50409375
transcript.pyannote[19].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[19].start 50.84159375
transcript.pyannote[19].end 51.16221875
transcript.pyannote[20].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[20].start 51.58409375
transcript.pyannote[20].end 53.23784375
transcript.pyannote[21].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[21].start 53.86221875
transcript.pyannote[21].end 57.76034375
transcript.pyannote[22].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[22].start 59.44784375
transcript.pyannote[22].end 60.07221875
transcript.pyannote[23].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[23].start 60.61221875
transcript.pyannote[23].end 66.43409375
transcript.pyannote[24].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[24].start 66.75471875
transcript.pyannote[24].end 72.32346875
transcript.pyannote[25].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[25].start 66.97409375
transcript.pyannote[25].end 68.30721875
transcript.pyannote[26].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[26].start 68.81346875
transcript.pyannote[26].end 69.82596875
transcript.pyannote[27].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[27].start 72.25596875
transcript.pyannote[27].end 73.03221875
transcript.pyannote[28].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[28].start 72.42471875
transcript.pyannote[28].end 76.69409375
transcript.pyannote[29].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[29].start 76.00221875
transcript.pyannote[29].end 78.19596875
transcript.pyannote[30].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[30].start 79.24221875
transcript.pyannote[30].end 81.73971875
transcript.pyannote[31].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[31].start 82.14471875
transcript.pyannote[31].end 82.54971875
transcript.pyannote[32].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[32].start 82.95471875
transcript.pyannote[32].end 90.16034375
transcript.pyannote[33].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[33].start 85.36784375
transcript.pyannote[33].end 85.85721875
transcript.pyannote[34].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[34].start 86.76846875
transcript.pyannote[34].end 88.33784375
transcript.pyannote[35].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[35].start 89.70471875
transcript.pyannote[35].end 90.75096875
transcript.pyannote[36].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[36].start 91.24034375
transcript.pyannote[36].end 96.03284375
transcript.pyannote[37].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[37].start 91.35846875
transcript.pyannote[37].end 91.67909375
transcript.pyannote[38].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[38].start 96.25221875
transcript.pyannote[38].end 97.45034375
transcript.pyannote[39].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[39].start 97.65284375
transcript.pyannote[39].end 99.54284375
transcript.pyannote[40].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[40].start 99.76221875
transcript.pyannote[40].end 101.48346875
transcript.pyannote[41].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[41].start 101.97284375
transcript.pyannote[41].end 104.09909375
transcript.pyannote[42].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[42].start 104.70659375
transcript.pyannote[42].end 106.76534375
transcript.pyannote[43].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[43].start 107.38971875
transcript.pyannote[43].end 112.23284375
transcript.pyannote[44].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[44].start 112.78971875
transcript.pyannote[44].end 115.96221875
transcript.pyannote[45].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[45].start 116.75534375
transcript.pyannote[45].end 124.34909375
transcript.pyannote[46].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[46].start 125.12534375
transcript.pyannote[46].end 126.57659375
transcript.pyannote[47].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[47].start 127.57221875
transcript.pyannote[47].end 136.49909375
transcript.pyannote[48].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[48].start 136.73534375
transcript.pyannote[48].end 137.79846875
transcript.pyannote[49].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[49].start 138.33846875
transcript.pyannote[49].end 139.16534375
transcript.pyannote[50].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[50].start 140.09346875
transcript.pyannote[50].end 142.42221875
transcript.pyannote[51].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[51].start 142.79346875
transcript.pyannote[51].end 147.31596875
transcript.pyannote[52].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[52].start 148.81784375
transcript.pyannote[52].end 160.76534375
transcript.pyannote[53].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[53].start 161.28846875
transcript.pyannote[53].end 161.74409375
transcript.pyannote[54].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[54].start 162.21659375
transcript.pyannote[54].end 162.63846875
transcript.pyannote[55].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[55].start 163.48221875
transcript.pyannote[55].end 164.91659375
transcript.pyannote[56].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[56].start 165.60846875
transcript.pyannote[56].end 166.58721875
transcript.pyannote[57].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[57].start 167.11034375
transcript.pyannote[57].end 167.75159375
transcript.pyannote[58].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[58].start 167.16096875
transcript.pyannote[58].end 172.27409375
transcript.pyannote[59].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[59].start 172.66221875
transcript.pyannote[59].end 183.00659375
transcript.pyannote[60].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[60].start 183.10784375
transcript.pyannote[60].end 194.29596875
transcript.pyannote[61].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[61].start 195.13971875
transcript.pyannote[61].end 211.28909375
transcript.pyannote[62].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[62].start 212.23409375
transcript.pyannote[62].end 214.46159375
transcript.pyannote[63].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[63].start 215.20409375
transcript.pyannote[63].end 223.57409375
transcript.pyannote[64].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[64].start 219.01784375
transcript.pyannote[64].end 219.47346875
transcript.pyannote[65].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[65].start 220.24971875
transcript.pyannote[65].end 224.53596875
transcript.pyannote[66].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[66].start 225.05909375
transcript.pyannote[66].end 234.37409375
transcript.pyannote[67].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[67].start 234.62721875
transcript.pyannote[67].end 237.96846875
transcript.pyannote[68].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[68].start 238.39034375
transcript.pyannote[68].end 239.65596875
transcript.pyannote[69].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[69].start 240.12846875
transcript.pyannote[69].end 241.93409375
transcript.pyannote[70].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[70].start 242.20409375
transcript.pyannote[70].end 242.79471875
transcript.pyannote[71].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[71].start 243.16596875
transcript.pyannote[71].end 247.11471875
transcript.pyannote[72].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[72].start 247.33409375
transcript.pyannote[72].end 254.20221875
transcript.pyannote[73].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[73].start 254.35409375
transcript.pyannote[73].end 256.17659375
transcript.pyannote[74].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[74].start 254.47221875
transcript.pyannote[74].end 254.91096875
transcript.pyannote[75].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[75].start 255.68721875
transcript.pyannote[75].end 263.63534375
transcript.pyannote[76].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[76].start 256.83471875
transcript.pyannote[76].end 258.79221875
transcript.pyannote[77].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[77].start 263.63534375
transcript.pyannote[77].end 265.76159375
transcript.pyannote[78].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[78].start 266.26784375
transcript.pyannote[78].end 271.75221875
transcript.pyannote[79].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[79].start 269.62596875
transcript.pyannote[79].end 271.83659375
transcript.pyannote[80].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[80].start 271.76909375
transcript.pyannote[80].end 274.75596875
transcript.pyannote[81].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[81].start 275.02596875
transcript.pyannote[81].end 276.64596875
transcript.pyannote[82].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[82].start 276.46034375
transcript.pyannote[82].end 279.71721875
transcript.pyannote[83].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[83].start 280.07159375
transcript.pyannote[83].end 282.70409375
transcript.pyannote[84].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[84].start 283.86846875
transcript.pyannote[84].end 288.54284375
transcript.pyannote[85].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[85].start 288.88034375
transcript.pyannote[85].end 289.57221875
transcript.pyannote[86].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[86].start 289.01534375
transcript.pyannote[86].end 293.89221875
transcript.pyannote[87].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[87].start 289.92659375
transcript.pyannote[87].end 290.56784375
transcript.pyannote[88].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[88].start 294.66846875
transcript.pyannote[88].end 296.54159375
transcript.pyannote[89].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[89].start 297.16596875
transcript.pyannote[89].end 302.92034375
transcript.pyannote[90].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[90].start 304.03409375
transcript.pyannote[90].end 306.86909375
transcript.pyannote[91].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[91].start 307.34159375
transcript.pyannote[91].end 308.37096875
transcript.pyannote[92].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[92].start 309.23159375
transcript.pyannote[92].end 325.60034375
transcript.pyannote[93].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[93].start 327.03471875
transcript.pyannote[93].end 332.77221875
transcript.pyannote[94].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[94].start 332.89034375
transcript.pyannote[94].end 337.66596875
transcript.pyannote[95].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[95].start 337.07534375
transcript.pyannote[95].end 340.90596875
transcript.pyannote[96].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[96].start 337.83471875
transcript.pyannote[96].end 338.20596875
transcript.pyannote[97].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[97].start 340.72034375
transcript.pyannote[97].end 348.49971875
transcript.pyannote[98].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[98].start 346.55909375
transcript.pyannote[98].end 352.76909375
transcript.pyannote[99].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[99].start 352.85346875
transcript.pyannote[99].end 356.09346875
transcript.pyannote[100].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[100].start 356.71784375
transcript.pyannote[100].end 359.36721875
transcript.pyannote[101].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[101].start 360.27846875
transcript.pyannote[101].end 372.39471875
transcript.pyannote[102].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[102].start 360.29534375
transcript.pyannote[102].end 362.32034375
transcript.pyannote[103].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[103].start 372.54659375
transcript.pyannote[103].end 379.24596875
transcript.pyannote[104].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[104].start 379.75221875
transcript.pyannote[104].end 390.02909375
transcript.pyannote[105].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[105].start 390.50159375
transcript.pyannote[105].end 392.03721875
transcript.pyannote[106].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[106].start 392.50971875
transcript.pyannote[106].end 394.28159375
transcript.pyannote[107].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[107].start 394.58534375
transcript.pyannote[107].end 399.04034375
transcript.pyannote[108].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[108].start 399.20909375
transcript.pyannote[108].end 403.29284375
transcript.pyannote[109].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[109].start 404.54159375
transcript.pyannote[109].end 410.29596875
transcript.pyannote[110].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[110].start 410.80221875
transcript.pyannote[110].end 416.21909375
transcript.pyannote[111].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[111].start 416.55659375
transcript.pyannote[111].end 418.22721875
transcript.pyannote[112].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[112].start 418.80096875
transcript.pyannote[112].end 423.96471875
transcript.pyannote[113].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[113].start 422.56409375
transcript.pyannote[113].end 430.41096875
transcript.pyannote[114].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[114].start 424.03221875
transcript.pyannote[114].end 424.13346875
transcript.pyannote[115].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[115].start 431.03534375
transcript.pyannote[115].end 432.65534375
transcript.pyannote[116].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[116].start 433.17846875
transcript.pyannote[116].end 434.20784375
transcript.pyannote[117].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[117].start 434.69721875
transcript.pyannote[117].end 439.97909375
transcript.pyannote[118].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[118].start 440.23221875
transcript.pyannote[118].end 442.56096875
transcript.pyannote[119].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[119].start 443.18534375
transcript.pyannote[119].end 444.75471875
transcript.pyannote[120].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[120].start 445.36221875
transcript.pyannote[120].end 445.95284375
transcript.pyannote[121].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[121].start 446.35784375
transcript.pyannote[121].end 448.34909375
transcript.pyannote[122].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[122].start 449.00721875
transcript.pyannote[122].end 450.69471875
transcript.pyannote[123].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[123].start 451.43721875
transcript.pyannote[123].end 452.77034375
transcript.pyannote[124].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[124].start 452.93909375
transcript.pyannote[124].end 455.41971875
transcript.pyannote[125].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[125].start 455.53784375
transcript.pyannote[125].end 463.82346875
transcript.pyannote[126].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[126].start 464.16096875
transcript.pyannote[126].end 466.92846875
transcript.pyannote[127].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[127].start 467.16471875
transcript.pyannote[127].end 478.67346875
transcript.pyannote[128].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[128].start 479.55096875
transcript.pyannote[128].end 481.17096875
transcript.pyannote[129].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[129].start 481.32284375
transcript.pyannote[129].end 483.09471875
transcript.pyannote[130].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[130].start 483.41534375
transcript.pyannote[130].end 488.41034375
transcript.pyannote[131].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[131].start 488.83221875
transcript.pyannote[131].end 490.55346875
transcript.pyannote[132].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[132].start 491.00909375
transcript.pyannote[132].end 497.06721875
transcript.pyannote[133].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[133].start 495.80159375
transcript.pyannote[133].end 506.26409375
transcript.pyannote[134].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[134].start 506.95596875
transcript.pyannote[134].end 508.22159375
transcript.pyannote[135].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[135].start 508.40721875
transcript.pyannote[135].end 510.58409375
transcript.pyannote[136].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[136].start 510.98909375
transcript.pyannote[136].end 518.39721875
transcript.pyannote[137].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[137].start 519.79784375
transcript.pyannote[137].end 522.88596875
transcript.pyannote[138].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[138].start 523.44284375
transcript.pyannote[138].end 526.58159375
transcript.pyannote[139].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[139].start 527.44221875
transcript.pyannote[139].end 528.40409375
transcript.pyannote[140].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[140].start 528.87659375
transcript.pyannote[140].end 530.02409375
transcript.pyannote[141].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[141].start 530.34471875
transcript.pyannote[141].end 530.76659375
transcript.pyannote[142].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[142].start 531.84659375
transcript.pyannote[142].end 533.56784375
transcript.pyannote[143].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[143].start 533.70284375
transcript.pyannote[143].end 534.91784375
transcript.pyannote[144].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[144].start 535.40721875
transcript.pyannote[144].end 538.20846875
transcript.pyannote[145].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[145].start 538.88346875
transcript.pyannote[145].end 542.29221875
transcript.pyannote[146].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[146].start 540.19971875
transcript.pyannote[146].end 543.22034375
transcript.pyannote[147].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[147].start 543.33846875
transcript.pyannote[147].end 551.94471875
transcript.pyannote[148].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[148].start 549.04221875
transcript.pyannote[148].end 549.83534375
transcript.pyannote[149].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[149].start 551.48909375
transcript.pyannote[149].end 553.17659375
transcript.pyannote[150].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[150].start 553.68284375
transcript.pyannote[150].end 561.29346875
transcript.pyannote[151].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[151].start 561.49596875
transcript.pyannote[151].end 561.98534375
transcript.pyannote[152].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[152].start 563.20034375
transcript.pyannote[152].end 566.17034375
transcript.pyannote[153].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[153].start 566.96346875
transcript.pyannote[153].end 567.77346875
transcript.pyannote[154].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[154].start 568.12784375
transcript.pyannote[154].end 591.73596875
transcript.pyannote[155].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[155].start 592.25909375
transcript.pyannote[155].end 593.91284375
transcript.pyannote[156].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[156].start 594.19971875
transcript.pyannote[156].end 596.95034375
transcript.pyannote[157].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[157].start 597.45659375
transcript.pyannote[157].end 600.51096875
transcript.pyannote[158].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[158].start 600.84846875
transcript.pyannote[158].end 601.28721875
transcript.pyannote[159].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[159].start 601.59096875
transcript.pyannote[159].end 604.13909375
transcript.pyannote[160].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[160].start 605.06721875
transcript.pyannote[160].end 606.53534375
transcript.pyannote[161].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[161].start 606.68721875
transcript.pyannote[161].end 607.42971875
transcript.pyannote[162].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[162].start 607.88534375
transcript.pyannote[162].end 611.76659375
transcript.pyannote[163].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[163].start 612.10409375
transcript.pyannote[163].end 616.55909375
transcript.pyannote[164].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[164].start 616.81221875
transcript.pyannote[164].end 619.95096875
transcript.pyannote[165].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[165].start 620.44034375
transcript.pyannote[165].end 623.79846875
transcript.pyannote[166].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[166].start 624.35534375
transcript.pyannote[166].end 629.60346875
transcript.pyannote[167].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[167].start 629.75534375
transcript.pyannote[167].end 631.44284375
transcript.pyannote[168].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[168].start 631.64534375
transcript.pyannote[168].end 635.59409375
transcript.pyannote[169].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[169].start 635.94846875
transcript.pyannote[169].end 638.83409375
transcript.pyannote[170].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[170].start 639.82971875
transcript.pyannote[170].end 642.15846875
transcript.pyannote[171].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[171].start 642.78284375
transcript.pyannote[171].end 650.89971875
transcript.pyannote[172].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[172].start 647.00159375
transcript.pyannote[172].end 647.54159375
transcript.pyannote[173].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[173].start 649.24596875
transcript.pyannote[173].end 649.71846875
transcript.pyannote[174].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[174].start 651.22034375
transcript.pyannote[174].end 657.90284375
transcript.pyannote[175].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[175].start 658.08846875
transcript.pyannote[175].end 666.28971875
transcript.pyannote[176].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[176].start 666.74534375
transcript.pyannote[176].end 668.43284375
transcript.pyannote[177].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[177].start 668.77034375
transcript.pyannote[177].end 669.46221875
transcript.pyannote[178].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[178].start 669.85034375
transcript.pyannote[178].end 677.73096875
transcript.pyannote[179].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[179].start 678.27096875
transcript.pyannote[179].end 680.63346875
transcript.pyannote[180].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[180].start 681.17346875
transcript.pyannote[180].end 685.05471875
transcript.pyannote[181].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[181].start 685.29096875
transcript.pyannote[181].end 685.93221875
transcript.pyannote[182].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[182].start 686.23596875
transcript.pyannote[182].end 689.34096875
transcript.pyannote[183].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[183].start 689.74596875
transcript.pyannote[183].end 691.14659375
transcript.pyannote[184].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[184].start 692.56409375
transcript.pyannote[184].end 693.30659375
transcript.pyannote[185].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[185].start 693.57659375
transcript.pyannote[185].end 694.50471875
transcript.pyannote[186].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[186].start 694.90971875
transcript.pyannote[186].end 695.71971875
transcript.pyannote[187].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[187].start 696.10784375
transcript.pyannote[187].end 702.21659375
transcript.pyannote[188].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[188].start 702.63846875
transcript.pyannote[188].end 707.59971875
transcript.pyannote[189].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[189].start 707.80221875
transcript.pyannote[189].end 717.57284375
transcript.pyannote[190].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[190].start 718.33221875
transcript.pyannote[190].end 728.62596875
transcript.pyannote[191].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[191].start 724.94721875
transcript.pyannote[191].end 725.52096875
transcript.pyannote[192].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[192].start 727.69784375
transcript.pyannote[192].end 734.24534375
transcript.pyannote[193].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[193].start 734.75159375
transcript.pyannote[193].end 753.88784375
transcript.pyannote[194].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[194].start 754.34346875
transcript.pyannote[194].end 759.20346875
transcript.pyannote[195].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[195].start 759.74346875
transcript.pyannote[195].end 762.20721875
transcript.pyannote[196].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[196].start 762.24096875
transcript.pyannote[196].end 766.76346875
transcript.pyannote[197].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[197].start 767.35409375
transcript.pyannote[197].end 767.94471875
transcript.pyannote[198].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[198].start 768.21471875
transcript.pyannote[198].end 769.15971875
transcript.pyannote[199].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[199].start 769.95284375
transcript.pyannote[199].end 770.79659375
transcript.pyannote[200].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[200].start 771.74159375
transcript.pyannote[200].end 773.96909375
transcript.pyannote[201].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[201].start 774.52596875
transcript.pyannote[201].end 775.80846875
transcript.pyannote[202].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[202].start 776.85471875
transcript.pyannote[202].end 783.84096875
transcript.pyannote[203].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[203].start 785.07284375
transcript.pyannote[203].end 793.91534375
transcript.pyannote[204].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[204].start 791.31659375
transcript.pyannote[204].end 792.24471875
transcript.pyannote[205].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[205].start 794.06721875
transcript.pyannote[205].end 800.58096875
transcript.pyannote[206].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[206].start 794.11784375
transcript.pyannote[206].end 794.53971875
transcript.pyannote[207].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[207].start 799.70346875
transcript.pyannote[207].end 805.12034375
transcript.pyannote[208].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[208].start 801.44159375
transcript.pyannote[208].end 801.89721875
transcript.pyannote[209].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[209].start 805.18784375
transcript.pyannote[209].end 824.66159375
transcript.pyannote[210].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[210].start 813.08534375
transcript.pyannote[210].end 813.37221875
transcript.pyannote[211].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[211].start 824.81346875
transcript.pyannote[211].end 828.35721875
transcript.pyannote[212].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[212].start 829.08284375
transcript.pyannote[212].end 832.32284375
transcript.pyannote[213].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[213].start 832.76159375
transcript.pyannote[213].end 833.87534375
transcript.pyannote[214].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[214].start 834.07784375
transcript.pyannote[214].end 841.60409375
transcript.pyannote[215].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[215].start 840.96284375
transcript.pyannote[215].end 841.40159375
transcript.pyannote[216].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[216].start 842.26221875
transcript.pyannote[216].end 844.50659375
transcript.pyannote[217].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[217].start 845.65409375
transcript.pyannote[217].end 851.44221875
transcript.pyannote[218].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[218].start 851.64471875
transcript.pyannote[218].end 856.67346875
transcript.pyannote[219].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[219].start 857.78721875
transcript.pyannote[219].end 862.39409375
transcript.pyannote[220].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[220].start 863.11971875
transcript.pyannote[220].end 863.45721875
transcript.pyannote[221].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[221].start 863.49096875
transcript.pyannote[221].end 869.24534375
transcript.pyannote[222].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[222].start 871.16909375
transcript.pyannote[222].end 872.89034375
transcript.pyannote[223].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[223].start 871.82721875
transcript.pyannote[223].end 872.28284375
transcript.pyannote[224].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[224].start 872.89034375
transcript.pyannote[224].end 874.27409375
transcript.pyannote[225].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[225].start 872.90721875
transcript.pyannote[225].end 872.99159375
transcript.pyannote[226].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[226].start 874.74659375
transcript.pyannote[226].end 883.20096875
transcript.pyannote[227].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[227].start 877.07534375
transcript.pyannote[227].end 877.17659375
transcript.pyannote[228].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[228].start 877.36221875
transcript.pyannote[228].end 877.49721875
transcript.pyannote[229].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[229].start 883.55534375
transcript.pyannote[229].end 886.64346875
transcript.pyannote[230].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[230].start 887.21721875
transcript.pyannote[230].end 889.71471875
transcript.pyannote[231].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[231].start 890.17034375
transcript.pyannote[231].end 893.93346875
transcript.pyannote[232].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[232].start 895.58721875
transcript.pyannote[232].end 896.09346875
transcript.pyannote[233].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[233].start 896.43096875
transcript.pyannote[233].end 902.45534375
transcript.pyannote[234].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[234].start 900.59909375
transcript.pyannote[234].end 912.54659375
transcript.pyannote[235].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[235].start 913.22159375
transcript.pyannote[235].end 914.99346875
transcript.pyannote[236].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[236].start 915.63471875
transcript.pyannote[236].end 925.50659375
transcript.pyannote[237].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[237].start 926.45159375
transcript.pyannote[237].end 930.43409375
transcript.pyannote[238].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[238].start 930.65346875
transcript.pyannote[238].end 936.37409375
transcript.pyannote[239].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[239].start 933.26909375
transcript.pyannote[239].end 933.62346875
transcript.pyannote[240].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[240].start 934.73721875
transcript.pyannote[240].end 943.76534375
transcript.pyannote[241].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[241].start 944.84534375
transcript.pyannote[241].end 948.37221875
transcript.pyannote[242].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[242].start 949.04721875
transcript.pyannote[242].end 955.89846875
transcript.pyannote[243].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[243].start 956.38784375
transcript.pyannote[243].end 961.87221875
transcript.pyannote[244].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[244].start 962.15909375
transcript.pyannote[244].end 971.96346875
transcript.pyannote[245].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[245].start 969.48284375
transcript.pyannote[245].end 973.49909375
transcript.pyannote[246].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[246].start 974.41034375
transcript.pyannote[246].end 975.86159375
transcript.pyannote[247].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[247].start 975.92909375
transcript.pyannote[247].end 996.12846875
transcript.pyannote[248].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[248].start 999.14909375
transcript.pyannote[248].end 1000.48221875
transcript.pyannote[249].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[249].start 1001.15721875
transcript.pyannote[249].end 1014.11721875
transcript.pyannote[250].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[250].start 1015.01159375
transcript.pyannote[250].end 1015.48409375
transcript.pyannote[251].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[251].start 1016.29409375
transcript.pyannote[251].end 1030.19909375
transcript.pyannote[252].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[252].start 1031.63346875
transcript.pyannote[252].end 1032.24096875
transcript.pyannote[253].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[253].start 1031.85284375
transcript.pyannote[253].end 1033.27034375
transcript.pyannote[254].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[254].start 1034.36721875
transcript.pyannote[254].end 1037.47221875
transcript.pyannote[255].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[255].start 1036.62846875
transcript.pyannote[255].end 1039.22721875
transcript.pyannote[256].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[256].start 1038.90659375
transcript.pyannote[256].end 1046.60159375
transcript.pyannote[257].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[257].start 1044.00284375
transcript.pyannote[257].end 1063.91534375
transcript.pyannote[258].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[258].start 1064.77596875
transcript.pyannote[258].end 1068.47159375
transcript.pyannote[259].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[259].start 1069.02846875
transcript.pyannote[259].end 1070.56409375
transcript.pyannote[260].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[260].start 1071.12096875
transcript.pyannote[260].end 1077.66846875
transcript.pyannote[261].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[261].start 1078.10721875
transcript.pyannote[261].end 1084.77284375
transcript.pyannote[262].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[262].start 1085.07659375
transcript.pyannote[262].end 1087.23659375
transcript.pyannote[263].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[263].start 1087.59096875
transcript.pyannote[263].end 1096.02846875
transcript.pyannote[264].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[264].start 1096.83846875
transcript.pyannote[264].end 1114.75971875
transcript.pyannote[265].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[265].start 1115.89034375
transcript.pyannote[265].end 1116.29534375
transcript.pyannote[266].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[266].start 1116.88596875
transcript.pyannote[266].end 1117.54409375
transcript.pyannote[267].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[267].start 1117.81409375
transcript.pyannote[267].end 1118.38784375
transcript.pyannote[268].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[268].start 1119.18096875
transcript.pyannote[268].end 1120.02471875
transcript.pyannote[269].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[269].start 1120.24409375
transcript.pyannote[269].end 1121.88096875
transcript.pyannote[270].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[270].start 1122.10034375
transcript.pyannote[270].end 1123.87221875
transcript.pyannote[271].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[271].start 1124.02409375
transcript.pyannote[271].end 1132.98471875
transcript.pyannote[272].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[272].start 1132.98471875
transcript.pyannote[272].end 1135.90409375
transcript.pyannote[273].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[273].start 1134.94221875
transcript.pyannote[273].end 1137.55784375
transcript.pyannote[274].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[274].start 1137.18659375
transcript.pyannote[274].end 1143.31221875
transcript.pyannote[275].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[275].start 1143.31221875
transcript.pyannote[275].end 1143.41346875
transcript.pyannote[276].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[276].start 1143.48096875
transcript.pyannote[276].end 1163.76471875
transcript.pyannote[277].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[277].start 1163.27534375
transcript.pyannote[277].end 1165.92471875
transcript.pyannote[278].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[278].start 1165.40159375
transcript.pyannote[278].end 1171.35846875
transcript.pyannote[279].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[279].start 1171.49346875
transcript.pyannote[279].end 1171.86471875
transcript.pyannote[280].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[280].start 1172.55659375
transcript.pyannote[280].end 1174.68284375
transcript.pyannote[281].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[281].start 1175.30721875
transcript.pyannote[281].end 1180.99409375
transcript.pyannote[282].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[282].start 1181.31471875
transcript.pyannote[282].end 1184.94284375
transcript.pyannote[283].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[283].start 1185.29721875
transcript.pyannote[283].end 1189.58346875
transcript.pyannote[284].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[284].start 1186.63034375
transcript.pyannote[284].end 1187.01846875
transcript.pyannote[285].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[285].start 1187.72721875
transcript.pyannote[285].end 1214.44034375
transcript.pyannote[286].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[286].start 1214.71034375
transcript.pyannote[286].end 1215.87471875
transcript.pyannote[287].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[287].start 1215.57096875
transcript.pyannote[287].end 1215.63846875
transcript.pyannote[288].speaker SPEAKER_01
transcript.pyannote[288].start 1216.12784375
transcript.pyannote[288].end 1219.18221875
transcript.pyannote[289].speaker SPEAKER_00
transcript.pyannote[289].start 1224.61596875
transcript.pyannote[289].end 1224.97034375
transcript.whisperx[0].start 4.256
transcript.whisperx[0].end 8.56
transcript.whisperx[0].text 謝謝院長我想請柯院長麻煩再請被提名人柯院長備詢院長好我想今天大家都會一樣的問題我也想同樣的問題要再跟您做個探討我知道你來自司法界很難得考試院有這樣的提名人
transcript.whisperx[1].start 27.557
transcript.whisperx[1].end 46.388
transcript.whisperx[1].text 那當然在檢察署包括剛剛講的死刑也好其實跟司法行政還是有很多的關係同樣的考試委員、考試院擔負了台灣重要的公務人員的不管是任用、最後的保障甚至是退休所以這個勞動部的這個
transcript.whisperx[2].start 50.817
transcript.whisperx[2].end 77.963
transcript.whisperx[2].text 不管您從您的角度來看這一次是不是關關相護到關了殺人因為整個內部的情形因為我不曉得他事先是不是有申訴不受理他有申訴但是都一直在機關裡面沒有出來也沒有找到外部委員他就是一個有機制沒有被落實的非常好的案例我覺得就是很遺憾的就是
transcript.whisperx[3].start 80.962
transcript.whisperx[3].end 101.193
transcript.whisperx[3].text 這位同仁會發展到放棄自己的生命應該之前應該有一些徵兆出來求助無門看到相關的人大家沒有舉手莫不作聲縱容了這個首長他濫權絕對不是一天
transcript.whisperx[4].start 101.974
transcript.whisperx[4].end 126.266
transcript.whisperx[4].text 而且他的霸凌已經是常態所以這整個機制我今天就說嘛多年前我們在社會上有一個很嚴重的事情叫做紅重囚事件他讓我們改革了軍隊改革了相關的法治多年後我們竟然在2024的臺灣民主法治的社會我們又在討論一個公務員為什麼被霸凌致死他一定不會是
transcript.whisperx[5].start 127.811
transcript.whisperx[5].end 146.962
transcript.whisperx[5].text 馬上發生他一定是一個長期累積沒有辦法求助最後他知道他沒有希望所以他結束自己的生命一個公務員為什麼要用生命去換取體制的改革這是我們今天要深深思考的所以我想問一下
transcript.whisperx[6].start 148.851
transcript.whisperx[6].end 171.758
transcript.whisperx[6].text 各院長我們都是來自我也當過首長我相信對相關的法制您都很清楚公務系統裡面現在有沒有相關的機制可以防止這些事情發生有吧都有其實我覺得就公務公務員要保障法有服務法有各種法但是就少了霸凌法對嗎
transcript.whisperx[7].start 172.711
transcript.whisperx[7].end 194.044
transcript.whisperx[7].text 公務人員本來就應該負相關的警戒或者是行政責任那如果是已經涉及到刑法那當然還有刑事責任所以我們一直都是一個問題是我們有規定但是沒落實有調查機制但是調查報告可以關關相護最嚴重的是他還可以
transcript.whisperx[8].start 195.439
transcript.whisperx[8].end 213.735
transcript.whisperx[8].text 壓在他的機關高達數個月甚至如果沒有這個公務員的死亡到今天為止可能這個案子還暗無天日所以重點是考試院主管的法規有公務員保障法有公務員考機法還有相關的安全衛生防護辦法看起來一點都沒有作用對嗎
transcript.whisperx[9].start 215.419
transcript.whisperx[9].end 237.704
transcript.whisperx[9].text 我想之前院長被提名他也承諾是這是你們要做的這也是中華民國體制上面要改的有辦法要落實第二個現在我們對於所謂的公務人員大家都在爭取尤其是警消我們在爭取公會公會的部分主要是團結權第二個他有協商權那最重要他有一個爭議權這個勞動三權我看過您的相關的
transcript.whisperx[10].start 242.485
transcript.whisperx[10].end 263.043
transcript.whisperx[10].text 問卷您好像不太贊成入法是嗎對於公務人員的部分我覺得不是不贊成入法而是說我們現在有一個公務人員我們有相關的法你贊不贊成至少錦霄應該有相關的保護因為他有特殊的狀況
transcript.whisperx[11].start 263.703
transcript.whisperx[11].end 282.535
transcript.whisperx[11].text 是 因為根據現在現在考試院已經提出修正草案修正草案但是大家都不滿意啦修正草案裡面有警消人員的特種公務人員協會但是就是不成立公務會不給罷免權罷工權這樣其實是不完整的權利
transcript.whisperx[12].start 284.279
transcript.whisperx[12].end 306.49
transcript.whisperx[12].text 我想罷工權的給予這個其實在各國的法制上還可以再討論我同意但是我的意思是說如果我們要做勞動的三法的精神我相信考試院有這個責任去釐清現在基層的需求好嗎是第二個部分是考試院一直是我們現在大家的問題這個問題在哪裡
transcript.whisperx[13].start 309.404
transcript.whisperx[13].end 325.314
transcript.whisperx[13].text 這個問題我們去研究了一下憲法保障憲法對於考試院的執掌講得很清楚要考試任用權序考積最後保障升遷包括退休養老我想問一下柯院長您的理解考試院跟考試委員功能在哪裡
transcript.whisperx[14].start 327.917
transcript.whisperx[14].end 355.634
transcript.whisperx[14].text 我還沒有去了據我了解考試院它是合一制那兩部一會那藉著院會的形式來推動所以你對考試委員跟考試院的功能執掌還不很清楚然後考試委員有時候他還要兼任因為現在剩下七位委員沒關係我覺得你對他的認知是你們要保障公務員還是要考核公務員還是要禁用公務員然後不管他的退場
transcript.whisperx[15].start 357.633
transcript.whisperx[15].end 382.831
transcript.whisperx[15].text 我想這個法律上我關於這些法治事項我就講這個案子好了這個案子 謝宜庸的案子很清楚的是我們在憲法上面考試院有這些執掌從禁用開始到保障到退休但是謝宜庸的案子裡面行政機關用公務員考機法把它兩大過免職然後運用的是公務員考機法這是行政單位的權責
transcript.whisperx[16].start 384.272
transcript.whisperx[16].end 402.846
transcript.whisperx[16].text 公務人員懲戒法是將來會交給監察院跟司法院也就是說發生類似的案子考試院一點角色都沒有發生這麼大的霸凌案件考試院一點聲音也沒有這不是很奇怪嗎我們中華民國國父在
transcript.whisperx[17].start 404.885
transcript.whisperx[17].end 417.95
transcript.whisperx[17].text 創建三民主義的時候五權憲法的時候他現在的考試院的執掌顯然被這幾個單位都分割了也就是考試院目前為止只管禁用 不管退場你同意嗎
transcript.whisperx[18].start 422.637
transcript.whisperx[18].end 448.377
transcript.whisperx[18].text 考試院如果有趣的話我希望考試院要管退場今天的問題就在於退場的機制在哪裡在原機關如果真的嚴重的才會到所謂的工程會才會到司法院所以司法權監察權都已經剝奪了考試權你們管的後面的權利也就是考試院目前的執照已經離原來的五權憲法很遠了
transcript.whisperx[19].start 449.063
transcript.whisperx[19].end 450.395
transcript.whisperx[19].text 我覺得這個部分如果
transcript.whisperx[20].start 451.482
transcript.whisperx[20].end 478.21
transcript.whisperx[20].text 柯院長可以的話去爭取一下考試院在所謂的人事禁用還有人事退場上面的權責否則看起來就是考試院只能眼巴巴的看著這些機關不做事然後被罵考試院一起挨罵但是真正不處理的是那個行政機關第二個接下來到監察院到司法院就像很多的委員說的如果他去申訴他成功了他還可以回任公務員
transcript.whisperx[21].start 479.768
transcript.whisperx[21].end 505.34
transcript.whisperx[21].text 這個公平跟正義我相信考試院不應該就放任他繼續能夠回到我們的公務系統繼續傷害其他的公務人員對吧這個可以法治上是不是要在明擺的規定限制這種好這個案子最特別的是剛剛很多委員在問他其實就是針對謝宜蓉被處分的他是用所謂的圖謀不法利益嚴刑不檢這個比較像
transcript.whisperx[22].start 506.994
transcript.whisperx[22].end 530.461
transcript.whisperx[22].text 但是裡面有一條考試法12條第3項第6款脅迫公然侮辱誣告長官情節重大的時候也可以計兩大過免職對吧但是這個條款非常非常的威權要脅迫公然侮辱誣告長官情節重大才會被免職所以
transcript.whisperx[23].start 532.172
transcript.whisperx[23].end 552.612
transcript.whisperx[23].text 脅迫公然侮辱部署同仁不屬於考機法的處罰範圍你覺得合理嗎這樣聽起來是不合理是這個是應該是我們應該是我們威權時代吧或者皇權時代的事的所以如果可以的話您可以承諾這一條條文是不是該修啊是我們可以再檢討
transcript.whisperx[24].start 553.735
transcript.whisperx[24].end 565.957
transcript.whisperx[24].text 如果入罵同仁、入罵部署、情節重大也是用這一條今天謝以榮他可能就不可能翻案對吧好,我希望院長你可以說到做到
transcript.whisperx[25].start 567.011
transcript.whisperx[25].end 591.507
transcript.whisperx[25].text 接下去我們要講的是公務員的禁用剛剛講了考試院既然管禁用但是考試院管的禁用還是停留在我認為停留在我們的科舉時代為什麼因為我們需要考試是公平的是公開的所以由考試院還有相關的考試機關來決定用人的考試保持所謂的中立性跟獨立性
transcript.whisperx[26].start 592.327
transcript.whisperx[26].end 615.826
transcript.whisperx[26].text 可是現在很多的機關就像今天勞動部發生的事情一樣有很多機關的用人他從來沒有看過他將來會分發到他這裡的人是誰也就是我們的考試沒有做事先的用人機關並沒有參與任何考試的過程甚至不知道誰會分發到他的這裡來
transcript.whisperx[27].start 616.906
transcript.whisperx[27].end 641.277
transcript.whisperx[27].text 所以很多的考試院在國家原力資源論壇裡面一直在討論說要不要增加所謂的口試院長你來自司法界我知道我們的司法官是需要口試的對吧對我們當律師不用口試啊但是考司法官要口試曾經有過考上司法官筆試過口試不過的因為他就可以做一些汰換對吧
transcript.whisperx[28].start 642.85
transcript.whisperx[28].end 650.583
transcript.whisperx[28].text 因為在接受考試前第20他本來就是依照需用的有多加百分之二十所以就會討厭他有一些
transcript.whisperx[29].start 651.257
transcript.whisperx[29].end 680.481
transcript.whisperx[29].text 沒錯第一是資格就是基本的能力第二就是我用人機關需要的人才這是所有民間機關的人力資源部門會做的事但是台灣的考試院非常非常重視公平所以用人機關從來不參與考試結果最後就是等他受訓完成分發才知道他是誰我們很多的學者說這是一種相親啊結婚的那一天才看到對方是誰啊
transcript.whisperx[30].start 681.261
transcript.whisperx[30].end 690.755
transcript.whisperx[30].text 所以發生霸凌事件也不會是偶然為什麼因為所有的機關都已經是一個成熟的環境新人分發進來他只能
transcript.whisperx[31].start 693.672
transcript.whisperx[31].end 717.35
transcript.whisperx[31].text 任命三年這三年長官對他不好他也只能忍氣吞聲就像剛剛講的他可能必須默不作聲然後等待三年的時間所以院長你覺得增加考試的機率是不是夠讓幼兒園機關能夠參與找到他適用的人我們是要考出讓他能夠用的人而不是只是用那些會考試的人
transcript.whisperx[32].start 719.794
transcript.whisperx[32].end 733.941
transcript.whisperx[32].text 據我從考試院那邊看到的資料我知道他們這幾年也其實要再增加用人機關參與口試用人機關參與口試非常的少你看一下這個表格第一階段、第二階段從美國、日本
transcript.whisperx[33].start 735.581
transcript.whisperx[33].end 753.649
transcript.whisperx[33].text 韓國或者是中國大陸其實都是第一階段、第二階段都有所謂的考試韓國是到第三階段那中華民國一律是比試第二階段有考試的只有少數特定的考試也就是說我們的傭人機關其實根本不知道將來誰會到他這裡來而他也不知道
transcript.whisperx[34].start 754.389
transcript.whisperx[34].end 783.562
transcript.whisperx[34].text 那些人可能也不知道這個機關它的相關的文化所以最後就會發生這種水土不服然後互相誤會、誤解甚至最後發生這種霸凌的事件所以院長我們不希望公務員分發變成相親啊變成盲婚啊所以現在的全區部長一直說希望能夠增加面試如果你是考試委員這件事情你會怎麼做
transcript.whisperx[35].start 785.394
transcript.whisperx[35].end 809.383
transcript.whisperx[35].text 我想增加面試這的確是我所看到的很多用人尤其在國外很多用人機關的一個趨勢這我同意那在面試當中那這個用人機關要參與我想這個我如果有機會我想很會考試的人不一定能夠適應那個工作或者是那個環境所以考試是公平的
transcript.whisperx[36].start 810.063
transcript.whisperx[36].end 827.964
transcript.whisperx[36].text 需要是要看用人機關的需求他必須要在用人之前先做參與甚至在用人之際他可以去選取他所適用的人好嗎口試當然很多人都說因為臺灣有非常多的觀說文化觀說文化不足口試又會變成另外一種
transcript.whisperx[37].start 829.145
transcript.whisperx[37].end 856.163
transcript.whisperx[37].text 公平的對待所以我們為了公平取消了口試但是我們用了口試就可能被關說這一點可能是需要設計一個更完善的機制重點是我知道您在法務部也好或在司法機制來說您在您的報告上面寫您參與了非常多的行政機關的法制作業還有行政救濟的相關的經驗
transcript.whisperx[38].start 857.813
transcript.whisperx[38].end 868.993
transcript.whisperx[38].text 一般機關都會有一個法制人員在每個機關裡面對吧幾乎大大小小不管是哪一個部門都會有一個法制人員在裡面全國大概有多少法制人員
transcript.whisperx[39].start 872.944
transcript.whisperx[39].end 893.235
transcript.whisperx[39].text 全國一千多人全國的公務員有29萬人也就是說我們的法制人員占了1435人只占了不到0.48%但是每個機關裡面的法制人員你覺得除了法制人員以外的行政人員高普考進去的公務員他們的法學素養夠不夠
transcript.whisperx[40].start 900.795
transcript.whisperx[40].end 912.389
transcript.whisperx[40].text 其實都不太夠,因為他們都沒有考法律所以他們可能是做採購,要修修採購法但是大部分非法治人員的法學素養其實是很低的
transcript.whisperx[41].start 913.391
transcript.whisperx[41].end 925.067
transcript.whisperx[41].text 所以我們的問題在於我看到案子裡面您也說現在跟法律院有關的機關有關公職律師的制度我想問說既然有法治人員為什麼要推公職律師
transcript.whisperx[42].start 926.776
transcript.whisperx[42].end 955.692
transcript.whisperx[42].text 我想公職律師據我的了解他們是希望公職律師因為他有訴訟的經驗沒錯而且公職律師對於法學專業可能比一般的法治院他是行政法治不太一樣的跟訴訟實務不太一樣對吧律師他就看他的專業了好所以你覺得這個你的認知公職律師政府推動的目的是什麼希望做到什麼成果
transcript.whisperx[43].start 956.866
transcript.whisperx[43].end 970.182
transcript.whisperx[43].text 我覺得應該是能夠讓機關的跟法制相關的業務能夠更接近實務那尤其是現在很多機關必須處理跟訴訟有關的我知道這個案子很好笑
transcript.whisperx[44].start 974.705
transcript.whisperx[44].end 995.903
transcript.whisperx[44].text 在12年推出來我們做律師的看到都蠻高興的因為為什麼?全世界都有各國先進國家都有公職律師美國有將近12萬人英國有將近2000人新加坡至少有380人香港有419人中華民國0人為什麼?我現在跟您說的很有趣
transcript.whisperx[45].start 999.121
transcript.whisperx[45].end 1013.908
transcript.whisperx[45].text 很有趣的部分就是在我們2012年推出來的時候行政院告訴立法院說我們至少有27個機關需要73個公職律師推出來之後到現在整整兩...快一年多了
transcript.whisperx[46].start 1015.026
transcript.whisperx[46].end 1030.471
transcript.whisperx[46].text 只有建保署跟國防部各要了兩個他們在修編制表其他的機關沒有人要來申請公職律師沒有人要甩考試院更沒有人要甩行政院的新政策到底怎麼回事對這個的理解怎麼樣
transcript.whisperx[47].start 1034.734
transcript.whisperx[47].end 1062.141
transcript.whisperx[47].text 我也很訝異說沒有人要申請沒有人要開編制因為照理說應該很多機關他碰到一些訴訟案件要需要人代理的時候那我現在就告訴你了我剛剛講的這些國家他佔職業律師的比例從美國是高達18%最低的香港有4.7%中華民國0人如果這兩個機關弄壞就變成4人我們有1萬多位律師的話我們可能0點百分之0.0幾重點是
transcript.whisperx[48].start 1064.907
transcript.whisperx[48].end 1093.96
transcript.whisperx[48].text 是沒有人要做而是沒有機關要開圈這個問題才是問題我現在要說的就是公職律師跟法治院的角色的差異在哪裡第一個就是我們考選不當時的說法法治體系是在書院會或者相關的法治單位做法律的研擬跟諮商行政增送公職律師要在第一線的業務單位瞭解業務核心協助機關依法行政這兩個是不一樣的
transcript.whisperx[49].start 1094.42
transcript.whisperx[49].end 1118.181
transcript.whisperx[49].text 但我很遺憾的告訴你財政部在我質詢他的時候問他說你們要開幾個公職律師因為你們一天到晚有所謂的土地訴訟啊、欠稅的訴訟他說不用我們的法治人員就夠了不用公職律師大不了用政府採購委外找民間律師開口合約一案子兩萬五萬塊就搞定院長可不可笑政府
transcript.whisperx[50].start 1119.209
transcript.whisperx[50].end 1142.301
transcript.whisperx[50].text 自己的部門不支持自己的政策您當考試委員你有什麼感想我想如果有機會當考試委員我想應該會去了解原因是什麼是不是因為編制那個緣額的問題沒辦法解決沒錯這就是公務系統最痛苦的事還有第二個就是如果我們只開了一個月六七萬塊的錢大概也不會有律師來啦
transcript.whisperx[51].start 1144.042
transcript.whisperx[51].end 1170.736
transcript.whisperx[51].text 這兩個是如果我們要讓臺灣的每一個機關都能有一定的法治概念就不應該把公職律師排除在外第二個讓所有的法治人員都具有律師的資格這件事情可能也是另外一個方法其實現在只有11%他們是固定已經具有律師資格了我知道很多法治人員都有考取律師資格最後一個問題就是我知道你在大力推動法律專業人員的資格跟任用條例的草案對嗎對
transcript.whisperx[52].start 1172.645
transcript.whisperx[52].end 1199.92
transcript.whisperx[52].text 四個考試合一檢、審、辯還有法制四試合一你認為就可以找回司法的公信力嗎我想當然這個要找回司法公信力沒有那麼簡單而且我覺得這個制度這四試合一裡面有一個很重要的精神他要做所謂的實習包括律師要實習司法官之前要實習然後實習呢我們現在的問題就在於司法界司法已經過勞了
transcript.whisperx[53].start 1201.081
transcript.whisperx[53].end 1202.422
transcript.whisperx[53].text 這一點我非常同意委員的看法這個實習的量能
IVOD_ID 157737
IVOD_URL https://ivod.ly.gov.tw/Play/Clip/1M/157737
日期 2024-12-03
影片種類 Clip
開始時間 2024-12-03T16:29:39+08:00
結束時間 2024-12-03T16:50:03+08:00
支援功能[0] ai-transcript